x
Security Platforms/Tools

Will Service Providers Steal ADT's Customers?

Several major U.S. MSOs and telcos are rushing into the home security and automation market, but this potential growth opportunity may not evolve into a material business anytime soon, Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. Inc. warns in a new report.

Comcast Corp. (Nasdaq: CMCSA, CMCSK), AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T), Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE: VZ) and Time Warner Cable Inc. (NYSE: TWC) are attracted to this market because the residential and small business segment for security and automation services is big (US$12 billion and 30 million homes), profitable (margins in the range of 50 percent), and fragmented (the top three, dominated by ADT Security Services Inc., together hold just 30 percent market share). There also seems to be room for growth as just 23 percent of homes currently take home security and automation services.

While Bernstein does believe that the MSOs and telcos are positioned to get their "fair share" of the existing home security market while also targeting the emerging home automation sector, the investment bank's researchers are not confident that the strategy will evolve into a big profit-maker.

The firm notes that each point of the current market is worth $120 million in revenues and $60 million in EBITDA. If cable were to grab 5 percent of the market in five years, that's still just $300 million in EBIDTA. If Comcast were to get 40 percent of that, we're still talking about $180 million in annual EBITDA, contributing less than 1 percent to the EBITDA that Bernstein is predicting for the MSO in 2016.

But that sort of prediction hasn't stopped the majors from going after the market. Among MSOs, Comcast expects to have its service, Xfinity Home, rolled to most of its markets by year-end, while TW Cable already has its IntelligentHome service available in a handful of markets ahead of expected, broader launches. AT&T and Verizon have also developed their own set of services through partnerships or spurred along by recent acquisitions. (See Comcast Goes Big With Xfinity Home , TW Cable Picks iControl, Verizon's Over-the-Top Home Control and AT&T Dives Deeper Into the Smart Home.)

Build versus buy
Many have speculated that ADT could become an attractive M&A target for Comcast and turn the MSO into a market leader virtually overnight. That idea's been fueled by the fact that ADT's CEO (and former General Instrument Corp. and Motorola Inc. exec) Edward Breen resigned from the Comcast board last year. (See Will Moto Go Back to the Future?)

But Bernstein's analysts note that Breen's resignation is understandable because Comcast and ADT were becoming competitors. And that's not the only reason. "ADT's geographic footprint doesn't match that of any Cable operator, nor does its technology, nor does its principal focus on security rather than automation. An organic growth strategy is far, far more likely, in our view," the research firm concludes.

If that's the case, Comcast and its big service provider peers may have a long, patient march ahead if they expect to turn their budding home security plays into future profit-drivers.

— Jeff Baumgartner, Site Editor, Light Reading Cable



Jeff Baumgartner 12/5/2012 | 5:36:41 PM
re: Will Service Providers Steal ADT's Customers?

If it will indeed be an uphill battle for MSOs to make much of a dent to their bottom lines, then one has to wonder why so many service providers are still jumping into this business and making a go of it. What do they see that the Bernstein analysts don't?


And (shamless plug) that's something I'll certainly try to cover when I moderate a session on this home automation topic on May 23 at 11am ET at The Cable Show in Boston. Hope you can join us then, as we'll have execs on the panel from Comcast, iControl, TW Cable, Rogers Communications and Cox Communications.  JB

joanengebretson 12/5/2012 | 5:36:38 PM
re: Will Service Providers Steal ADT's Customers?

I always wonder about broadband providers' forays into the alarm business because they normally see it as a fourth or fifth service they can offer as part of a broadband bundle--but if you ask a traditional alarm company, they will generally tell you they would much rather use wireless communications than broadband. Their take is that if they touch the customer's broadband connection, the customer will perceive that they are the cause of any future problems they may have with their computer--and what customer doesn't have computer problems?


Perhaps the risk is a bit less for a broadband provider since they are more involved in the broadband connection to begin with. But there's also the issue of the unreliability (real or perceived) of broadband (a.k.a. Internet) networks. You may say wireless neworks are unreliable, too--and they are--but those issues are largely ameliorated when you put a transmitter in a place with good reception and leave it there.

Flook 12/5/2012 | 5:36:32 PM
re: Will Service Providers Steal ADT's Customers?

Instead of trying to take over this market, why don't service provders see/explore how they can cooperate with existing home security companies in way that is beneficial for both and leads to further innovation and better home securit

skirstein 12/5/2012 | 5:31:47 PM
re: Will Service Providers Steal ADT's Customers?

I'm certainly no insider, but from the outside it certainly seems as though these additional services provide not only a barrier to exit / disincentive to switch; they also represent largely marginal additional revenues rather than having to pass a margin hurdle on their own.


 

HOME
Sign In
SEARCH
CLOSE
MORE
CLOSE