Regarding the Xbox usage: Think about it. Like a set-top, the Xbox is not mobile. Like a set-top, the Xbox delivers on-demand content through a subscription video service. Like a set-top, the signals do not travel over the open Internet or have any impact at all on last-mile Internet traffic. The only difference is the technology: one is QAM and the other is IP.
The FCC has had the goal of getting cable service on 3rd-party devices for 15 years. The CableCARD just was not the right solution for two-way cable traffic on 3rd-party devices. An IP-based device works, however, not just on the Xbox, but also on the retail TiVo box using both a one-way CableCARD for linear and IP for on demand.
What's the big fuss? CE companies and consumer advocates should be jumping for joy that a mass market for cable service on 3rd party devices is finally at hand, rather than whining about net neutrality stuff that doesn't apply.
If usage based pricing gains traction, then Will Richmond's point about the subsidy non-sports fans pay for bundled programming could too. Idea being those who never watch Sports Center would prefer not to pay for it.
Regarding the Xbox usage: Think about it. Like a set-top, the Xbox is not mobile. Like a set-top, the Xbox delivers on-demand content through a subscription video service. Like a set-top, the signals do not travel over the open Internet or have any impact at all on last-mile Internet traffic. The only difference is the technology: one is QAM and the other is IP.
The FCC has had the goal of getting cable service on 3rd-party devices for 15 years. The CableCARD just was not the right solution for two-way cable traffic on 3rd-party devices. An IP-based device works, however, not just on the Xbox, but also on the retail TiVo box using both a one-way CableCARD for linear and IP for on demand.
What's the big fuss? CE companies and consumer advocates should be jumping for joy that a mass market for cable service on 3rd party devices is finally at hand, rather than whining about net neutrality stuff that doesn't apply.