Killed By the Cloud

Mitch Wagner
3/31/2017

This morning I did not do something I've done nearly every morning for the past 20 years: Log in to a little online community called SFF.net to kibitz a bit with my pals there. The reason: SFF.net is gone. Killed by the cloud.

SFF.net was originally founded as a haven for science fiction and fantasy fans -- hence the acronym -- but it branched out into a community that shared a common interest in... well, each other. For 20 years, the members of SFF.net have talked and argued and supported each other, sometimes financially, and done the things that online communities do.

SFF.net was run by a couple of guys named Jeffry Dwight and Steve Ratzlaff and, for a few years, a man named James Macdonald who writes science fiction and fantasy in collaboration with his wife, Debra Doyle. The last I checked, Dwight and Ratzlaff were in the Dallas, Texas, area; Macdonald and his family lived in rural New Hampshire ("as far north as you can go without speaking French," he says). They were running sff.net out of a server in Dwight's garage, as a passion project adjunct to Greyware Automation Products, a networking business.

I'm a little bit vague on specifics here. That's the nature of online friendships. I've never met Dwight and Ratzlaff, though I'd like to. I have gotten together with Macdonald and Doyle a few times when I lived in Boston.

What killed sff.net? The cloud.


What are the hottest jobs in the cloud? Get our special report: Cloud Skills: What's Hot?.


More precisely, "the economics of hosting services favor large providers over small communities," according to a memorial page for sff.net by Dwight and Ratzlaff.

Free hosting, free email, and social media (all supported by advertisements) came along, and large providers took over the remainder of the business by offering low-cost sites with tools for designing and maintaining websites without understanding HTML. Google was only a year old when SFF Net started. Social media sites, such as Facebook, founded in 2004, have mostly replaced the traditional "bulletin board" sites.

SFF.net was founded in 1997, but its roots go back longer. It was a spinoff of an online service called GEnie, founded in 1985, which ran on GE's mainframes. When rumors began in the 90s that GE was going to shut down GEnie, SFF.net launched as a kind of lifeboat. GEnie eventually did die, on December 31, 1999. It was an indirect victim of the Y2K bug; then-owners IDT, a telecom company, didn't bother updating the software for the new millennium.

So that's 32 years of online history hitting a big milestone today.

When I started doing online communities with GEnie, that was a very unusual activity that I couldn't even explain to my real-life friends. Now, everybody does it -- on Facebook, Twitter and myriad smaller cloud communities. When I started with online communities, sometimes somebody would say something that got me angry for hours afterwards; my wife would be baffled. "Why do you care about somebody you haven't even met?" she'd wonder. Now, these same kinds of feuds happen on Twitter and Facebook and they're front-page news on The New York Times. The President of the United States spends his time with them.

I'm a little bit sad about sff.net shutting down, but not a lot. Much of the population of sff.net had already dwindled before this year. Many went to Facebook, of course, and I keep in touch with them there. I made some real friends on GEnie and sff.net -- by now we've been friends a long time -- and we see each other occasionally in real life, when we're in the same cities. There is one particular friend I'm a little concerned with losing touch with, but he's already set up a spinoff of SFF.net -- a spinoff of a spinoff -- using an open source BBS discussion system on a private cloud server.

Like a character in the book "Dune" says: "Parting with friends is a sadness. A place is only a place." A friend shared that quote in the final hours of SFF.net.

— Mitch Wagner Follow me on Twitter Visit my LinkedIn profile Visit my blog Friend me on Facebook Editor, Enterprise Cloud News

(8)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
kq4ym
kq4ym
4/11/2017 | 9:47:09 AM
Re: life after ....
I too regret the loss of those communities. It does seem that Facebook, and to some lessor extent other media sites are trapping us and our eyeballs and fingers in a frenzy of attention. As noted by a 60 Minutes piece this Sunday evening, apps and social media are designed to get and keep our attention. Not actually promising usefulness to us but desgined primarily to get us there and keep coming back repeatedly as a new habit we can't kick. How this will translate in human empathy and commpassion will be interesting to watch and observe.
danielcawrey
danielcawrey
4/2/2017 | 3:33:59 PM
Re: life after ....
Sad to hear. It would seem that Facebook is really changing the dynamics for smaller online communities. The company has crazy network effects, and now people just set up Facebook pages and things like that instead. Hopefully there is a movement back to some of these smaller communities someday, because I think they are needed. 
maryam@impact
[email protected]
3/31/2017 | 11:40:05 PM
Re: life after ....
Joe agreed, if you connected with those intentions.I have had made some connections with people strictly because we are in the same communities. We were complete strangers before and did not become friends until we were part of the community, so it can be just pure and straightforward mutual interests.
Joe Stanganelli
Joe Stanganelli
3/31/2017 | 11:14:09 PM
Re: life after ....
@maryam: Well, there may be ulterior motives, depending upon the context, but the context may make those motives more open (e.g., reconnecting with a high-school crush on Facebook, reaching out to a more successful colleague on LinkedIn, etc.).
maryam@impact
[email protected]
3/31/2017 | 4:39:00 PM
Re: life after ....
Joe that's a great point there are no ulterior motives and no happenstance of location just strictly the interest in the same activities.
Joe Stanganelli
Joe Stanganelli
3/31/2017 | 3:57:56 PM
Re: life after ....
I've met several friends and colleagues from what were once strictly online friendships/acquaintanceships.  The nice thing about that is those friendships tend to be a bit more pure because they're based less on the commonality of circumstance and more on the commonality of shared interests and a certain inherent degree of likemindedness.
Joe Stanganelli
Joe Stanganelli
3/31/2017 | 3:56:05 PM
Nostalgia
Wow.  GEnie.  There's a name I haven't heard in a long time.

Once in a while I get nostalgic for the BBSes and online communities I was a part of in another time.  But, of course, those have been replaced by other, more modern versions.
maryam@impact
[email protected]
3/31/2017 | 1:19:34 PM
life after ....
Yes, it is sad when online communities you have been a part of die but its part of the evolution. I have met some online friends in real life as well, and we have worked together! Other Friends have just moved on, in some ways, it's not death but a resurrection in another online life.
More Blogs from Wagner’s Ring
We're packing our bags for Dallas, for our cleverly named Network Virtualization and SDN Americas conference, but first we sat down to talk about NV, SDN and our favorite travel snack.
Will Apple's new iPhone 11 grow telco profits? Will Apple TV+ compete in a crowded OTT market? And why does everybody have fabulous hair in an Apple TV+ series where civilization has collapsed because everybody in the world is blind?
After years of defending itself against US spying accusations, Huawei claims the US government is spying on it.
The satellite network operator is looking to the Open Networking Automaton Platform (ONAP) to automate connecting its space-based network with terrestrial operators.
VMware's been shopping this summer, buying three cloud and networking startups that will bolster its telco strategy.
Featured Video
Upcoming Live Events
October 22, 2019, Los Angeles, CA
November 5, 2019, London, England
November 7, 2019, London, UK
November 14, 2019, Maritim Hotel, Berlin
December 3-5, 2019, Vienna, Austria
December 3, 2019, New York, New York
March 16-18, 2020, Embassy Suites, Denver, Colorado
May 18-20, 2020, Irving Convention Center, Dallas, TX
All Upcoming Live Events