Light Reading
Unstrung tries to get beyond the theoretical peak speeds of new mobile broadband networks from AT&T, Clearwire, and Verizon

WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World

Dan Jones
LR Mobile News Analysis
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor
5/28/2009
50%
50%

With several major new mobile broadband services launched -- or coming soon -- in the U.S., and all promising blazing performance, it can be hard to get a clear picture of what wireless speeds you will actually get when you plug in your new data card or switch on that minty fresh new handheld or netbook.

The official word from AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T), Clearwire LLC (Nasdaq: CLWR), and Verizon Wireless is that their new networks will be faster than the maximum speeds offered today. But not landline-replacement kind of fast.

In fact, the fastest-sounding new network is also the one with the least known about it. Indeed, Verizon doesn’t want to talk numbers at all on its Long Term Evolution (LTE) network until it has done a lot more testing outside the lab. But we can look to other users' experiences, particularly in the case of AT&T’s planned High-Speed Packet Access (HSPA) upgrade, to glean some indication of how these networks will operate in the real-world.

AT&T
AT&T has just unveiled its timetable to update its 3G network with a technology called HSPA 7.2, work that is expected to start this year and be completed by 2011. A spokeswoman for AT&T says that -- as you might expect -- the network upgrade will offer a “theoretical maximum speed of 7.2 Mbit/s” compared to the 3.2 Mbit/s peak rate currently available.

The operator says the new update "will primarily affect downlink speeds." It notes that uplink speeds will be between 500 kbit/s and 1.2 Mbit/s.

We can, however, look to Vodafone Group plc (NYSE: VOD)’s deployment of the 7.2-Mbit/s upgrade in the U.K. to get some general idea of how AT&T’s network might perform. Heavy Reading analyst Gabriel Brown tested the network in June last year and recorded some performance figures.

Brown found that in central London locations where 7.2-Mbit/s service was enabled, service was consistently in the range of 3 to 4 Mbit/s data throughput on the downlink while stationary, with bursts as high as 5.5 Mbit/s. Stationary uplink offered a throughput of around 1 Mbit/s. 3G in motion was not quite so blazing, however: “300 kbit/s is what you can expect on a 3G connection while on the move across London by car or train,” Brown wrote at the time. (See Vodafone's Blazin' 3G Upgrade.)

There's no guarantee that AT&T’s network will perform exactly the same, since each market topology is different and can affect performance, amongst many other variables. Still, the Vodafone experience does offer a starting point for user expectations.

Clearwire
Clearwire is a little more forthcoming about the average speeds of its new Clear mobile WiMax networks. "Average download speeds range from 2 to 6 Mbit/s," a spokesman tells Unstrung. "Upload speeds are typically up to 1 Mbit/s." The company says the network can deliver burst peak rates of "more than 10 Mbit/s," but there's no telling how close you have to live to the cell-tower for that to happen.

Clearwire’s WiMax service is currently available in Atlanta and Portland, Ore. When Clear’s precursor, the Sprint Corp. (NYSE: S) XOHM service launched in Baltimore, Unstrung saw download speeds between 1 Mbit/s and 3.5 Mbit/s in the various tests around the city, although the Clear networks are said to be somewhat different than the original Sprint offering. (See XOHM's Big WiMax Demo Day.)

Verizon
Verizon is the most tight-lipped of the three about the speeds that will be offered by its LTE network, which is due to start going commercial in 2010. The operator has only said that it has seen between 50- and 60-Mbit/s downloads with the technology in initial tests. A spokesman for the company says that it doesn’t want to set customer expectations until it has done "a lot more testing outside of the lab" with the proto-4G technology.

"The bottom line is that until you load the network you can’t know for certain -- you can make an educated guess, but you can’t know," the spokesman says.

Unstrung has very little hard data on how LTE runs, since the first commercial base station just went live in Sweden. (See Sweden Claims LTE First.) Motorola Inc. (NYSE: MOT) did, however, stream video at 8 Mbit/s on an LTE test network at the CTIA show this year. This may give some indication of the raw speeds but doesn’t yet help to account for how the network will perform when lots of users are roaming on it.

— Dan Jones, Site Editor, Unstrung

(10)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
kaps
50%
50%
kaps,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:52 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


Verizon's Dick Lynch has said, publicly, that advanced radio technologies like WiMax and LTE are essentially equivalent. So what will make for higher end-user speeds? The amount of available spectrum.


If you REALLY want to see Verizon and AT&T get tight-lipped, start asking them about how much spectrum they have available for mobile wireless data use. Even the so-called "beachfront property" 700 MHz chunks won at auction don't really offer a whole lot of wireless pipe. And when you don't have enough overall spectrum depth, you have to use smaller channels per antenna -- which reduces the speed. See this handy chart Motorola has put together to get an idea on some "real world" speeds.


The betting line -- WiMax will stay fastest because Clearwire has gobs of spectrum, but likely available in fewer markets. LTE when it launches will be in the 7 Mbps range if Verizon is lucky; and AT&T's HSPA+ upgrades... well, this company said a year ago it was going to 20 Mbps this year. Now it's down to 7.2. How low can you go and keep the iPhone all to yourself?

kaps
50%
50%
kaps,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:52 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


Verizon's Dick Lynch has said, publicly, that advanced radio technologies like WiMax and LTE are essentially equivalent. So what will make for higher end-user speeds? The amount of available spectrum.


If you REALLY want to see Verizon and AT&T get tight-lipped, start asking them about how much spectrum they have available for mobile wireless data use. Even the so-called "beachfront property" 700 MHz chunks won at auction don't really offer a whole lot of wireless pipe. And when you don't have enough overall spectrum depth, you have to use smaller channels per antenna -- which reduces the speed. See this handy chart Motorola has put together to get an idea on some "real world" speeds.


The betting line -- WiMax will stay fastest because Clearwire has gobs of spectrum, but likely available in fewer markets. LTE when it launches will be in the 7 Mbps range if Verizon is lucky; and AT&T's HSPA+ upgrades... well, this company said a year ago it was going to 20 Mbps this year. Now it's down to 7.2. How low can you go and keep the iPhone all to yourself?

joset01
50%
50%
joset01,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:51 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


Asked Dick Lynch that back at MWC in Barcelona, he said he was "very comfortable" with their spectrum position, but then what did you really expect him to say?


I think the spectrum postion is interesting, but it is what it is, the only way AT&T and Verizon add more in the future is by buying it in. I sometimes wonder if that the eventual outcome of Clearwire, to be bought by one of the big two? I think its a possibility, I don't know how likely a possibility yet, Clearwire still has show they can make it work across more markets.


I actually think the upload speeds of these technologies is as interesting as the downloads. If they really want cameras and netbooks and all kinds of other gizmos on there I think the upload speeds become much more important.


DJ 

kaps
50%
50%
kaps,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:51 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


I think you're spot on, Dan -- if CLWR were to be sold it wouldn't be the first time a Craig McCaw spectrum-acquisition strategy paid off, would it? But I see a sticking point in the Comcast and Google investment... they may not approve any such deal, think it will be something to watch if CLWR can prove the business case.


Gabriel, I understand your desire for everywhere connectivity, but I wonder how much that caveat applies to the general populace. For every globe-trotting mobile professional there must be many more folks who stay close to home and might see greater value in faster speeds with local mobility. Not sure there is enough data yet to prove this idea, but it's a flip side to your coin that bears consideration.

kaps
50%
50%
kaps,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:51 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


I think you're spot on, Dan -- if CLWR were to be sold it wouldn't be the first time a Craig McCaw spectrum-acquisition strategy paid off, would it? But I see a sticking point in the Comcast and Google investment... they may not approve any such deal, think it will be something to watch if CLWR can prove the business case.


Gabriel, I understand your desire for everywhere connectivity, but I wonder how much that caveat applies to the general populace. For every globe-trotting mobile professional there must be many more folks who stay close to home and might see greater value in faster speeds with local mobility. Not sure there is enough data yet to prove this idea, but it's a flip side to your coin that bears consideration.

IPobserver
50%
50%
IPobserver,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:51 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


There's been a good amount of simulation and testing on what LTE might deliver in the real world.


LSTI has some public results. Slide 15 of this presentation from February 2009 is worth a look: http://www.lstiforum.org/file/news/Latest_LSTI_Results_Feb09_v1.pdf


They have some more recent data, but I can't find a link.


For my money, coverage is at least as important as high data rates. Knowing you can get a connection everywhere at, say, 1 Mbit/s is more valuable to me than being able to get, say, 5 Mbit/s every now and then.

mobileinsider
50%
50%
mobileinsider,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:50 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


Dan, great article - it brings up a variety of points and angles for consideration.


My point of view is: It's not about LTE vs WiMAX speeds. It's about best experience using available spectrum with full mobility and access to a plethora of devices and laptops. HSPA and HSPA+ networks will deliver a great multi-Mb experience for years to come - today. Why wait for LTE? Look at Telstra...people are experiencing 2-3Mb and sometimes more. AT&T will be able to replicate this here in the US much like Vodafone and T-Mobile will be able to do the same in Europe and US for years to come. 


Verizon wants access to the global device market and to simplify its device/service offerings, thus the path to LTE makes good sense. As for spectrum, all of the operators need more spectrum - period (video is a network destroyer).  Where will they get it from?  Yes, Clearwire is a good target as is Sprint.  I would be surprised if both brand names are still around 12 months from now. Suitable buyers include: T-Mobile, A&T, VZ (market entry by: China Mobile, Vodafone). 


Just my 2 cents.


Twitter/mobilinsider

IPobserver
50%
50%
IPobserver,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:50 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


It's not so much globe-trotting execs I'm talking about. It's having that always-on, always-available, experience that comes from good coverage.


That will have a big influence on mobile apps and and the mobile data use case.


Coverage is King !

john.nobel@team.telstra.com
50%
50%
john.nobel@team.telstra.com,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:44 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World


You might want to check http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NextG ...


"The Next G Network is also the fastest cellular network in the world, delivering theoretical network speeds of up to 21Mbit/s,<sup class="reference" id="cite_ref-1">[2]</sup> and is planning to increase the speed up to 42Mbit/s in 2009." HSPA ...


Or http://www.telstra.com/nextg&nbsp;...


"Telstra is excited to announce the launch of the new Turbo 21 Modem<sup>^</sup> that provides typical download speeds of 550kbps to 8Mbps in selected CBD, metro and regional areas<sup>^</sup>. Available now exclusively to business customers, it will unleash the power of the world&rsquo;s fastest national mobile broadband network for Australian businesses in these areas."


John

IPobserver
50%
50%
IPobserver,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:03:42 PM
re: WiMax & LTE Meet the Real World

@omniobso -- I didn&rsquo;t read this as an LTE vs. WiMax&nbsp;, or ClearWire vs VZW, article. More like an attempt to get a handle on what end users might realistically expect.

Broadly,&nbsp;I think the service provided over today's HSPA is phenomenal. Think back five years and 3 Mbit/s downlink was a top end ADSL service. Now it's available on a &pound;10-&pound;15 a month mobile plan.

Page 1 / 2   >   >>
Flash Poll
From The Founder
It's clear to me that the communications industry is divided into two types of people, and only one is living in the real world.
LRTV Interviews
From 4G to 5G: Alcatel-Lucent's Dave Geary

11|25|14   |   09:09   |   (0) comments


Dave Geary, President of Wireless at Alcatel-Lucent, talks about the evolution of the 4G market, small cells, partnerships, 5G and the IoT.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Building a Secure Telefonica Network With Huawei's High-End Firewall

11|24|14   |   4:37   |   (0) comments


Andrew Davies, IP architect of the Telefonica, a leading digital communications company, discusses the Huawei security gateway solution and putting the solution into the testbed.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei Partners with Spirent to Verify CE12816's 10GE Port & TRILL Networking Capabilities

11|24|14   |   2:50   |   (0) comments


Spirent Communications is the world's leading supplier for telecom testing appliances and solutions. Spirent has been in a close partnership with Huawei for a long time.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Saudi Airlines & Its ICT Transformation

11|24|14   |   2:07   |   (0) comments


In this video, Saudi Airlines discusses its network problems and how Huawei's Agile Network is its all-in-one solution.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei's Agile Switch Benefiting Saudi Arabia's Yamamah Hospital

11|24|14   |   2:40   |   (0) comments


Saudi Arabia's Yamamah Hospital speaks about how Huawei's Agile Switch has improved the medical service's network infrastructure.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
FanPlay & Huawei Build a Wireless Agile Smart Stadium

11|24|14   |   2:13   |   (0) comments


FanPlay is a cloud-based white label service, which is effectively a football fan engagement platform underpinned by mobile payment technology.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Building an Agile Stadium

11|24|14   |   3:54   |   (0) comments


Stadiums may be thousands of tons of concrete and steel, but they now need to be agile. Being at the stadium may not be as alluring as it once was. Sports franchises and stadium operators discuss how to get fans back.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei Helps ChinaCache Tackle Challenges in the Internet Industry

11|24|14   |   3:09   |   (0) comments


ChinaCache is China's largest content distribution network supplier. Huawei's CE12800 has provided ChinaCache with very strong support in its establishment of an infrastructure network.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Cefinity on Managed Security Services & Next-Generation Firewall

11|24|14   |   7:05   |   (0) comments


Cefinity is a cloud management service provider in Southeast Asia. Ivan Zhang, CEO of the company, discusses the implementation of security service management in the cloud era.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei's Agile Gateway in the Eyes of Cefinity

11|24|14   |   2:11   |   (0) comments


Cefinity is a managed service provider for enterprise networks. The company currently uses Huawei's AR series routers for the most complete range of functions. CEO Ivan Zhang speaks about the advantages of the AR series routers.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
CTO of Bus-Online Talks About Huawei's Agile Gateway

11|24|14   |   2:53   |   (0) comments


Bus-Online covers around 100 million users everyday. In addition to providing mobile TV, and advertising services to the public, Bus-Online has also entered the field of mobile Internet.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Amsterdam ArenA as an Agile Campus

11|24|14   |   3:31   |   (0) comments


The Amsterdam ArenA, home of the Ajax soccer team, can be a crowded space. ArenA has partnered with Huawei to work on bringing ample bandwidth to 53,000 people at the same time.
Upcoming Live Events
December 2, 2014, New York City
December 3, 2014, New York City
December 8-10, 2014, Reykjavik, Iceland
February 10, 2015, Atlanta, GA
April 14, 2015, New York City, NY
May 6, 2015, McCormick Convention Center, Chicago, IL
May 13-14, 2015, The Westin Peachtree, Atlanta, GA
June 9-10, 2015, Chicago, IL
Infographics
Irish Telecom outlines the rise of VoIP technology, including its adoption within businesses and their perception of its quality.
Hot Topics
Bell Labs Chief Slams 'Toy' Networks
Robert Clark, 11/19/2014
$38.3M: Ain't That a Kik in the SMS
Sarah Reedy, Senior Editor, 11/20/2014
Do You Have a 2020 Vision?
Dennis Mendyk, Vice President of Research, Heavy Reading, 11/21/2014
Operators Should Block Ads to Get Their Cut, Startup Says
Sarah Reedy, Senior Editor, 11/24/2014
$35B+ Spectrum Auction Dings Verizon, Shines Dish
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/24/2014
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed