FCC on the Verge of 2-2 Split

With the US Senate shutting down for the holidays, the FCC appears to be on the edge of whittling down its team of Commissioners to an even split of two Democrats and two Republicans.

Senate Democrats had hoped to vote on the reconfirmation of Democratic Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel before the end of the year. But despite the Senate Commerce Committee's unanimous approval of her nomination for a second term more than a year ago, Committee Chairman John Thune (R-S.D.) did not bring a vote on her continued tenure to the full Senate floor. Without that vote, Commissioner Rosenworcel will have to step down from her post by the end of 2016.

The fight over Rosenworcel's re-confirmation seemed to coalesce around the news that Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chairman Tom Wheeler was unwilling to announce his own departure date despite the election of Republican Donald Trump to the White House. Typically, an FCC chairman will leave office when a new president is elected, but it's not required by law. Recently, Multichannel News reported that Wheeler would be willing to step down immediately if it would guarantee a vote for Rosenworcel, but that wasn't enough to force a vote before the Senate recess.

Technically, the Senate is still holding pro forma sessions this week, but, as the name implies, very little business is expected to take place during those sessions, and many senators have likely already left town for the holidays.

With Rosenworcel's departure, the FCC will drop down to four commissioners: Chairman Wheeler and Commissioner Mignon Clyburn on the left, and Commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O'Rielly on the right. The ideological tie means neither side will be able to push through controversial orders. Several recent votes by the FCC have split along party lines, including rulings on media ownership and Internet privacy where the Democratic commissioners exercised their majority over Republican dissent. (See Trump Win Will Reshape FCC and The Set-Top's Not Dead, Set-Top Regulation Is.)

For more broadband market coverage and insights, check out our dedicated Gigabit/Broadband content channel here on Light Reading.

Once President-elect Trump enters the White House, Chairman Wheeler will have to leave his position as head of the FCC, but his term as commissioner technically continues into November, 2018. Trump will get to nominate a new candidate for chairman and also a third Republican to the Commission, giving Republicans a 3-2 majority. If Wheeler stays on at the agency, he and Commissioner Clyburn will represent the Democratic minority. If he resigns, Trump will nominate another Democratic candidate to fill his position.

It is widely assumed that the FCC under a President Trump will take a more hands-off approach to regulation and may even look to roll back the Open Internet Order (i.e. net neutrality) passed in February of 2015. (See Trump Team Appoints Net Neutrality Naysayers for FCC Transition.)

Current names reportedly being floated for FCC chairman include Commissioner Pai, lawyer and FCC transition advisor Jeff Eisenach, and, according to one report, possibly former AT&T and Comcast CTO David Fellows.

— Mari Silbey, Senior Editor, Cable/Video, Light Reading

kq4ym 12/28/2016 | 4:45:07 PM
Re: How serious is this? How much political posturing? I wonder what might happen if the positions became non-partisan and held by folks of technical and legal backgrounds so as to make decisions not on profits and political leanings but by what is good for the citizens and the building of infrastructures to benefit them?
KBode 12/13/2016 | 6:05:51 PM
Re: How serious is this? How much political posturing? I imagine Wheeler's a little pissed that he has to stick around and watch an endless series of 3-2 votes dismantle four years of work instead of enjoying his retirement. That 2-2 split won't last more than a few months, I imagine...
brooks7 12/13/2016 | 10:43:23 AM
Re: How serious is this? How much political posturing? How serious is this situation? How much of this is political posturing?

- It is not serious.  Stuff like this happens around the transition between administrations all the time.  Having lobbied these offices, they Commissioners are 100% politicians and do not care about constituents.  What they do care about is their next political gig.

Does anyone know how this will turn out?

Yes, there will be an FCC with a 3 - 2 Repubulican majority.  Decisions here are SLOW anyway.  Expect it all to be done by May - if not sooner.


msilbey 12/13/2016 | 10:10:17 AM
Re: How serious is this? How much political posturing? I'll find it very interesting to see how long Wheeler hangs on with Rosenworcel out of the picture. If he leaves, the Commission will be 2-1 or 3-1 Republicans to Democrats until a new Democratic Commissioner is confirmed. And how long will that take? I'm imagining some pretty serious confirmation fights in the near future. 
[email protected] 12/13/2016 | 6:27:02 AM
How serious is this? How much political posturing? How serious is this situation? How much of this is political posturing?

Does anyone know how this will turn out?

Let's see what you think.... vote in our poll

Festive Fun at the FCC

What impact, if any, will a 2-2 split of FCC commissioners have on US telecom regulation? Click on this link to vote and see what others are thinking...

Sign In