Google Wants You to Be Your Own ISP

The Internet is too slow for Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) and the nation's telecom and cable companies are to blame. At least that's how Google sees it.

In an interview with journalist Tom Foremski at the Fortune Brainstorm conference in Half Moon Bay, Google VP of engineering and chief Internet evangelist Vint Cerf slammed AT&T, Verizon, and the cable companies for failing to invest in network infrastructure.

"It's like little kids in a tantrum," he said. "'I'm not going to build this system unless you give me three scoops of ice cream and a pony.'"

Such behavior, Cerf said, harms the national interest.

Read the whole story at InformationWeek.

— Thomas Claburn, InformationWeek

jc_iii 12/5/2012 | 3:35:57 PM
re: Google Wants You to Be Your Own ISP Carriers not going to build unless they get three scoops of cash? Tell that to their shareholders:)
netmeister 12/5/2012 | 3:35:53 PM
re: Google Wants You to Be Your Own ISP Does anybody else feel that Google acts like a spoiled child, born with a silver spoon in his mouth, who never had to work a day in his life?

Google can afford to make nonsensical business decisions because it has a huge cash-cow called AdWords that finances every crazy idea that comes into its head. The rest of the world has to make rational business choices.

And "...harms the national interest"?!?!? WTF? Did the USA become socialist without my noticing it? (As an aside, I guess that could happen if Obama wins...)

If Google wants to spend some of its gobs of cash to build out a gold-plated national network, then I invite it to do so. I bet you within 10 years it will be completely out of the network operations business, having sold that division for a huge loss to somebody that understands how carrier networks are run.

Either way, put up or shut up. Money talks and everything else walks. If somebody else won't do what you want them to do, instead of whining about their whining, dangle some cash in front of them and see how fast they move.

All that said, I'm not a carrier guy and I don't think the carriers are above criticism for some of the crap they routinely pull (access, neutrality, etc.). But for Google (and Cerf) to spout this bilge water? Sheesh.

What color is the sky in Google's world, Vint?

corwin0 12/5/2012 | 3:35:51 PM
re: Google Wants You to Be Your Own ISP Greetings,

Before you question Vint on his not knowing how carriers work, please remember that he was SVP for architecture and engineering at AS3561 (iMCI), then AS70[123] (MCI/UUNET) (which became the two biggest Internet backbones at the time). He has spent more time designing networks and pushing packets than you have, I would be willing to bet.

Also, since Comcast, VZ, AT&T, etc. pretty much act as a monopoly or duopoly in their service areas, it is fair to ask if they are investing in their service, as they have placed the bar so high for potential competitors (with better, cheaper product), that there is not a commercial driver for them to do so. The natural behavior of a {mon,du}opoly is to maintain the status quo. If they didn't have that commercial position, the question would be potentially specious, but they do, and therefore, it's not.

Therefore, sir, please think more carefully, and check your facts BEFORE you attempt to zing someone in a public forum.

nodak 12/5/2012 | 3:35:50 PM
re: Google Wants You to Be Your Own ISP Just out of curiosity, how does working for UUNET (which became part of Worldcom) make him all that great? All UUNET/Worldcom did was inflate the telcom bubble even further by making false claims of Internet traffic growth. How does this make him the person to claim the telcos are wrong?
Sign In