5G: So Where's the US?

Joanne Taaffe
News Analysis
Joanne Taaffe
9/24/2014

LONDON -- The 5G Huddle -- "Where is the US?" The question came from the floor of The 5G Huddle in London. Certainly Americans were conspicuous by their absence at an event that brought together participants from China, South Korea, Japan, India and much of Europe to discuss future 5G standards, frequency needs and possible usages.

"I don't think there is a unified [global] vision and they [the Americans] are reluctant to engage in the radio wireless infrastructure element," said Thibaut Kleiner, an advisor in the Cabinet of European Commission Vice President Neelie Kroes.

"There is research ongoing in the US -- we need to ensure they liaise with 5G vision," added Kleiner.

The structure of research in the US, combined with the global strength of the American computing industry, however, means the US is likely to play a different role to that of Asian or European countries in developing 5G systems and infrastructure. "Research in the US is mainly in universities ... in the area of millimeter wave propagation and modeling, and there is some in Intel, but there is not a counterpart to us in the US," said Dr Werner Mohr, chair of the 5GPPP.

Notably, "there is less (US) government intervention on spectrum. In Asia (governments) are really pushing it -- South Korea is investing US$1.5 billion as a single country," said Mohr.

This means US companies may miss out relative to other countries on developing patents relating to the air interface. However, 5G is set to be a broad church that will have to embrace new approaches to designing networks if it is to deliver operational cost savings and support new usages.

"5G is not only about radio access part -- it consists of core network and management and support systems," said Jan Färjh, vice president, head of standardization and industry, Ericsson AB (Nasdaq: ERIC).

And core networks are where US companies currently have an edge. "The US will come in on maybe not so much on radio side." Instead it is likely to play to its strengths "on the core networks and cloud networks, SDN," says Mohr.

Regardless of geographical strengths, the potential shifts in business models that 5G needs to underpin will require greater exchange with other industries on standards.

"If we look at ETSI and 3GPP the population has increased; 3GPP numbers 400 companies but they are telco companies. It's more of the same; we are lacking the energy (industry) and vehicle manufacturers; we have to be much more welcoming," said Adrian Scrase, CTO of European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) .

— Joanne Taaffe, special to Light Reading

(12)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
R Clark
R Clark
9/29/2014 | 10:16:43 PM
Huddle glut
One thing about the telecom industry: there's no shortage of huddles.

But I'm struck by this: "Research in the US is mainly in universities .."

ALU, Qualcomm, Intel? 

 

 

 
mendyk
mendyk
9/25/2014 | 9:38:56 AM
Re: IS-95G Anyone?
Maybe I'm not looking at the same post you are.
pdonegan67
pdonegan67
9/25/2014 | 9:24:41 AM
Re: IS-95G Anyone?
Not lack of attendance, no. The measuring stick is the quotes from 5G standards participants embedded in the article.
mendyk
mendyk
9/25/2014 | 8:53:01 AM
Re: The setting sun
Don't forget the mushy peas. Preferably out of the tin. Fortunately, there's plenty of bitter to wash it all down.
mendyk
mendyk
9/25/2014 | 8:50:01 AM
Re: IS-95G Anyone?
Should we be using the lack of attendance at something called the 5G Huddle as the measuring stick for engagement by US operators?
pdonegan67
pdonegan67
9/25/2014 | 7:09:00 AM
IS-95G Anyone?
Historical precedent suggests that the U.S should be wary of neglecting the rest of the world's efforts on mobile standards.

Being out of the blocks first with the 5G equivalent of IS-95 CDMA and CDMA 2000 might feel great at the outset three years hence. But if the rest of the world meanwhile congregates around something superior which takes longer to bring to market, that leadership would risk being short-lived. Think "The Hare and The Tortoise". 

In today's hyper-fast, web-scale, technology and market environment it may well be that historical precedent and children's fable just aren't relevant to 5G standardization. But unless U.S industry is somehow certain that these comparisons are worthless, then they're probably worth thinking about.
Gabriel Brown
Gabriel Brown
9/25/2014 | 4:26:56 AM
Re: What does it mean?
My impression is there is plenty of research ongoing in the U.S., but that there is less centralized co-ordination. The co-operation is more bilateral than multilateral, I'm told. 
Ariella
Ariella
9/24/2014 | 5:42:42 PM
Re: The setting sun
LOL @mendyk So fish and chips and such is not your thing?
mendyk
mendyk
9/24/2014 | 4:49:31 PM
Re: The setting sun
Well, there's the food for starters. And the cabs are really expensive. Then there's the anxiety of possibly running into a royal personage and not knowing whether to bow, curtsey, or break into the Sex Pistols' version of God Save the Queen. And then there's the food. I kid, of course. Some of my best friends are English.
Ariella
Ariella
9/24/2014 | 4:38:42 PM
Re: The setting sun
@MendyK more so than in NYC? For what reason?
Page 1 / 2   >   >>