& cplSiteName &

Another Operator Shuns Tru2way

Jeff Baumgartner
9/29/2009

Buckeye CableSystem will consider moving to an IPTV-based architecture before even considering an upgrade to tru2way, offering more evidence that only the nation's largest MSOs will likely adopt the CableLabs -specified platform in a significant way in the near term.

Evolution Broadband LLC , a Colorado-based company that's developed a digital platform for Tier 2 and Tier 3 cable operators, recently disclosed that it had abandoned a tru2way product strategy, holding that the headend costs are too much to bear for smaller MSOs. R.L. Drake LLC , a company that targets the same market with a system called Digital Freedom, has admitted that its MSO customers aren't even asking for them to sprinkle in tru2way support. (See Evolution Passes on Tru2way .)

Since then, Cable Digital News has asked several small and mid-sized operators about their tru2way plans, and the silence has been deafening: Only Buckeye, headquartered in Toledo, Ohio, has come back with any definitive answers. Officials at some operators outside the top six that are involved in the Sony Corp. (NYSE: SNE) tru2way memorandum of understanding admitted privately, however, that tru2way has not entered their planning discussions for several months. (See Revealed: The Tru2way MOU.)

Cost is one obstacle. The idea of implementing the Docsis Set-Top Gateway (DSG) and putting in the entire tru2way ecosystem without a big penetration of tru2way-capable set-tops "causes a little angst," says Buckeye CTO Joseph Jensen.

His bigger issue, though, is with tru2way being single-threaded: It can only run one thing at a time. For example, if a TV-based caller ID application pops up on the screen, the viewer must exit that app if she wants to pause the DVR before answering the call.

CableLabs responds: CableLabs, the organization that heads the tru2way specs and tests tru2way devices, counters that tru2way can indeed support multi-process and multi-threaded run-time environments.

"As a Java-based technology, multiple tru2way applications can run simultaneously; furthermore, tru2way allows multiple simultaneous threads within each application," the organization asserts in a statement to Cable Digital News.

However, CableLabs allows that this is "subject to the availability of resources on the platform and to business rules implemented by operators. For example, the system will certainly support applications like caller-id and emergency alerts that can and will run simultaneously with the program guide."

But it doesn't appear that Buckeye is fully convinced.

The operator, which competes with AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T) U-verse and serves about 150,000 subscribers in parts of Ohio and Michigan, "is interested in supporting next-generation interactivity," Jensen says, noting that he'd like to offer social networking on the TV, or let viewers pick which channels make up a mosaic (AT&T just introduced such an offering). "My concern is that tru2way might not be able to fulfill it."

So, Buckeye is considering a twofold strategy that would include going all-digital and moving more and more video to IP. Buckeye, by the way, is already doing switched digital video (SDV) with BigBand Networks Inc. (Nasdaq: BBND), which has developed a cable IPTV product strategy (just sayin'). (See BigBand Pushes IP Video Convergence, BigBand Lays Cable IPTV Groundwork, Koreans Take Cable IPTV for a Spin , and Buckeye Picks BigBand for SDV .)

Jensen knows vendors won't build an IPTV platform tailored just for Buckeye. But he's keeping a close eye on how cable suppliers are trying to address his concerns. For instance, he acknowledges that the engineering brains behind tru2way are developing a workaround for the single-threaded issue.

In the meantime, Buckeye is testing some limited interactivity using Enhanced TV Binary Interchange Format (EBIF), a CableLabs -specified platform that addresses cable's entire universe of set-tops, including millions of thin-client boxes. Buckeye is one of a several MSOs on board to beta test a hosted EBIF service headed up by the Comcast Media Center (CMC) . (See CMC Plays Host to iTV and Four More Join 'HITS AxIS'.)

— Jeff Baumgartner, Site Editor, Cable Digital News




Interested in learning more on this topic? Then come to TelcoTV 2009, the telecom industry’s premier event for the exploration of a comprehensive entertainment convergence strategy, to be staged in Orlando, Fla., November 10-12. For more information, or to register, click here.


(5)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
MisterMHP
MisterMHP
12/5/2012 | 3:55:25 PM
re: Another Operator Shuns Tru2way


Multi Threading - Multi Instance Apps - is a fundamental part of the Java based MHP and Tru2way Specs. Italian DTT have an MHP Application running continuosly called a dashboard where you can run multiple apps from it...and tru2way is built from MHP.


Anyhow - If you have a Caller-ID button light up and you want that to pause the PVR then that will be up to the "Application developer" to include that as a feature of the application...or it would be a set-up function that the user can select...


EBIF is a low-level middleware designed for limited functionality and will certainly not reach the dizzy heights of Tru2way capability (Designed for low CPU, low Memory legacy STBs i.e. already deployed)


TVANGELIST


www.tvangelist.wordpress

JeffBonin
JeffBonin
12/5/2012 | 3:55:23 PM
re: Another Operator Shuns Tru2way


I would have to agree with MisterMHP on this issue.


Alticast has been providing applications for tru2way (and it's sibling standard DVB-MHP) since 2003.  There is nothing "single threaded" about tru2way.  It is all about applications sharing the screen and remote control.  Just like in the PC world, application builders must realize that the applications they build will not be the only applications running at one time.  Certain applications will have priority over others (especially with respect to certain keys on the remote).


There is coordination involved in making sure applications behave well with each other.  But to state that the entire environment is flawed because it is "single threaded" is not an accurate statement.


Jeff Bonin


Alticast

Jeff Baumgartner
Jeff Baumgartner
12/5/2012 | 3:55:22 PM
re: Another Operator Shuns Tru2way


Hi Jeff, Thanks for supplying some clarification on this important issue.  But are you aware of this workaround that Joe's referring to?  Has that already been implemented, or is something like that even required? Seems that there's some massive confusion on this one. JeffB

Jeff Baumgartner
Jeff Baumgartner
12/5/2012 | 3:55:21 PM
re: Another Operator Shuns Tru2way


CableLabs sent along a statement countering that tru2way can indeed support multi-process and multi-threaded run-time environments without any additional workarounds. Their comments have been added to the story. JB

Jeff Baumgartner
Jeff Baumgartner
12/5/2012 | 3:55:14 PM
re: Another Operator Shuns Tru2way

Buckeye CableSystem CTO Joe Jensen asked us to share the following statement in the hopes of further clarifying his position on this evidently thorny tru2way topic:

 "Tru2way does support multiple applications and allows transfer of keys as deemed appropriate by the application environment. However, in the current structure, only one application can be in focus at a time. In reference to my comment on ‘multithreaded’ applications, I was specifically speaking from the customer perspective. Our next generation of customers has been raised in a multi-tasking environment; I would hope that we are working toward an entertainment and communications service that can address their needs. The ability to present to the customer multiple activities simultaneously such as social networking, tickers, and multiple video screens represents the desired solution we seek for our future user environment. This convergence between computer screen and TV screen is our focus at this time."

Featured Video
Upcoming Live Events
October 22, 2019, Los Angeles, CA
November 5, 2019, London, England
November 7, 2019, London, UK
November 14, 2019, Maritim Hotel, Berlin
December 3-5, 2019, Vienna, Austria
December 3, 2019, New York, New York
March 16-18, 2020, Embassy Suites, Denver, Colorado
May 18-20, 2020, Irving Convention Center, Dallas, TX
All Upcoming Live Events