Light Reading

Cable IPTV Debate Brews

Jeff Baumgartner
LR Cable News Analysis
Jeff Baumgartner

Cable operators across the globe may be eager to introduce IPTV services, but how they deliver them -- directly through the cable modem termination system (CMTS) or via a CMTS "bypass" scheme -- is rapidly becoming a point of contention.

BigBand Networks Inc. (Nasdaq: BBND) is one of the vendors advocating a CMTS bypass approach with "vIP PASS," a platform that feeds video through the edge QAMs. BigBand holds that the approach is inexpensive when compared to piping video through the core CMTS. Furthermore, BigBand, which gave up on core CMTSs in the fall of 2007, argues that CMTSs are also prone to dropping packets, which is a big no-no for video. (See BigBand Lays Cable IPTV Groundwork and BigBand Terminates CMTS.)

Although Arris Group Inc. (Nasdaq: ARRS) counters most of BigBand's claims (more on that later), other vendors have developed or are pursuing CMTS IPTV bypass products of their own.

Motorola Inc. (NYSE: MOT), for example, unveiled the Docsis IPTV Bypass Architecture (DIBA) in 2006, basing it on proprietary protocols. The company, which makes core CMTS products, originally viewed DIBA as an opportunity to sell massive amounts of downstreams using its own edge QAMs, if and when cable IPTV took off.

Motorola still thinks bypassing IPTV traffic to the edge QAM could save MSOs plenty of capital, and the company is working on a DIBA demo that simulcasts about 100 traditional broadcast channels over IP.

A DIBA deployment for unicast video still hasn't happened, though. "We have nothing in the field because most of our customers are not at the point of…considering something like this," says Mike Cookish, director of product management for Motorola's CMTS business unit.

That's not the attitude at Harmonic Inc. (Nasdaq: HLIT), whose video-over-Docsis demo got high marks at a CableLabs meetup in 2007. (See Harmonic's Bright Idea .)

"We are beyond the proof of concept" for CMTS IPTV bypass, Gil Katz, senior director of cable solutions for Harmonic, told Cable Digital News recently at the vendor's headquarters in Sunnyvale, Calif. He says one cable MSO customer in Asia is already doing this today using Harmonic's NSG9000 edge QAM. "All major operators... one way or the other are looking into IPTV."

BigBand, meanwhile, has not yet revealed its first vIP PASS deployment partner, but it's believed to be an MSO based in Korea.

Not all the CMTS IPTV bypass activity is happening outside the United States. H&B Communications is deploying IPTV services using a CMTS bypass system outfitted with GoBackTV Inc. edge QAMs and SecureMedia Inc. 's conditional access/digital rights management technology.

The CMTSs' side
Although Arris sees some potential for CMTS bypass, it thinks core CMTSs (or more specifically, its CMTSs) are perfectly capable of supporting IPTV services at an acceptable price.

Tom Cloonan, Arris's chief strategy officer, says CMTS memory buffers today are plenty deep enough today to handle the load and keep packets from dropping off.

"Typically, today's CMTS would have much larger buffers than edge QAMs," he says, noting that CMTSs are also better equipped than edge QAMs to handle big bursts of traffic.

He says CMTSs can likewise be tuned to handle IPTV traffic by dropping some Docsis features, a move that should enable the box to boost the number of downstream channels it can process at one time.

Although it would behoove Arris to protect its CMTS business, it also makes edge QAMs. "We can thrive with either decision... but we see limitations on the MSOs if they choose the bypass approach," Cloonan says.

He also bristles at the notion that CMTS IPTV bypass is cheaper, because it's not necessarily fair to compare the two.

"The CMTS has to manage the upstream. That's the most challenging job," Cloonan says. "IPTV [services] need to select channels... through the upstream, but they [the edge QAM vendors] don't include that in their price comparison. It's kind of an apple and elephant comparison." He also thinks that core CMTS downstream port pricing will eventually close the gap with those for edge QAM downstream ports.

Arris isn't a lone voice in the forest.

Guangzhou Digital Media Group of China offers one the best cable examples so far. It's rolling out IPTV services to all of its 2.5 million cable subscribers within the next five years using Microsoft Corp. (Nasdaq: MSFT) Mediaroom and set-tops from Tatung Co. Rather than bypassing the CMTS, Guangzhou Digital is delivering video directly through the Casa Systems Inc. C3200, a Docsis 3.0-qualified CMTS. (See Chinese MSO Does IPTV With Microsoft.)

Guangzhou represents Microsoft's first cable deployment for Mediaroom, and more are coming, according to Ben Huang, Microsoft Mediaroom's director of product management. Just don't expect any of them to show up in North America. Asia and Latin America "are the frontrunners" when it comes to Microsoft's cable-related IPTV activity, he says.

That's not a huge surprise, since operators in those regions may not have the QAM-based digital legacy that MSOs in North America have today. "We still believe there is an opportunity in North American cable, but those are further out in time than the other regions," Huang says.

New specs?
If domestic cable MSOs do pursue CMTS bypass architectures for IPTV in a big way, some industry insiders wonder if the industry should draft some standards so MSOs don't get locked into particular vendors' product lines.

BigBand's bypass architecture, for example, requires a small software client in the modem that communicates back to the vendor's vIP PASS server. But the company is trying to show its architecture can still play nice with the industry.

For example, VP of marketing John Holobinko says vIP PASS uses Docsis mechanisms and can "work with any CMTS, because we're using pass-through messages like any other IP messages." The first vIP PASS deployment is running on "one of the two largest suppliers of CMTSs," which could mean gear from Arris, Cisco, or Motorola. He also confirmed that a recent demo conducted at the CableLabs Winter Conference in Colorado Springs was done with the Cisco flagship CMTS, the uBR10012.

Holobinko adds that BigBand is talking with Docsis modem chip players -- meaning Texas Instruments Inc. (NYSE: TXN) and Broadcom Corp. (Nasdaq: BRCM) -- about including that software client on their chips.

For now, BigBand doesn’t have much to worry about, anyway, at least when it comes to having to comply with a new set of specs. There's no such effort underway at CableLabs, according to David Reed, the R&D house's chief strategy officer. But he didn't completely rule one out, either.

"We are not at this moment creating a [cable IPTV] spec," he says. "If a consensus would emerge around something, we'd take that to our members. On the broadband side, we want to make sure we're trying to bring the best technology available to the cable operators."

And Comcast Corp. (Nasdaq: CMCSA, CMCSK), the largest MSO in the land, is evidently looking at all of the options on the table. At last month's Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers (SCTE) Conference on Emerging Technologies, MSO senior fellow Weidong Mao said Comcast is still weighing which approach makes the most economic and technical sense. (See The Cable Show '09: 5 Takeaways .)

— Jeff Baumgartner, Site Editor, Cable Digital News

(2)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:05:33 PM
re: Cable IPTV Debate Brews

In the end it's going to come down to which is more economical

User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:05:07 PM
re: Cable IPTV Debate Brews

and again , whats the Long Standing, always Missing word in this and every other IPTV PR  industry writeup today!.

"Multicast" .

Near realtime "IP Multicast" protocol, lets not mention "IP Broadcast" as someone in the core networks at Virgin Media etc will have a heart attack ;) and the "it cant be done" brigade will come out in force, "Mbone" anyone, now that was were the real innovators were, shame theres no real "CAN DO" innovators around today...

just stop filtering off Multicast on all the worlds ISP grade installed routers and related kit all the way "to and from" all the current end users officially graded and certifyed CPE DS3 IPv6/Multicast capable kit would be a very good start....

its all about costs for sure, and Multicast is the long standing EXISTING protocol officially made for exactly this massive bandwidth saving single data flow point to multi-point etc, thats officially ON ALL THE WORLDS routers and related kit right NOW, all the way to the DS2/DS3 (Euro)DS certifyed kit TODAY.

 so you cant get cheaper than already powered,installed and currently inactive Multicast in all the worlds retail Cable BB customer base after all....

this industrial grade ISP Kit even comes pre-set for generic Multicast ON, the ISP techs have to go out of their way turn it OFF in their config files etc.


were have all the old "MBONE" IP Multicast code innovators done today?, we have masses of young PR innovators but no real bedroom "Software code multicast Innovators" anymore it seems, and thats a shame.

From The Founder
Steve Saunders provides an overview of white box networking and introduces a new "slim line" version of the OSI 7-layer model.
Flash Poll
Live Streaming Video
CLOUD / MANAGED SERVICES: Prepping Ethernet for the Cloud
Moderator: Ray LeMaistre Panelists: Jeremy Bye, Leonard Sheahan
Between the CEOs
Centec on Ethernet Switching

11|26|15   |   09:58   |   (0) comments

Centec CEO James Sun talks to Steve Saunders about Ethernet switching and the white box revolution.
LRTV Custom TV
Delivering Service Agility in the Virtualization Era

11|25|15   |   5.41   |   (0) comments

Interview with Massimo Fatato, WW OSS Business Lead, Hewlett Packard Enterprise.
Wagner’s Ring
How Might Open Source Fail?

11|24|15   |     |   (10) comments

Open source, SDN, and NFV are looking inevitable – but performance, standards proliferation and regulatory capture could derail the movement.
LRTV Custom TV
NFV Lifecycle Orchestration – a Fresh Vision for Telco

11|23|15   |   6.40   |   (0) comments

Simon Osborne, CTO Comptel, and Heavy Reading's Caroline Chappell reveal the business impacts of new SDN and NFV, and what the term service orchestration actually means. Together they define Lifecycle Service Orchestration and how the virtualized future will look for telecoms operators.
Between the CEOs
Cisco's Virtual Role in Saudi

11|20|15   |   12:15   |   (2) comments

Light Reading founder and CEO Steve Saunders talks with Zayan Sadek, Regional Manager at Cisco Systems, about the competitive communications services market and advance of virtualization in Saudi Arabia.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei Leads With Kubernetes for Cloud PaaS

11|19|15   |   08:26   |   (0) comments

Huawei is looking to Kubernetes as a key tool for building robust open source technologies for customers and partners, said Ying Xiong, chief architect of cloud platform at Huawei, in an interview with Light Reading West Coast Bureau Chief Mitch Wagner at the recent Kubecon conference.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
WiC in London: The Highlight Reel

11|19|15   |   5:33   |   (1) comment

NetCracker's Mervat El Dabae headlines an inspiring morning in London with help from leading women from Vodafone, TalkTalk, Hyperoptics and Ciena.
LRTV Documentaries
Why Saudi's So Hot for New Tech

11|19|15   |   05:07   |   (0) comments

Light Reading's Steve Saunders reports from Saudi Arabia, a hyper-competitive market desperate to embrace the next generation of communications technologies and services.
LRTV Custom TV
Why Data Models Deliver More Value Than Information Models

11|19|15   |   5.08   |   (0) comments

Stefan Vallin argues that more automation is needed to manage end-to-end services and the hybrid networks they run on, and that data models are key to achieving this.
Telecom Innovators Video Showcase
SDN Management & Orchestration in the WAN

11|17|15   |   7.20   |   (0) comments

Carol Wilson and Packet Design CTO Cengiz Alaettinoglu discuss CSPs' SDN service delivery and assurance requirements. Learn about a modular approach to building automated control, orchestration and management functions for the WAN that are policy- and analytics-driven.
LRTV Custom TV
Flash Networks: Optimizing for Radio Spectral Efficiency

11|17|15   |   3:34   |   (0) comments

Today most optimization vendors only focus on optimizing voice or data. Ofer Gottfried, Flash Networks' CTO, shows how improving data throughput and maximizing spectral efficiency reduces capital and operating expenses while also providing a platform for user engagement.
LRTV Custom TV
Making Pay-TV User Experiences Millennial-Friendly

11|16|15   |   6:42   |   (0) comments

The unique challenge of reaching and engaging Millennials is driving pay-TV video experience transformation that can include higher quality UIs, viewing of multiple content streams at once and seamless transitions between handheld devices and the television.
Allot MobileTrends Report H2/2015 reveals how daily online behavior can be used to discover smarter ways to profile customers and propose valuable, real-time offers to them.
Hot Topics
Samsung to Sell Wireless Networking Unit?
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/23/2015
Samsung: No Sale of Wireless Unit
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/25/2015
How Might Open Source Fail?
Mitch Wagner, West Coast Bureau Chief, Light Reading, 11/24/2015
Sprint to Get $1.2B From New Leasing Venture
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/23/2015
Networking Shines in HP's Gloomy Final Earnings
Mitch Wagner, West Coast Bureau Chief, Light Reading, 11/25/2015
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
December 15, 2015
Virtualizing Cable Services
Webinar Archive
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
Centec CEO James Sun talks to Steve Saunders about Ethernet switching and the white box revolution.
Light Reading founder and CEO Steve Saunders talks with Zayan Sadek, Regional Manager at Cisco Systems, about the competitive communications services market and advance of virtualization in Saudi Arabia.
Cats with Phones
Can't Find the Phone on Thanksgiving? Click Here
Check under the cat! (hint: bottom right)
Live Digital Audio

Broadband speeds are ramping up across Europe as the continent, at its own pace, follows North America towards a gigabit society. But there are many steps to take on the road to gigabit broadband availability and a number of technology options that can meet the various requirements of Europe’s high-speed fixed broadband network operators. During this radio show we will look at some of the catalysts for broadband network investments and examine the menu of technology options on offer, including vectoring and for copper plant evolution and the various deployment possibilities for FTTH/B.