& cplSiteName &

BT Threatens to Ditch OpenStack

Iain Morris
10/14/2015
0%
100%

DUSSELDORF -- SDN & Openflow World Congress -- BT is threatening to abandon OpenStack in favor of a proprietary technology during its rollout of virtual enterprise services unless vendors backing the standard can overcome six potential technology showstoppers.

Such a move by the UK fixed-line incumbent could be a major setback for OpenStack, an open standard that is being touted as one of the key technologies underpinning NFV.

BT Group plc (NYSE: BT; London: BTA)'s concern relates to the use of OpenStack with virtual enterprise CPEs, whereby servers are distributed around the edge of the network and on customer premises.

Peter Willis, BT's chief researcher for data networks, acknowledges that OpenStack has major attractions as set of open source tools, with backing from some of the world's biggest IT companies, but says the technology still holds a number of risks for an operator rolling out virtual enterprise CPEs.

Unless the OpenStack community can address a number of serious challenges, BT will look to use an alternative technology.

Those challenges relate to the connection of virtual network functions (VNFs), service chain modification, scalability, so-called "start-up storms," the security of OpenStack over the Internet and backwards compatibility.

"If these six issues are not addressed we will not use OpenStack for virtual enterprise," he told attendees here in Dusseldorf. "There are proprietary solutions out there we could use and we will use them in lieu of OpenStack being available."


For more NFV-related coverage and insights, check out our dedicated NFV content channel here on Light Reading.


Willis revealed that some of the most important OpenStack stakeholders -- including HP Inc. (NYSE: HPQ), Red Hat Inc. (NYSE: RHT), Canonical, Mirantis Inc. and Intel Corp. (Nasdaq: INTC) -- have agreed there are problems but have not yet reached a consensus on how to address them.

Although BT could opt for a proprietary technology in the short term and introduce OpenStack at a later stage, this will become more difficult as services are rolled out.

"It's a strategic migration issue," says Willis. "It's easy to start off greenfield because we've not deployed any large numbers of virtual enterprise CPEs but in two or three years there will be more legacy."

Next page: The six challenges

(14)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
kq4ym
50%
50%
kq4ym,
User Rank: Light Sabre
10/26/2015 | 9:48:02 PM
Re: Rather ridiculous
I'm sceptical that BT would follow through with the "threat." I'm just guessing they;re bluffing in an attempt to speed up the openstack standards solutions. Going to proprietery is much like moving backwards at this point.
ahmadarshad
100%
0%
ahmadarshad,
User Rank: Light Beer
10/16/2015 | 10:21:33 AM
Resistance is one form of acceptance
I take it a positve step. Risks pointed out in this articles shoud be taken positively. Openstack is still in its infancy and there are fears and uncertaintity everywhere on its use and deployment. Best thing is to contribute and be part of it as pointed by EtherealMind. I like see these type of comments/risks from other Service Providers and users so that openstack community starts lokking in these areas. We face these challenges in our professional life every day and either get them resolved or find a work around. I believe security of infrastructure will be a big challenge in coming years and will be a hot topic of discussion.
Director72287
50%
50%
Director72287,
User Rank: Light Beer
10/15/2015 | 7:11:31 PM
Srsly?

Overall this smells like a FUD piece designed to demonstrate that a major service provider is unlikely to adopt OpenStack at this point in time. For starters, the idea that OpenStack is suitable for a major telco service provider's  virtual enterprise CPE platform is implausible at best.

If (and that's a big IF) Peter Willis is actually considering it he's guilty of trying to bang a square peg into a round hole, he should know better. I don't believe he is, so I have to assume this piece is an indirect rebuttal to a number of vendors who are hammering on his door telling him he should be using OpenStack because it is the answer to a maidens prayer. OpenStack is not an SDN platform. OpenStack could be used to build a service platform alongside other components, but that's a different discussion.

 

To address the points directly...

 

VNF's. Virtual Network Functions, are not a core use-case that OpenStack was ever designed to address. It may evolve to do that, but right now you need a focussed SDN solution to address this one.

 

Service chaining, the connection of a number of VNF's in series. It's just an amplification of the previous point.

 

Lack of scalability with a single controller.  Spare me! No sane commercial, service provider, or enterprise grade implementation would try to run with a single controller, scaling OpenStack requires an understanding of how to scale distributed systems.

 

Start-up storms. Anyone who thinks they can load 100,000 virtual CPE's onto a single controller has either been at the pixie dust, or is lacking clue about scaling distributed systems, or both (see previous point). Solving the problem of high volume SSL session setup is a well trodden path, horizontal scaling is one possibility, doing it in hardware is another (see previous point, again)  

 

Security. Yes, there is work to be done in securing OpenStack. SSL gets us a long way down the path at the transport layer, but there are other aspects as well. To state that a hypervisor to controller connection requires "500 pinholes" in a firewall is naive demagoguery, you need about 8, and that could probably be reduced even further if you're really security conscious and prepared to tweak the control plane architecture.

 

Backwards compatability. This problem exists for every single piece of moderately complex software with lifetime of more than a few months. In the specific case of OpenStack it's more complex than most, OpenStack has a lot of moving parts, and is developed by a community of loosely coupled projects. Synchronising them all is a challenge. To adopt open source software into your platform and enterprise usefully you have to invest in understanding the community and contributing to it.

 

Disclosure: I'm a huge fan of OpenStack, I'm a director of an OpenStack platform operator. It's a great platform, but it's not the answer to every question.

Flames will be piped to /dev/null :-)

mendyk
100%
0%
mendyk,
User Rank: Light Sabre
10/15/2015 | 11:06:46 AM
Re: Rather ridiculous
Heavy Reading's most recent research shows incredibly strong support for OpenStack among network operators, at least right now.
NeilMcRae
50%
50%
NeilMcRae,
User Rank: Lightning
10/15/2015 | 3:34:51 AM
Re: Rather ridiculous
I would say yes - it also, in many use cases, performs very well.
Steve Saunders
100%
0%
Steve Saunders,
User Rank: Blogger
10/14/2015 | 5:12:59 PM
Re: Rather ridiculous
Is VMware really carrier class code? I know they are now sniffing around the t4elecom market but i thought they had Enterprise pedigree. 
NeilMcRae
100%
0%
NeilMcRae,
User Rank: Lightning
10/14/2015 | 4:57:48 PM
Re: Is this a common view?
We always want more!  We want the best for our customers!

Openstack scalability is not a new issue and Peter is merely stating a fact and its not a threat its simply an ackowledgement of the current challenges operators face in rolling NFV (and other cloud services) out. Its not an issue of being competitive its an issue of having something that works for customers, at BT we only deploy things that work for customers!

There are alot of other gaps in Openstack and in time I am sure they will all be resolved, however with the current focus on these services customers are starting to want these services and the whole ecosystem is at varied levels of maturity; We are acknowledging an issue that we feel is not being as widely recognised as it needs to be and in many cases this is preventing large scale deployment. For vendors in the NFV/SDN space its going to be a barrier to sales for sure (I'd argue it already is).

Also its not the only issue in this space, lets not forget that this technology is still in its infancy, there are still significant OSS/BSS issues with SDN/NFV. The IT stack and capability to manage large scale SDN/NFV deployments and wide range of interacting services simply doesn't exist right now and how these technologies overlap with the existing telco and datacentre networks is still very "homebriew". For BT Cloud Connect we have created something to fill the gaps but its iimited in its capability, we want something more that truly brings abstracted service creation on any type of containerised/virtiualised/appliance based solution hence our significant contribution to OpenConfig and other Yang models across the network space. The end to end architecture in areas of service inventory, logical and physical inventory, workflow, activation and telemetry is still at a very early stage, with very little alignment or deployable solutions. Without these things, some of the promise these new technolgies bring won't materialise.

How does workflow work? how do atomic services interact with one another? how do we really drive the on demand opportunities between different methods of delivering services over different technologies and infrastructure - there is a long way to go.  If my customers fixed broadband Internet service goes down, how to I create a standby internet service using personal hotspot on my customers cellular service on demand whilst the fixed service is restored?

These are all maturity issues but we feel not enough focus is on this topic. We are all focused on interop and POCs, well frankly we've done that, infact we did it _years_ ago, now we want to move to proper deployment and for that we need a more complete ecosystem. But to be clear we aren't making any threats or otherwise we just want it to work for our customers and we will continue to collaborate to do this. And lightreadng if you want to come and have a chat about this, we are always open for coffee!

 

Regards,

Neil

 
brooks7
50%
50%
brooks7,
User Rank: Light Sabre
10/14/2015 | 4:50:55 PM
Re: Rather ridiculous
So, you can wait for OpenStack to fix their problems someday or implement today using VMware?  Is that the argument?

And by the way, all kinds of SaaS operators use VMware....and make money.  And I don't work for them, but I have been trying to raise this point for over a year.  Which is that SaaS operators have things pretty well solved already.

seven

 
Steve Saunders
50%
50%
Steve Saunders,
User Rank: Blogger
10/14/2015 | 3:39:20 PM
Re: Rather ridiculous
i need to dig in a bit more - thans for the insights. 
EtherealMind
100%
0%
EtherealMind,
User Rank: Lightning
10/14/2015 | 3:34:55 PM
Re: Rather ridiculous
The issues raised are well known, raised several times by others and OpenStack has been working on them for about a year and making progress. It might take a couple more years to get stable code and viable delivery. If BT got involved, comitted funding and developers then it could happen faster. Instead of gum flapping, they should participate. 

The only alternative that does have solutions for the issues raised is VMware and comes at a licending between £200-800 per physical server or ~£50-100 per VM (depending). 

There are OpenStack solutions from Cisco, HP, Mirantis and others that offer some answers but, again, cost per VM would make BT uncompetitive. 

Also I'm not raising the fact that OpenStack isn't specifically intended to handle lagacy applications that exist in private data centers. 

 
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
Educational Resources
sponsor supplied content
Educational Resources Archive
From The Founder
Kicking off BCE 2017, Light Reading founder Steve Saunders lays blame for NFV's slow ramp-up and urges telecom to return to old-fashioned standards building and interoperability.
Flash Poll
Live Streaming Video
Charting the CSP's Future
Six different communications service providers join to debate their visions of the future CSP, following a landmark presentation from AT&T on its massive virtualization efforts and a look back on where the telecom industry has been and where it's going from two industry veterans.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
Cisco: Mentoring Critical to Attract & Retain Women

7|19|17   |   6:40   |   (1) comment


Liz Centoni, senior vice president and general manager of Cisco's Computing System Product Group, shares why mentoring in all its forms is important for women and what Cisco is doing that's made a difference for women in tech.
LRTV Custom TV
Gigabit LTE With Snapdragon 835

7|12|17   |     |   (1) comment


At an event in Wembley stadium, EE used its live network to demonstrate gigabit LTE using a Sony Xperia XZ Premium smartphone with a Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 chip.
LRTV Custom TV
Implementing Machine Intelligence With Guavus

7|12|17   |     |   (0) comments


Guavus unites big data and machine intelligence, enabling many of the the largest service providers in the world to save money and drive measureable revenue. Learn how applying Machine Intelligence substantially reduces operational costs and in many cases can eliminate subscriber impact, meaning a better subscriber experience and higher NPS.
LRTV Custom TV
Unlocking Customer Experience Insights With Machine Intelligence

7|12|17   |     |   (0) comments


When used to analyze operational data and to drive operational decisions, machine intelligence reduces the number of tasks which require human intervention. Guavus invested in Machine Intelligence early. Learn about the difference between Machine Learning and Machine Intelligence.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
Verizon VP Talks Network, Career Planning

7|12|17   |   4:49   |   (0) comments


Heidi Hemmer, vice president of Technology, Strategy & Planning at Verizon, shares how bold bets and the future of tech define her career.
Telecom Innovators Video Showcase
Masergy's NFV Journey

7|11|17   |     |   (0) comments


Ray Watson, vice president of global technology at Masergy, discusses the advantages and challenges in entering the still-maturing NFV market for the past three years.
Telecom Innovators Video Showcase
Mavenir on RCS Cloud Platform & Multi-ID

7|10|17   |     |   (0) comments


Guillaume Le Mener, head of marketing and corporate development at Mavenir, discussed RCS and the recent launch of Multi-ID, which supports T-Mobile's DIGITS, the revolutionary new technology that breaks down the limitation of one number per phone and one phone per number.
LRTV Custom TV
ADTRAN Executive Outlines Trends in Next-Generation 10-Gigabit Cable Networks

7|10|17   |     |   (0) comments


Hossam Salib, VP of Cable and Wireless Strategy at ADTRAN, outlines key trends as MSOs begin to deploy next-generation Gigabit and 10-Gigabit cable networks. In the interview, Hossam outlines the advantages of a Fiber Deep architecture, FTTH options including EPON and RFoG, and the importance of SDN and NFV in building next-generation high-bandwidth cable networks.
LRTV Interviews
Global Capacity: Bandwidth Demand Driving Ethernet Growth

7|6|17   |   6:37   |   (0) comments


At Light Reading's Big Communications Event in Austin, Texas, Global Capacity's VP of Marketing Mary Stanhope talks about how the demand for bandwidth is changing the way service providers deliver broadband services.
LRTV Interviews
Colt's Services Chief on Digital Delivery

7|5|17   |   16:12   |   (0) comments


Rogier Bronsgeest, the chief customer experience officer (chief CEO!) at Colt, discusses the way in which the service provider interacts with its customers these days and his aggressive net promoter score (NPS) targets.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
BT VP: Women Should Fill Security Talent Gap

7|5|17   |   6:00   |   (2) comments


By 2020 there will be six security jobs for every qualified worker, and Kate Kuehn, vice president of Security for BT in the Americas, says BT wants to encourage women to fill the shortage in jobs.
LRTV Interviews
Colt Sales Exec on Services Trends

7|4|17   |   12:59   |   (0) comments


Colt's sales director for enterprise, James Kershaw, sheds some light on the services currently in demand and how network upgrades are influencing customer demand.
Upcoming Live Events
September 28, 2017, Denver, CO
October 18, 2017, Colorado Convention Center - Denver, CO
November 1, 2017, The Royal Garden Hotel
November 1, 2017, The Montcalm Marble Arch
November 2, 2017, 8 Northumberland Avenue, London, UK
November 30, 2017, The Westin Times Square
All Upcoming Live Events
Infographics
With the mobile ecosystem becoming increasingly vulnerable to security threats, AdaptiveMobile has laid out some of the key considerations for the wireless community.
Hot Topics
Mobile to Power Online Video Consumption – Zenith
Aditya Kishore, Practice Leader, Video Transformation, Telco Transformation, 7/19/2017
Can Mushroom Sprout in Crowded SD-WAN Field?
Carol Wilson, Editor-at-large, 7/18/2017
AI Will Be Ubiquitous in 2020 but Overhyped in 2017 – Gartner
Sarah Thomas, Director, Women in Comms, 7/18/2017
Facing the Facebook Video Threat
Gary Miles, Chief Marketing Officer, Amdocs, 7/17/2017
Brocade, Broadcom Merger in Doubt
Iain Morris, News Editor, 7/19/2017
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
Following a recent board meeting, the New IP Agency (NIA) has a new strategy to help accelerate the adoption of NFV capabilities, explains the Agency's Founder and Secretary, Steve Saunders.
One of the nice bits of my job (other than the teeny tiny salary, obviously) is that I get to pick and choose who I interview for this slot on the Light Reading home ...
Animals with Phones
Fuzzy Quick Fix Click Here
If you can't access it, is it really broken?
Live Digital Audio

Playing it safe can only get you so far. Sometimes the biggest bets have the biggest payouts, and that is true in your career as well. For this radio show, Caroline Chan, general manager of the 5G Infrastructure Division of the Network Platform Group at Intel, will share her own personal story of how she successfully took big bets to build a successful career, as well as offer advice on how you can do the same. We’ll cover everything from how to overcome fear and manage risk, how to be prepared for where technology is going in the future and how to structure your career in a way to ensure you keep progressing. Chan, a seasoned telecom veteran and effective risk taker herself, will also leave plenty of time to answer all your questions live on the air.