VCs Slammed in Poll
In the poll, respondents are asked to pick the folk they hold most responsible for the current, sorry state of affairs.
So far, 22 percent of votes have been cast for "venture capitalists, for over-inflating the bubble" -- way out ahead of the next category of possible culprits, "top executives, for feathering their own nests at the expense of workers," which has got 14 percent of the votes at present.
Other groups that get it in the neck include "telecom regulators, for failing to curb anti-competitive behavior" (13 percent) and "analysts, for not telling the truth" (11 percent). (Somehow, we forgot to include journalists in our list.)
At the other end of the scale, there are some real surprises. Nobody so far has blamed "governments, for charging too much for 3G wireless licenses," even though this appears to be one of the main reasons some European incumbent carriers are weighed down with huge debts (see British Telecom on the Mend).
Likewise, only 4 percent of respondents blame "financial regulators, for failing to blow the whistle on corrupt behavior." Also getting off lightly are "traditional systems manufacturers, for offering vendor finance," which get a mere 3 percent of votes. (The scale of this issue is laid out in Vendor Financing.)
Respondents were also asked to name the current development that gives them most hope for recovery.
The biggest surprise here is that "less competition" is currently tying for top place with "advances in access technologies," both of which garner 23 percent. Less competition probably equates to carriers being able to charge higher prices for their services -- the hope being that this will lead to more infrastructure investment. (Dream on.)
The next biggest hope is that "new sources of traffic such as 3G wireless" will encourage carriers to resume investment in infrastructure. That gets 11 percent, just ahead of "advances in metro technologies," which gets 10 percent.
"Bargain-basement acquisitions" and "bargain-basement telecom infrastructure from bankrupt/distressed carriers" get 7 percent and 8 percent of votes, respectively -- a reflection of the belief that if someone can't make money out of an asset, then the likelihood is that no one else can either.
To take the poll yourself, and get the latest results in detail, click here.
— Peter Heywood, Founding Editor, Light Reading