So which is it? Evolution or revolution?
Actually, it's both. Or it's either one. It depends very much on what LTE deployment strategy you have in mind.
LTE does undoubtedly present profound, game-changing challenges. The X2 interface between eNodeBs is a whole new paradigm for cellular network planners. Cellular base stations have never had a direct communication path between them before. Deploying the X2 optimally and securely is a major new challenge.
The long-haul S1 interface between the eNodeBs and the core of the network is also brand new. There's no more intermediary BSC or RNC node to provide a security buffer between the cell site and the core. If the backhaul network is what the 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) defines as "untrusted," then IPSec is prescribed to protect against illegal interception – except that the prospect of managing hundreds or thousands of IPsec tunnels across the backhaul makes many mobile network planners' blood run cold.
And voice over LTE won't be a walk in the park, either. Cellular voice quality is variable enough without having to deliver it over an all-IP network – let alone one based on a newly defined standard that is still very much in its infancy.
These new features of the LTE standard are potentially very daunting for even the most IP-savvy mobile operator; there isn't much serious debate about that. Nevertheless, the alternative "business as usual" outlook is still very credible, particularly when closely linked to pragmatic assumptions about the timescales associated with these backhaul-impacting LTE features.
The bottom line is that it's possible to launch a perfectly viable LTE network in the next couple of years without actually activating the X2 interface; without implementing IPSec; and without offering voice over LTE. Operators certainly need to invest in understanding when – or in the case of IPsec, if – they will stand to benefit from deploying these capabilities and features. But there is nothing to say that they need to be deployed at launch, or even any time soon following initial launch.
As shown in my new report, "Backhaul Evolution Strategies for LTE Operators," the optimal approach for many operators will be rolling out a basic, stripped-down LTE network at launch and adding more sophisticated capabilities over time. That way, the toughest challenges can be managed as the evolution that the operators prefer – and not the revolution than many of them are right to fear.
— Patrick Donegan, Senior Analyst, Wireless, Heavy Reading
For more information about Heavy Reading's "Backhaul Evolution Strategies for LTE Operators," or to request a free executive summary of this report, please contact:
- Dave Williams
Sales Director, Heavy Reading