Lucent's $5 Billion Question
But despite Alcatel SA's (NYSE: ALA; Paris: CGEP:PA) prominent figuring in such a potential deal, don't rule out a last-minute victory by a dark horse, including one of the Japanese giants Fujikura Ltd., Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd., Hitachi Ltd. (NYSE: HIT; Paris: PHA), or Sumitomo Corp..
In February, Light Reading reported that Lucent was weighing its options with respect to the fiber unit, specifically a possible deal with Corning Inc. (NYSE: GLW) (see Corning and Lucent May Reach Deal). Then in March, Lucent officially put its Norcross-Ga.-based Optical Fiber Solutions unit up for sale, closing the bidding two weeks ago. Alcatel SA (NYSE: ALA; Paris: CGEP:PA) so far is the only company to publicly confirm the placing of a bid (amount undisclosed). A report in Friday's Wall Street Journal says Lucent and Alcatel have talked about merging in the past and may do so yet.
Lucent's need for cash, a factor that drove the company to spin off Agere Systems (NYSE: AGR) in an unfavorable IPO market, is likely to make something happen relatively fast. (Most analysts say the value of the fiber unit is roughly $5 billion.) Lucent's current financial woes, they say, will put the kibosh on a full-out merger for the present time.
"A merger between Lucent and Alcatel would create a powerful networking company, but I think it's a low probability right now," says Lawrence Harris, VP at Josephthal & Co.. "Alcatel is a value-oriented type of investor, and there are no premiums in the current share prices."
Although Alcatel hasn't been averse in the past to buying companies with operating losses (such as Newbridge Networks), Harris notes it's unlikely it would be attracted to Lucent given the enormity of Lucent's current problems.
Harris doesn't rule out the possibility that Lucent might throw some of its other properties into a pending sale of its fiber business. After all, Lucent has solid value in its optical systems, wireless, and even circuit-switching businesses, he maintains.
But most analysts agree that whatever deals Lucent decides to make, it will make quickly. Besides its own immediate cash flow issues, Lucent needs to come up with about $2 billion in cash by September 30, 2001, in order to complete the divestiture of Agere Systems (NYSE: AGR). According to Harris, this date and amount are in the deal Lucent made with its bankers, which includes a variety of other conditional payments.
Besides Alcatel, offers for Lucent's fiber unit also reportedly have come from Corning Inc. (NYSE: GLW), Furukawa, JDS Uniphase Inc. (Nasdaq: JDSU; Toronto: JDU), Pirelli SpA, and/or Tyco International Ltd. (NYSE: TYC), which purchased Lucent's power systems business back in January 2001 (see Tyco Acquires Lucent Division).
Of these, sources say it's likely the choice will boil down to Alcatel or Furukawa. Other combinations, such as Corning and Lucent, would prompt lengthy regulatory scrutiny. Corning already has a 40 percent market share in the optical fiber business and Lucent has about 20 percent to 30 percent, according to analysts. Alcatel owns only 10 percent and Furukawa less than that. So a combination of Lucent with one of the latter two would not take as long to accomplish as a deal with Corning.
"I think Lucent wants to get this done," says one Wall Street analyst, who asked not to be named. "Also, there have been other bids put in that didn't make the papers. Don't rule out the chance of a dark horse ending up the winner."
Alcatel and Lucent declined to comment on any aspect of a sale or merger.
- Mary Jander, Senior Editor, Light Reading http://www.lightreading.com