& cplSiteName &

Broadband Fee Fight Gets Messy at the FCC

Mari Silbey

One of the many debates surrounding broadband deployments in the US is how much municipalities should be allowed to charge telecom companies for access to public rights-of-way for use in installing communications equipment. The issue comes up frequently because the telecom industry expects to deploy a lot more gear in the coming years -- enough to support greater wireline broadband access, but also enough to enable future 5G wireless services.

So what's a reasonable amount? How much money is acceptable as a trade-off for better broadband, and how much is an overreach?

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai and Commissioners Mignon Clyburn and Michael O'Rielly attended the November BDAC meeting early in the day.
FCC Chairman Ajit Pai and Commissioners Mignon Clyburn and Michael O'Rielly attended the November BDAC meeting early in the day.

The debate was summed up in stark terms Thursday at the latest meeting of the Broadband Deployment Advisory Committee (BDAC) at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) . Municipalities by and large want a market-based approach to determining fee amounts, while the telecom industry is looking for a cost-based approach that allows local governments to recoup their costs in the process, but not add money to government coffers. Many of the BDAC members are determined to find a middle ground between the two positions, but many individuals, both in and around the committee, have also expressed strong opinions on the topic.

For example, FCC Commissioner Michael O'Rielly referred in opening comments at the BDAC meeting to fee practices in the city of San Jose, suggesting "that the mayor's team is seeking to extract high rents and fees for merely trying to attach small cells to utility poles." Notably, the mayor of San Jose, Sam Liccardo, is a member of the BDAC, so the barb was especially pointed given the audience in the room.

On the other hand, city officials have made clear time and time again that there are reasons for imposing some fees on rights-of-way (ROW) access, not just to cover costs, but also to fund digital inclusion initiatives and generally to ensure equitable broadband access. (See On Broadband, FCC Talks Carrots, Not Sticks.)

In reinforcing that very point, Mayor Liccardo suggested later in the day that if the committee wants to recommend a cost-based approach, that "the cost mandate, if that's what the industry is successful in getting, should be accompanied by a mandate that the industry serve everyone because that's what we do with public utilities."

San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo speaks at the BDAC meeting
San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo speaks at the BDAC meeting

The fee debate could effectively be papered over in the BDAC because committee membership is weighted toward industry representatives rather than local government officials, and ultimately the group will decide its final recommendations by vote. However, several members say they want to find an effective compromise because if municipality or state government views are discounted, the fee issue will continue to rear its head in policy discussions for years to come.

"We are not ultimately deciding how to resolve every issue. [Our role] is to inform people who will resolve issues in the most intelligent way," said Christopher Yoo, communications law expert and professor at the University of Pennsylvania. And he added, "Someone told me [that] in a negotiation, you know when you have a problem because it keeps coming up. You can win an issue early in a negotiation, but if it's not really stably resolved, it will come back again."

Andy Huckaba, City Council member from Lenexa, Kansas, also expressed concern that the fee issue must be addressed in every working group the BDAC has established. These include working groups on: streamlining federal siting, ensuring competitive access to broadband infrastructure, removing state and local regulatory barriers and creating model codes for state and local governments.

"Frankly, from my perspective, we're stuck," commented Huckaba on the issue of fees. And he said, "I would encourage this group as a whole, and I would encourage the FCC, to do some hard work on this."

Next: Finding answers in data

(4)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
User Rank: Blogger
11/15/2017 | 12:06:09 PM
Re: Correction
Yikes, sorry about that. Kansas it is. Thanks for pointing it out. 
User Rank: Light Beer
11/14/2017 | 6:30:06 PM
Lenexa Kansas not Lenexa Texas although I’m sure that would also be a delightful place!
User Rank: Light Sabre
11/13/2017 | 4:28:01 PM
Shooting themselves in the foot
Perhaps these elected officials should trade places with their counterparts in unserved and underserved communities who can't get service providers to give them the time-of-day, never mind Gigabit-capable broadband service.

Squeezing carriers for vigorish is not a good strategy. They can take their capex elsewhere, and leave uncooperative communities behind. That's why Boston got "no FiOS for you" back in 2008 or so. Then-Mayor Tom Menino (RIP) thought that the cable franchise was worth more to Verizon than they did. FiOS envy is a real thing for Boston residents.

The city learned from that experience. The Boston/Verizon partnership is a great win-win model that other municipalities would be wise to adopt.

Ironically, digital inclusion (in the form of low cost/high velocity broadband deployment to MDUs) will probably be one of the main use cases for fixed 5G.

-- Dan Grossman 
User Rank: Light Sabre
11/13/2017 | 2:33:58 PM
double tax
The fee debate goes on. This doesn't seem to be any closer to resolution - I hope they get there soon. I'm glad to be outside the discussions. This can't be an easy problem to fix with all the parties involved.
Featured Video
From The Founder
Light Reading is spending much of this year digging into the details of how automation technology will impact the comms market, but let's take a moment to also look at how automation is set to overturn the current world order by the middle of the century.
Flash Poll
Upcoming Live Events
November 30, 2017, The Westin Times Square
December 5-7, 2017, The Intercontinental Prague
March 20-22, 2018, Denver Marriott Tech Center
May 14-17, 2018, Austin Convention Center
All Upcoming Live Events
SmartNICs aren't just about achieving scale. They also have a major impact in reducing CAPEX and OPEX requirements.
Hot Topics
When Will 6G Arrive? Hopefully Never, Says BT's McRae
Iain Morris, News Editor, 11/21/2017
Let's Talk About 5G Efficiency, Not Wacky Services
Iain Morris, News Editor, 11/21/2017
AT&T's Lurie Leaps to Synchronoss as New CEO
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/17/2017
Wireless Could Arrive Soon in NYC Subway Tunnels
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/20/2017
Animals with Phones
Live Digital Audio

Understanding the full experience of women in technology requires starting at the collegiate level (or sooner) and studying the technologies women are involved with, company cultures they're part of and personal experiences of individuals.

During this WiC radio show, we will talk with Nicole Engelbert, the director of Research & Analysis for Ovum Technology and a 23-year telecom industry veteran, about her experiences and perspectives on women in tech. Engelbert covers infrastructure, applications and industries for Ovum, but she is also involved in the research firm's higher education team and has helped colleges and universities globally leverage technology as a strategy for improving recruitment, retention and graduation performance.

She will share her unique insight into the collegiate level, where women pursuing engineering and STEM-related degrees is dwindling. Engelbert will also reveal new, original Ovum research on the topics of artificial intelligence, the Internet of Things, security and augmented reality, as well as discuss what each of those technologies might mean for women in our field. As always, we'll also leave plenty of time to answer all your questions live on the air and chat board.

Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
Partner Perspectives - content from our sponsors
The Mobile Broadband Road Ahead
By Kevin Taylor, for Huawei
All Partner Perspectives