& cplSiteName &

XORP Goes Live

Light Reading
News Analysis
Light Reading

The Extensible Open-Source Router Platform (XORP) project is reaching a milestone of sorts, as its creators are ready to replace their own routers with XORP-wielding PCs.

Cut from the same conceptual cloth as Linux, XORP is an open-source alternative to the routing software provided by the likes of Cisco Systems Inc. (Nasdaq: CSCO) and Juniper Networks Inc. (Nasdaq: JNPR). As with other open-source software, the XORP code is freely available -- meaning it costs nothing and can be manipulated at will by users, who must pledge to share any innovations with the world.

Version 1.0 of XORP came out last summer, and with version 1.1 imminent, the team feels ready to pour XORP into their own network. XORP-based IPv6 routers will be connecting the project's home, at the International Computer Science Institute, to the nearby University of California, Berkeley campus, researcher Atanu Ghosh told visitors at a recent ICSI open house.

Why build something like XORP? Just as Linux fans accuse Microsoft of stifling innovation, XORP's creators say router vendors are holding back progress. The problem is that each company's routing code is proprietary and not available for users to tweak. "They're inaccessible to you. You can't go to your router and add, say, some new piece of security," Ghosh says. "It's very difficult to experiment or innovate."

Supporters of the open-source concept say bugs get fixed more quickly this way, because an entire community can work on the problem. The software gets enhanced more quickly, too, because users can collaborate on ideas and aren't beholden to one vendor's release schedule. "You get the benefit of many more people adding features," Ghosh says.

Beyond the open-source philosophy, XORP could cut hardware costs. The software is built to run on a PC rather than on the specialty hardware used by router vendors.

XORP started four years ago, and Ghosh, working in Australia at the time, was drawn in after multiple conversations with project creator Mark Handley. (Handley has dropped out of day-to-day XORP work to teach at University College London.) XORP's team consists of Ghosh and three other full-time researchers, alongside several part-time contributors. In addition to the usual government sources, the project has drawn funding from Intel Corp. (Nasdaq: INTC) and, of all companies, open-source pariah Microsoft Corp. (Nasdaq: MSFT).

XORP won't be storming Cisco's gates any time soon, because the project is limited to small routers bearing just a few ports. The handicap comes not from XORP itself, but from the PC's Peripheral Component Interconnect (PCI) architecture. "If you have many interfaces, PCI won't let you switch across all of them," Ghosh says. "We're hoping for industrial partners so we can run XORP on high-end hardware."

Some of the established players have doubts about XORP's prospects in large-scale networks, however. One difficulty lies in the varying ways of applying standards.

"Cisco does it one way. Juniper does it another. We spend a lot of our time in interoperability testing," says Manish Vaidya, product marketing manager for NextHop Technologies Inc.. Likewise, routing code these days is tightly integrated with the underlying hardware -- chipsets from the likes of Broadcom Corp. (Nasdaq: BRCM), Intel, or Marvell Technology Group Ltd. (Nasdaq: MRVL) -- and open-source software might not be able to provide those ties, he says.

Vaidya also believes customers are shying way from buying separate pieces such as software. "What they want is a complete solution they can drop on a piece of hardware, so they can go to market quickly," he says. "They want to move away from being systems integrators."

What's Cisco's take on the Linux of routing? In XORP's early days, the team presented the idea to Cisco and got a warm reception: "They seemed to be very interested," Ghosh says. He adds that there's been no contact with Cisco lately. Cisco representatives couldn't be reached for comment.

— Craig Matsumoto, Senior Editor, Light Reading

(3)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 3:25:30 AM
re: XORP Goes Live
There are fundamental legal and phbilosophical differences between the various "Open Source" licenses. "Public domain, "BSD-style," and "GPL" are all very different.

XORP is licensed under a BSD-style license. This means that anyone can use the XORP source and distribute binary-only copies. There is no requement to "give back" to the community. Thus, the article is wrong.

Even the GPL does not, strictly speaking, require that an author of changes "give back" the changes. The author is required to "give forward" the source code and the changes to anyone to whom the author gives the binary. The author of changes cannot prohibit the recipient from publishing the source changes back to the world at large, but the author has no obligation to publish those changes.
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 3:25:30 AM
re: XORP Goes Live
XORP is not the only Open Sourece routing code.

XORP is elegant, but Quagga appears to have a larger constituancy and more functionality. Reak companies use Quagga in real networks.
Pete Baldwin
Pete Baldwin,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 3:25:28 AM
re: XORP Goes Live
arch_1, you're correct -- open-source licensing doesn't require that you share changes. Thanks for pointing that out.

People really should share their work, of course -- that's the whole spirit of the thing -- but you figure commercial outfits will come up with proprietary ideas once in a while that they need to keep in-house.
Featured Video
From The Founder
John Chambers is still as passionate about business and innovation as he ever was at Cisco, finds Steve Saunders.
Flash Poll
Upcoming Live Events
September 12, 2018, Los Angeles, CA
September 24-26, 2018, Westin Westminster, Denver
October 9, 2018, The Westin Times Square, New York
October 23, 2018, Georgia World Congress Centre, Atlanta, GA
November 6, 2018, London, United Kingdom
November 7-8, 2018, London, United Kingdom
November 8, 2018, The Montcalm by Marble Arch, London
November 15, 2018, The Westin Times Square, New York
December 4-6, 2018, Lisbon, Portugal
All Upcoming Live Events
Hot Topics
T-Mobile to Play the Customer Care Card With Layer3 TV
Jeff Baumgartner, Senior Editor, Light Reading, 8/15/2018
Australia Could Open 5G Door to Huawei
Robert Clark, 8/16/2018
Video Navigation Gets an AI Assist
Jeff Baumgartner, Senior Editor, Light Reading, 8/16/2018
Eurobites: Deutsche Telekom Pulls Out of Iran
Iain Morris, International Editor, 8/17/2018
Animals with Phones
When Your Cat Hijacks Your Tech Click Here
Live Digital Audio

A CSP's digital transformation involves so much more than technology. Crucial – and often most challenging – is the cultural transformation that goes along with it. As Sigma's Chief Technology Officer, Catherine Michel has extensive experience with technology as she leads the company's entire product portfolio and strategy. But she's also no stranger to merging technology and culture, having taken a company — Tribold — from inception to acquisition (by Sigma in 2013), and she continues to advise service providers on how to drive their own transformations. This impressive female leader and vocal advocate for other women in the industry will join Women in Comms for a live radio show to discuss all things digital transformation, including the cultural transformation that goes along with it.

Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed