& cplSiteName &

Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate

Light Reading
News Analysis
Light Reading
8/22/2001
50%
50%

Analysts agree that Ethernet has a long road ahead before it overtakes Sonet in metro area networks (MANs). But just what flavor of Ethernet will prevail, how long it will take before it becomes widely deployed, and where, is still being hotly debated.

Marian Stasney, senior analyst with The Yankee Group, published a report yesterday saying that, while service providers are certainly considering Ethernet as a low-cost option for delivering high-speed access in metro networks, actual deployments are still thin on the ground (Yankees See Rosy Gig-E Future).

“Eventually, Ethernet will take over in metro,” says Stasney. “But [that's] at least seven to 10 years down the road.”

Stasney cites several barriers to widespread deployment of Ethernet in the near term. Although Ethernet equipment is much cheaper to purchase and maintain than Sonet gear -- thus saving on initial capital expenditures and operational costs -- the fiber infrastructure needed to support Ethernet services in the metro is still far from ubiquitous.

Further, metro Ethernet applications like voice over IP and storage networking are still immature, making carriers less willing to adopt a pure Ethernet approach in the near future.

”Service providers trying voice over IP say that quality varies substantially between vendors’ gear,” says Stasney. “I’m not sure end users are comfortable with using pure Ethernet for storage yet, either. Even greenfield Ethernet players are being asked to provide services other than Ethernet to handle these services.”

There is also a tremendous amount of Sonet already installed in most carrier networks. Some estimates show that there are at least 100,000 Sonet rings operating in the U.S. and possibly twice that number of SDH rings operating outside the U.S., according to Michael Howard, co-founder and principal analyst with Infonetics Research Inc.

Both Stasney and Howard agree that cutbacks in capital spending mean service providers won't lay massive quantities of fiber, or rip out older Sonet infrastructure, to deploy a technology that may not be able to generate revenue right away.

No hard numbers from the report have been released to the public yet, but Stasney says she is basing her research on conversations with 30 to 40 Ethernet, Sonet, resilient packet ring (RPR), and wave division multiplexing (WDM) equipment vendors, as well as data that was collected for another Yankee Group report on service providers, which hasn’t yet been published.

Other analysts agree with her basic premise. Chris Nicoll, vice president at Current Analysis, and Mark Lutkowitz, VP of optical networking research at Communications Industry Researchers Inc., both say they agree that Sonet will continue to dominate the metro for at least the next three to five years.

“This is probably the first time that I can say that I agree with Yankee,” says Lutkowitz. “The rate at which Sonet gear becomes obsolete is very slow. That stuff will be around for another 30 years. There’s no question that Sonet is here to stay.”

But Lutkowitz seems a bit leery of the specifics of The Yankee Group report: “Projecting the market seven to 10 years is ridiculous."

Fellow analysts may also quibble with Stasney on another point. She is bullish on the prospect of pure Ethernet eventually becoming the technology du jour in the metro, while others say that some combination of Ethernet over Sonet, or even the emerging packet technologies like RPR, will rule.

“It’s hard to say which technology will win out,” says Stasney. “RPR will likely be extremely important, but with Ethernet over Sonet you lose benefits of both technologies.” Analysts who disagree point to specific examples to back up their case.

Ocular Networks Inc. and Native Networks Ltd., which both offer Ethernet over Sonet, are getting serious attention from service providers,” says Nicoll from Current Analysis. “But companies like Atrica Inc. and Extreme Networks Inc., pure Ethernet guys, are finding legacy carriers a harder nut to crack. There aren’t that many Cogent Communications Inc. or Yipes Communications Inc.-type providers out there for them.”

- Marguerite Reardon, Senior Editor, Light Reading
http://www.lightreading.com

(28)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
Page 1 / 3   >   >>
uncle_optics@yahoo.com
50%
50%
uncle_optics@yahoo.com,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:43 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
Yo Mama is soooo fat that.....

oh yeah????


Well, you Mama is so ugly that.....

I love it.

Hey Yankee.....stop wasting your time interviewing the vendors!!!! Then again, everyone knows that you offer the best PR that money can buy so if you didn't rely on the vendors for your information then you'd be out of business!!!!
uncle_optics@yahoo.com
50%
50%
uncle_optics@yahoo.com,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:41 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
AMEN!!!

Or maybe at least create a PR section of the report and you can put Yankee and RHK in there.

Here's a Tag Line:

Will Shill For Food (or in RHK's case, pre-IPO stock)
hisles
50%
50%
hisles,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:41 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
To Lightreading

please keep Yankee off this sight

This is suppossedly to be for intelligent forward thinking people...

It isn't about Ethernet V Sonet but the integration of Ethernet into the Broadband IP strategy of existing networks.

A lot of buzz words start happening like provisioning, mpls etc etc and if i was anymore specific the boys at Yanks would publish it

But then since I wasn't paying them for writing it maybe not.....
flanker
50%
50%
flanker,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:40 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
Ethernet isnt a solution for corporations with global private line network needs.
jones1
50%
50%
jones1,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:40 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
I would like to share a few critical considerations before adopting the metro-ethernet
standard.

If the metro-ethernet is base on today' s pure ethernet implementation, there is no way it can
achieve that kind of protection and restoration scheme offered by SONET. This scheme is so important to justify carrier-class service which
primary dedicated to a voice-carrier network.

A maximum tolerence of 50 ms for any restoration
scheme will ultimately inhibit the adoption of ethernet.

It is impossible for ethernet to solve voice
carrier-class service requirement unless IEEE
802.3 working group modify ethernet so much to look like sonet. (With all the in-band signaling)
Prove me wrong.Anyone?

jmd
50%
50%
jmd,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:39 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
It may look and act like SONET in some ways but it will be called Ethernet. People have decided it's easier to get there from the Ethernet base camp. If you can't beat 'em, join 'em.
jmd
50%
50%
jmd,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:38 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
Of course itGÇÖs going to take some time GÇô it requires what is commonly referred to as business case. You see not that long ago you needed to build a business case in order for things to move ahead, then along came a big party where everybody said the f* with business cases I gonna get my piece before somebody else does.

Are we all so focused on instant billions that we canGÇÖt be a bit more patient? Geez!

The SONET v Ethernet debate is over already, weGÇÖre just waiting for the business case to mature. Last year you didnGÇÖt need a business case to convince somebody to buy into it, this year you do.

tintin
50%
50%
tintin,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:37 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
"It is impossible for ethernet to solve voice
carrier-class service requirement unless IEEE
802.3 working group modify ethernet so much to look like sonet. (With all the in-band signaling)
Prove me wrong.Anyone?"

Why do you want to solve resiliency at layer 2?
Ethernet over Sonet, Ethernet over Lambda, or IEEE 802.17,... all of them offer sub-50 ms resiliency.

Just don't use Spanning Tree (not even its grand-son) and your problem is solved. :-)

Tintin.

FiberFan
50%
50%
FiberFan,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:36 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
MMA asked the question;

What was the reason for the 50 ms restoration switching time requirement? Does anyone recall?

50ms restoration is key to support legacy TDM/voice networks. This kept calls (hundreds to thousands of them) from dropping and causing the Class 4/5 switch to melt down. There are probably a couple of other reasons, but maintaining calls (or Tandem Links) was the main reason.

This discussion thread is very interesting. Ethernet vs. SONET. From all of my reading the answer to this question seems to be RPR.

Any thoughts on this?

FiberFan
mma
50%
50%
mma,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/4/2012 | 7:55:36 PM
re: Report Stirs Ethernet vs Sonet Debate
"A maximum tolerence of 50 ms for any restoration
scheme will ultimately inhibit the adoption of ethernet."

What was the reason for the 50 ms restoration switching time requirement? Does anyone recall?
Page 1 / 3   >   >>
From The Founder
Kicking off BCE 2017, Light Reading founder Steve Saunders lays blame for NFV's slow ramp-up and urges telecom to return to old-fashioned standards building and interoperability.
Flash Poll
Live Streaming Video
Charting the CSP's Future
Six different communications service providers join to debate their visions of the future CSP, following a landmark presentation from AT&T on its massive virtualization efforts and a look back on where the telecom industry has been and where it's going from two industry veterans.
LRTV Custom TV
The Overall Objective Is to Win the Game

6|26|17   |     |   (0) comments


SCTE•ISBE's Chris Bastian discusses Energy 2020's success to date and the importance of a flexible approach that allows for changes in specific strategies in order to reach significant milestones.
LRTV Interviews
CenturyLink: Let's Get Past SD-WAN Hype

6|23|17   |   04:02   |   (0) comments


Technology becomes a "shiny object" unless it's properly focused on solving business needs for enterprise customers, says Bill Grubbs, network solutions architect for CenturyLink. He explains to Light Reading why SD-WAN deployments have to be tailored to specific needs – and more.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
Infinera's Sales Director Paints Tech's Big Picture

6|21|17   |   4:14   |   (1) comment


Shannon Williams, Infinera's director of sales, shares how she achieves work's many balancing acts -- between her role and the broader company, today and tomorrow's tech and more.
LRTV Custom TV
SD-WAN Innovation & Trends

6|20|17   |     |   (0) comments


Versa CEO Kelly Ahuja discusses with Carol Wilson the current status and trends in the SD-WAN market, Versa's innovation around building a software platform with broad contextualization, and the advantages that startups can bring to the SD-WAN market.
LRTV Interviews
Ovum's Dario Talmesio on 5G in Europe

6|20|17   |   02:16   |   (0) comments


At 5G World 2017, Dario Talmesio, principal analyst and practice leader on Ovum's fixed and mobile telecoms European team, explains the emerging trends amongst European operators as they prepare for 5G.
LRTV Custom TV
Putting Power on a Pedestal

6|19|17   |     |   (0) comments


ARRIS's John Ulm says a major accomplishment of SCTE•ISBE's Energy 2020 program is increased focus on power cost and consumption, including inclusion of energy requirements in operators' RFPs and RFIs.
LRTV Custom TV
Gigabit Access: The Last-Mile Pipe for All Future Services

6|19|17   |     |   (0) comments


A Gigabit access platform being deployed today must be able to deliver all types of services to an increasing number of devices. A non-blocking architecture is necessary to support the ever-increasing growth in bandwidth demand. The Huawei Gigabit access solution is based on a distributed design that is fully scalable to deliver a unprecedented performance.
LRTV Custom TV
Key Factors to Successfully Deploy an SD-WAN Service

6|19|17   |     |   (0) comments


As service providers transition their SD-WAN solution from trials and limited deployments into production at large scale, there are important considerations to successfully operationalize these solutions and realize their full potential, without adding complexity, introducing uncertainty or disrupting current business operations. Sunil Khandekar, CEO and Founder ...
LRTV Custom TV
IoT Solutions: Rational Exuberance

6|19|17   |     |   (0) comments


IoT solutions are morphing from hype into viable business opportunities. Huawei has the platform and ecosystem support to help carriers successfully address new business opportunities in the IoT space.
LRTV Custom TV
Realizing ICN as a Network Slice for Mobile Data Distribution

6|19|17   |     |   (1) comment


Network slicing in 5G allows the potential introduction of new network architectures such as Information-centric Networks (ICN) as a slice, managed over a shared pool of compute, storage and bandwidth resource. Services over an ICN slice can benefit from many architectural features such as Name Based Networking, Security, Multicasting, Multi-homing, Mobility, ...
LRTV Interviews
Ovum's Mike Roberts on 5G Uptake

6|19|17   |   04:08   |   (0) comments


Mike Roberts, research director for Ovum's service provider markets group, explains why he has boosted his 5G subscriptions forecast.
LRTV Interviews
AT&T's Hubbard on Intersection of SD-WAN & MPLS

6|15|17   |     |   (0) comments


Rick Hubbard, SVP of Network Product Management for AT&T Business Solutions, discusses how AT&T's approach to SD-WAN fits in with its overall virtualization strategy, explains how SD-WAN can improve enterprise customers' use of the cloud and addresses the intersection of SD-WAN and MPLS.
Upcoming Live Events
October 18, 2017, Colorado Convention Center - Denver, CO
November 1, 2017, The Montcalm Marble Arch
November 1, 2017, The Montcalm Marble Arch
November 30, 2017, The Westin Times Square
All Upcoming Live Events
Infographics
With the mobile ecosystem becoming increasingly vulnerable to security threats, AdaptiveMobile has laid out some of the key considerations for the wireless community.
Hot Topics
No Imagination: UK Chip Biz Goes Up for Sale
Iain Morris, News Editor, 6/22/2017
Does AT&T Deserve Time Warner?
Mari Silbey, Senior Editor, Cable/Video, 6/23/2017
Netflix's Lesson in Culture Expectation Settings
Sarah Thomas, Director, Women in Comms, 6/21/2017
Kalanick Steps Down as Uber CEO
Sarah Thomas, Director, Women in Comms, 6/21/2017
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
Following a recent board meeting, the New IP Agency (NIA) has a new strategy to help accelerate the adoption of NFV capabilities, explains the Agency's Founder and Secretary, Steve Saunders.
One of the nice bits of my job (other than the teeny tiny salary, obviously) is that I get to pick and choose who I interview for this slot on the Light Reading home ...
Animals with Phones
Live Digital Audio

Playing it safe can only get you so far. Sometimes the biggest bets have the biggest payouts, and that is true in your career as well. For this radio show, Caroline Chan, general manager of the 5G Infrastructure Division of the Network Platform Group at Intel, will share her own personal story of how she successfully took big bets to build a successful career, as well as offer advice on how you can do the same. We’ll cover everything from how to overcome fear and manage risk, how to be prepared for where technology is going in the future and how to structure your career in a way to ensure you keep progressing. Chan, a seasoned telecom veteran and effective risk taker herself, will also leave plenty of time to answer all your questions live on the air.