The Wall Street analysts at Cowen found that the US wireless industry collectively lost 330,000 prepaid customers during the entirety of 2019, a first for the industry.

Mike Dano, Editorial Director, 5G & Mobile Strategies

March 9, 2020

4 Min Read
Why the US prepaid market is collapsing

US wireless network operators are recording record-setting losses of prepaid customers.

According to the Wall Street analysts at research firm Cowen, US wireless carriers collectively lost a record 238,000 prepaid customers during the fourth quarter of 2019, which the firm said eclipsed the previous record of 72,000 in customer losses during the third quarter of 2019. The firm said the industry collectively lost 330,000 prepaid customers during the entirety of 2019, which it noted is the first time ever that the wireless industry lost prepaid customers during the course of a full year.

Figure 1: The US prepaid market has been shrinking at a record-setting rate. (Source: Cowen) The US prepaid market has been shrinking at a record-setting rate.
(Source: Cowen)


Executives at some of the nation's top operators attribute the situation to a variety of factors, including improvements in the US economy and the lack of light between prepaid and postpaid plans.

"I think as the economy has improved the differences between the two products have gotten a little less as smartphones have worked their way into the prepaid base. Because of the cycle of maybe previous generation phones being available, we see customers now starting to opt into a postpaid construct," explained AT&T's John Stankey during his operator's quarterly conference call with analysts, according to a Seeking Alpha transcript of the event.

AT&T operates an extensive prepaid business through its Cricket Wireless brand. Prepaid customers typically pay for their service in advance – and it's therefore sometimes sold to customers with low credit scores – while postpaid customers typically pay for their service after they use it.

T-Mobile executives noted that the company's prepaid customers have increasingly been opting for the operator's postpaid plans.

"I think that postpaid has been growing at the expense of prepaid and that's probably great for the industry overall. So these things aren't really two different things. They are just two parts of one industry that has very positive trends that are fueled as much as anything else by the strong economic conditions that we're seeing. More people are qualifying for postpaid and therefore you're seeing postpaid grow at the expense of prepaid," explained T-Mobile's John Legere during his company's quarterly conference call with analysts, according to a transcript of the event by Seeking Alpha.

Legere also attributed some of the dynamic to the rise of cable operators in the mobile industry, noting customers who typically would have signed up for a prepaid plan are instead signing on to the mobile plans by Altice, Comcast and Charter Communications.

Legere's comments about prepaid are particularly notable considering T-Mobile recently laid off a number of employees within its Metro by T-Mobile prepaid business, as Light Reading previously reported.

Analyst Bill Ho with 556 Ventures said that part of the reason the prepaid industry has been shrinking is because the FCC has been working to modify its Lifeline program. That program is designed to provide government-subsidized wireless services to low income Americans, and operators ranging from Sprint to America Movil's TracFone sell Lifeline services. However, the FCC has reported widespread fraud in the program, and as a result companies like Sprint and TracFone have reduced the number of their Lifeline customers.

"That is a huge part," Ho said of the Lifeline changes in regards to a slowdown in prepaid.

Further, Ho explained, carriers have increasingly been working to acquire more postpaid customers because they typically spend more money than prepaid customers, and they don't change their plans very often. Thus, postpaid customers generally provide higher average revenues per user (ARPU) and lower churn (which is the percent of customers who leave a carrier).

So will the postpaid side of the wireless industry continue to grow? After all, according to Cowen, the nation's biggest wireless providers added 2.5 million postpaid phone customers in the fourth quarter of 2019, an 18% increase over the same period a year prior.

Some speculated that changes in the American economy could affect the growth of postpaid.

"Does that reverse itself, if we see some economic headwinds and maybe people become a little bit more careful about what they do? That's possible," warned AT&T's Stankey.

Mike Dano, Editorial Director, 5G & Mobile Strategies, Light Reading | @mikeddano

About the Author(s)

Mike Dano

Editorial Director, 5G & Mobile Strategies, Light Reading

Mike Dano is Light Reading's Editorial Director, 5G & Mobile Strategies. Mike can be reached at [email protected], @mikeddano or on LinkedIn.

Based in Denver, Mike has covered the wireless industry as a journalist for almost two decades, first at RCR Wireless News and then at FierceWireless and recalls once writing a story about the transition from black and white to color screens on cell phones.

Subscribe and receive the latest news from the industry.
Join 62,000+ members. Yes it's completely free.

You May Also Like