& cplSiteName &

Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?

Dan Jones
LR Mobile News Analysis
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor
11/2/2012
50%
50%

The wireless devastation wrought by Superstorm Sandy may be reason to re-evaluate the amount of battery backup power available to commercial cell sites after a major disaster.

Light Reading Mobile spoke to a public safety network expert at the 4G World show in Chicago this week who suggested one reason why some networks maintained connection through the brunt of the storm but went dead the next day was inadequate backup battery power.

"After Katrina, the FCC mandated eight-hour battery backup on cell sites," Emil Olbrich, lead project engineer for the office of law enforcement standards at the National Institute of Standards and Technology, reminded us.

That, though, was just the start of a long struggle between the regulator and the industry.

The backup power battle
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) started an inquiry into communication failures after Katrina in 2006 and mandated the change in early 2007. The CTIA and mobile operators kicked back against the ruling, arguing that it would cost hundreds of millions of dollars to add eight-hour battery backup to 200,000 cell sites across the U.S.

The FCC made some concessions on the ruling in 2008 but generally stuck to its guns. The CTIA, Sprint Corp. (NYSE: S) and others took the ruling to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, asking for a stay from the ruling.

There's a good summary of these events in this Powergrid International article from 2008.

The court declared the case "unripe" in July 2008 because the Office of Management and Budget ("OMB") hadn't examined the ruling. The CTIA requested the OMB reject the FCC mandate in October 2008.

The White House office, which has oversight of federal regulations, rejected the rule in November 2008 because the FCC failed to get public comment on it. The FCC could have tried to overturn that decision but decided not to in December 2008.

The FCC said back then it would revise the ruling but didn't give a timescale for those actions.

The issue was raised again in 2011 when, following tropical storm Irene, Connecticut State Senator Andrew Roraback said he would introduce legislation to make operators equip towers with backup generators. The industry described the measures as unnecessary and unrealistic.

After Sandy?
At the 4G show, Olbrich noted that many commercial cell sites currently have less backup time than eight hours.

Verizon Wireless , however, did tell the Associated Press on Oct. 29 that all of its cell sites have eight hours or more of backup battery power.

Industry attendees we spoke to at the 4G World show agreed that battery backup had kicked in after the storm but then simply ran out. In such instances, carriers have to bring in generators or mobile cell sites to bring coverage back while the power is out.

Clearly, in a storm the size of Sandy it's difficult and dangerous to try and undertake that in the immediate aftermath of the storm's impact. The entire process is also a costly one for operators, as they have to send workers to the sites to prepare them for power availability once the grid comes back.

Obviously -- as we have reported -- backup power is by no means the only cell site issue in a storm of this magnitude. Many sites have also suffered major water damage, wind damage or simply been overloaded by the volume of traffic from concerned users trying to reach friends and loved ones.

All the major carriers are providing blow-by-blow updates of their efforts to bring the networks online.

As of 10 a.m. ET Thursday, the number of cell site outages in areas affected by the storm had fallen from about 25 percent to 19 percent, according to the FCC.

The public safety angle
Still, NIST engineer Olbrich says the kind of backup capabilities available on commercial networks would not pass muster on the nationwide first-responder LTE network being funded to the tune of $2 billion (of a total projected $7 billion) by the federal government.

"For public safety, well, it's just not good enough," Olbrich said of backup at commercial sites.

For more
For continuing updates on the state of communications following the superstorm, see Hurricane Sandy Updates.

— Dan Jones, Site Editor, Light Reading Mobile

(10)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
year2525
50%
50%
year2525,
User Rank: Light Beer
1/22/2013 | 9:37:42 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?
-áInteresting stuff, thanks for your input on this.
191Jack
50%
50%
191Jack,
User Rank: Light Beer
1/22/2013 | 8:57:29 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?
The generators we used at our sites were either natural gas or propane. in the case of propane we buried all the tanks we could along with the fuel lines. All our tanks were set up for a minimum of 5 days continuous run time. In every case of an emergency, it gave us ample time to clear a path to a site and get a fuel truck in. We never ran out of gas. The other thing we did was to clear all the trees growing outside our sites so that any outdoor generators were not damaged although many of our sires had generators inside the cell building. The buildings were precast concrete and none were ever damaged in an emergency.

Our only use of diesel powered generators was at our switches and a few portable generator sets that could be brought in in case of a generator failure. We also had 365/24/7 generator service contracts and regular preventative maintenance. We ran every generator including our switch units on Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday under full site and switch loads during the very busiest times of the day to make sure they would do the job when needed.
191Jack
50%
50%
191Jack,
User Rank: Light Beer
1/22/2013 | 8:39:57 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?
I retired after 23 years with a NE US cellular carrier. From day 1 we not only had battery backup at our cell sites and switches but also generators. To me and the carrier I worked for at the time it was unthinkable not to provide continuous backup power as our subscribers needed their phones more during an emergency.-á
In 1985 we had a hurricane that put our rival carrier OUT OF SERVICE because the power outage was several days. We stayed on line except for one site where the leased tower we were on was blown down.-á
I've seen carriers pour money into portable generators and control centers, but for naught as the generators could not be dispatched to the sites that needed them when the crisis hit.-á
I'm afraid I find the carriers argument pretty weak about the cost if they are going to serve the public interest. Their loss of revenue in these cases should be cause for alarm.-á
If anyone is interested I have plenty more to say but I am not going to bore the people that won't listen.-á
Kit Kilgour
50%
50%
Kit Kilgour,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:16 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?


I can see that there is a stronger case for ensuring that macro-cell sites have significant amounts of backup power - the physical size of the site, mast and cabinet allows this. As the world moves towards more and more cell sites, this will become more challenging - small cells are designed to fit into small spaces, as well as some indoor ones even being powered over the ethernet, and some with both power supply and backhaul not under the full control of the operator.


It would seem that some mandate for backup power should be limited by e.g. the maximum transmit power of the cell, and the obligation on the operator to provide reasonable coverage, even if they had to limiting peak data rates in order to keep user capacity up with a smaller number of cells 

joset01
50%
50%
joset01,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:15 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?


How well small cells would survive a major storm and be managed after was also a question at the 4G World show. I asked Cisco's Kelly Ahuju about that.

krishanguru143
50%
50%
krishanguru143,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:11 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?




The problem with generators is that they are either going to run on a gas such as natural or propane or a liquid like gasoline or diesel.  Natural gas is not everywhere, how many homes in the Northeast still use heating oil?  So with the lack of natural gas in places, that leaves propane, gasoline or diesel.  The remaining three all have issues.  The pipes for propane could be damaged in a storm and leak propane fuel out; you also have an issue of refilling the tank after a storm.  The same holds true for gasoline and diesel, when the tank is empty, the tower is shutdown and you have to find a way to get the tank refilled.  That is easier said than done as the tower may not be accessible; downed trees, flooding, etc.  Carriers typically have portable generators and the site techs will drive let the generator charge the batteries backup and then move to the next site.  When you have a large number of sites that need attention, you don’t have the manpower or the generators to cover all of them.  It can take several hours or more to charge the batteries back up; so if it took four hours, the most you could do is less than six in any period unless you had multiple generators and then you might be able to get around twelve to eighteen.  Even that is not going to cut it, the techs are working non-stop.  Even with onsite generators, nothing says they would survive the storm either.  You also have that gasoline and diesel does go bad by just sitting in a tank.  Sure you can put fuel stabilizer in it; it still is not a good long-term solution.

Why not look at the power companies not be able to provide power.  Isn’t that really the issue?




krishanguru143
50%
50%
krishanguru143,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:10 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?




Power being out causes more problem than just mobile phone service.  Hospitals, grocery stores, fuel stations, water.  If someone has electric water heater, electric stove/oven and their fridge is obviously electric, good luck with food.  You better have MRE’s or something else.

 

That is why I said there is no real solution.  There is more everyone can do but just looking at mobile carriers to get their cards in order is very unfair.  The wireless carriers could pool together and have one generator per site for all the carriers there, but you still run into natural gas availability issues or fuel going bad or having to refill the tanks before they are empty.  Taking a hit a 8 hours after the storm is no different than a hit the day following.  An outage is an outage.

Probably why you won’t see power companies being asked to fix their infrastructure, some are municipality owned and the government would never do anything that would cost them money, they would make sure they would be excluded.  Asking the power companies to fix their infrastructure would also mean rate increases and that would never be popular either.  The telcos are a sitting duck.




joset01
50%
50%
joset01,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:10 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?


So you're proposing fixing the power grid as a more realistic solution? Okay then...


The point is that many commercial sites have very limited backup. I don't think anyone is expecting the networks not to take a hit in this situation but its not like we haven't had storms in the North-East recently.


I do wonder why companies don't put more power lines underground though. I get that it is initially cheaper but for how long if you need to keep fixing them?

joset01
50%
50%
joset01,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:10 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?


I don't disagree that the grid and fuel utilities should be fixed.


But it's not like the carriers aren't also benefiting from a shared nationwide resource as well. Often to great profits.

vz 29.5
50%
50%
vz 29.5,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 5:18:09 PM
re: Sandy: The Case for Better Cell Site Backup?


Until we use a multi-fuel source generator such as a solar, wind turbine ,nat gas,220v,with a hand crank so we may take turns spinning the generator at each site,we may have to live within our eras limitations.How boring.Yours for site advancement.A malibu son.

From The Founder
The time has come for a telecom app store to save the industry.
Flash Poll
Live Streaming Video
Charting the CSP's Future
Six different communications service providers join to debate their visions of the future CSP, following a landmark presentation from AT&T on its massive virtualization efforts and a look back on where the telecom industry has been and where it's going from two industry veterans.
LRTV Documentaries
Service Provider Panel: Partnering in the Digital Era

5|22|17   |     |   (0) comments


Coopetition has always been part of telecom, but the ecosphere now includes data centers, vendors, apps developers, cloud service providers and Internet content providers. This BCE 2017 panel explores the new attitudes among network operators as to the value and variety of ...
LRTV Interviews
Site Demo: AT&T's IoT Flow Platform

5|19|17   |   04:25   |   (0) comments


At AT&T's R&D center in Tel Aviv, Israel, project leader Eyal Segev talks about the operator's Flow platform and how it helps to prototype IoT applications.
LRTV Documentaries
Agent of Change: A Q&A With AT&T's John Donovan

5|18|17   |     |   (0) comments


Carol Wilson talks with the man leading AT&T's transformation efforts about the challenge of change.
LRTV Documentaries
BCE Service Provider Panel: The New Business Realities

5|18|17   |     |   (0) comments


For virtualization to happen, the telecom industry first has to grapple with key functional aspects of SDN and NFV that need to be universal, such as onboarding of virtualized network functions and federation of software-defined networks.
LRTV Interviews
BCE Service Provider Keynote: CenturyLink

5|16|17   |   22:32   |   (0) comments


Aamir Hussain leads the Product Development and Technology organization at CenturyLink, which includes the company's information technology function. He is an experienced senior technology executive with more than 25 years of proven success in the implementation of global technology operations, operationalization of complex technology, infrastructures and business ...
LRTV Interviews
CenturyLink CTO on Transformation

5|16|17   |   7:43   |   (0) comments


The 50-year-old telco has already gone through several transformations, including every time it made an acquisition, but its purchase of Level 3 coupled with changes in technology and customer expectations necessitates its biggest transformation yet.
LRTV Documentaries
Light Reading Hall of Fame 2017

5|15|17   |   5:05   |   (1) comment


Find out who made it into Light Reading's Hall of Fame this year.
LRTV Interviews
Site Visit: AT&T's Tel Aviv R&D Center

5|15|17   |   09:58   |   (1) comment


Nir Shalom, general manager and VP of application development at AT&T Israel, talks about the key service developments undertaken at the AT&T R&D facility in Tel Aviv and how the team there has adopted new ways of working.
Telecom Innovators Video Showcase
Act on Your Intelligence With Amdocs aia!

5|15|17   |     |   (0) comments


Amdocs CMO Gary Miles explains how communications service providers can seize the AI opportunity with Amdocs real-time digital intelligence platform.
LRTV Interviews
Logtel CEO: Making Sense of IoT

5|15|17   |   09:48   |   (0) comments


Jacques Bensimon, founder and CEO of Tel Aviv-based training and consultancy Logtel, talks about the need to make IoT more than just a buzzword.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
The Challenges of Mobile Banking Implementation

5|12|17   |     |   (0) comments


Kamal Quadir of bKash Limited explains the challenges and needs of implementing mobile banking in the Bangladesh market.
LRTV Interviews
Tel Aviv: A Hub of Innovation

5|10|17   |   07:58   |   (0) comments


Light Reading's Ray Le Maistre and Dan Allen discuss the technology innovation, food and amazing sights they witnessed during a recent trip to Israel.
Infographics
With the mobile ecosystem becoming increasingly vulnerable to security threats, AdaptiveMobile has laid out some of the key considerations for the wireless community.
Hot Topics
BSS Is BS, Says KPN Tech Boss
Iain Morris, News Editor, 5/16/2017
AT&T's Donovan: Women Adapt Faster Than Men
Sarah Thomas, Director, Women in Comms, 5/18/2017
Verizon on M&A: Who Needs a Cableco?
Mari Silbey, Senior Editor, Cable/Video, 5/17/2017
Standardization Needs Room for Innovation
Mitch Wagner, Editor, Enterprise Cloud, 5/17/2017
AT&T's Donovan: Resistance to Change Is Futile
Alan Breznick, Cable/Video Practice Leader, Light Reading, 5/18/2017
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
One of the nice bits of my job (other than the teeny tiny salary, obviously) is that I get to pick and choose who I interview for this slot on the Light Reading home ...
TEOCO Founder and CEO Atul Jain talks to Light Reading Founder and CEO Steve Saunders about the challenges around cost control and service monetization in the mobile and IoT sectors.
Animals with Phones
Live Digital Audio

Playing it safe can only get you so far. Sometimes the biggest bets have the biggest payouts, and that is true in your career as well. For this radio show, Caroline Chan, general manager of the 5G Infrastructure Division of the Network Platform Group at Intel, will share her own personal story of how she successfully took big bets to build a successful career, as well as offer advice on how you can do the same. We’ll cover everything from how to overcome fear and manage risk, how to be prepared for where technology is going in the future and how to structure your career in a way to ensure you keep progressing. Chan, a seasoned telecom veteran and effective risk taker herself, will also leave plenty of time to answer all your questions live on the air.