& cplSiteName &

Judge to Blackberry Users: Drop Dead

The Martin Chronicles
The Martin Chronicles
The Martin Chronicles
2/3/2006
50%
50%

5:20 PM -- I've never been in Judge James R. Spencer's courtroom, and I hope I never will be.

Don't get me wrong: Judge Spencer is a distinguished jurist, a cum laude graduate of Harvard, first in his class at Howard University's divinity school, and the first African-American judge on the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. He worked in the civil rights movement in the late 1960s, and I have no doubt that his principles match his brilliance.

But Judge Spencer has got it wrong in the BlackBerry case. I'm not talking about the merits of NTP's patent infringement suit; I'm talking about Spencer's stubborn refusal to take into account the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office's moves to invalidate NTP's patents. This week the Patent Office issued a preliminary ruling that struck down the fifth and final patent at issue in the NTP-RIM lawsuit. NTP will appeal that ruling; a final decision could come in the next 60 days -- or it could take years. (See Final NTP Patent Struck Down.)

Judge Spencer won't wait. He's repeatedly made it clear he has no intention of letting the slow grinding of the Patent Office's machinery affect his ruling re: RIM. "Frankly, it's highly unlikely that I'm going to stay these proceedings," Spencer said from the bench back in November. "I don't run [the Patent Office's] business and they don't run mine."

Well, nobody's trying to restrict your judicial independence, Judge Spencer, but the outcome of the RIM case is not just "your business" -- it's the business of millions of Blackberry users, too, who use the devices every day to keep the wheels of American commerce spinning. RIM may very well have based its business on second-hand technology; it certainly wouldn't be the first successful tech company to do so. But if the Patent Office strikes down NTP's patents, as appears likely, there's no case here. Maybe it's worth waiting a while longer to find that out.

If Judge Spencer's impatience prevails, though, Crackberry addicts can refer to this handy guide to how to deal if the worst-case scenario happens.

— Richard Martin, Senior Editor, Unstrung

(4)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
daniel.taylor
50%
50%
daniel.taylor,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:07:19 AM
re: Judge to Blackberry Users: Drop Dead
Mr. Martin is making an assertion not supported by the facts at hand when he discusses "...Spencer's stubborn refusal to take into account the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office's moves to invalidate NTP's patents." The Court's November 30 decision is devoted entirely to the prospect of a PTO decision and appeals process.

That decision is available on Pacer. It's Document #423 for Case 3:01-cv-00767-JRS in the U.S. District Court of Eastern Virginia. Like NTP's 960 patent, it's a worthwhile read for anyone interested in the outcome of this case.
mwatson1111
50%
50%
mwatson1111,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:07:10 AM
re: Judge to Blackberry Users: Drop Dead
While I compliment Mr. Martin on his ability to write, his argument is extremely flawed. He is suggesting that RIM be rewarded for violating patents simply because there are a lot of customers and "maybe" some of the patents will be invalidated. So if I want to steal IP and make money, it's OK as long as I get lots of customers before someone finds out that I have violated the IP? After all, we don't want to upset customers? If there is someone you want to criticize, it should be RIM, not the judge. If you or RIM were really concerned about Blackberry customers, then start an editorial campaign aimed at having RIM settle with NTP. Or start an editorial campaign aimed at IP squatting scum (which is not-so-subtly inferred in your article). Why should the known violator be rewarded based soley on a presumption of public interest and the hope that their defensive campaign of patent invalidation will work? More importantly, why should a judge be criticized for doing his job and not becoming a 'consumer activist' judge. Let us all hope that you never have any influence over our patent office or judiciary.
RBMartin
50%
50%
RBMartin,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:06:52 AM
re: Judge to Blackberry Users: Drop Dead
Actually I think you've mischaracterized my argument. As I said, RIM may well have violated NTP's patents; if those patents are invalidated, though, there's no intellectual property to infringe upon, is there? This seems self-evident. I entirely agree with your larger points -- that RIM should settle, and that the patent system needs reforming.

....and thanks for the compliment.
mwatson1111
50%
50%
mwatson1111,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:06:37 AM
re: Judge to Blackberry Users: Drop Dead
I'm sorry if I mischaracterized your argument. I understand that the patents may become invalidated. Personally, I have equal distain for IP violators as I do squatters. I also understand that in a perfect world that patent validation and infringement judgements shouldn't be decoupled. Unfortunately, they are. My point was that given the current state of our legal system and this particular case, the victim should be given the benefit of doubt while the peripheral cases are being resolved, not the other way around as you suggest. That's all I meant.

...and you're most welcome.
More Blogs from The Martin Chronicles
Is this where Apple got its 'Multi-Touch' UI idea?
Former Qwest CEO set to stand trial starting March 19
Muni network controversy pales next to the mayor's private scandals
Billionaire might force a Moto showdown
One can't help but chortle
From The Founder
Download our complete guide to de-risking NFV deployment in 2016, including:
  • An eight-step strategy to deploying NFV safely, based on input from the companies that have already started virtualizing their production networks.
  • Interviews with leading executives at Colt, AT&T, Deutsche Telekom, Cisco, Nokia, ZTE, Ericsson and Heavy Reading.
  • Flash Poll
    Live Streaming Video
    Prepping for the Future: Upskill U Explained
    During this short kick-off video, Doug Webster, Vice President of Service Provider Marketing, Cisco, and Light Reading’s CEO & Founder Steve Saunders give an overview of Upskill U.
    LRTV Interviews
    Ditching the Slash & the Orchestration Wars

    5|3|16   |     |   (2) comments


    SDN and NFV have been inextricably bound with each other for so long that on a conceptual level, smooshing them together into one catch-all phrase – SDNFV – is now justifiable, according to Dan Pitt, executive director of the Open Networking Foundation (ONF). Light Reading spoke to Pitt at the NFV World Congress, where he explained that the next ...
    LRTV Custom TV
    ZTE TV Connect Highlights

    5|3|16   |     |   (0) comments


    ZTE gives us a tour of its booth and new products at TV Connect in London.
    LRTV Custom TV
    Deluxe's Unified Delivery Solution

    5|3|16   |     |   (0) comments


    Join Alan Breznick of Light Reading and visit the Deluxe booth at NAB! Here you'll find Deluxe's Unified Delivery Solution, OTT video, virtual reality, HDR, 4K and much more!
    LRTV Interviews
    Verizon Puts Gray Boxes in the Shade

    5|2|16   |   04:33   |   (1) comment


    When it comes to the white box trend, "gray" boxes, which have a slight proprietary twist, don't give service providers and end users the advantages they're seeking, according to Verizon's Vice President of Product and New Business Innovation Shawn Hakl.
    LRTV Custom TV
    Dealing With a Disrupted Video Market

    5|2|16   |     |   (0) comments


    Ericsson's Simon Frost discusses how traditional pay-TV providers can cope with the big changes wrought by the rise of OTT video and IP technology.
    LRTV Custom TV
    The VNF Responsibility of Red Hat

    5|2|16   |     |   (0) comments


    At MWC, Caroline Chappell of Heavy Reading visits the Red Hat booth and sits down with Chris Wright to talk about the responsibility the VNF needs to take on in order to ensure the operators get the carrier-grade performance they expect for their network.
    LRTV Interviews
    AT&T Expert on the Key Pillars of UC

    4|29|16   |   03:58   |   (0) comments


    Vishy Gopalakrishnan, AVP of product marketing at AT&T, talks about the three developments that are making unified communications and collaboration secure and reliable for enterprise users.
    LRTV Documentaries
    LRTV Report: Mobile Core Innovation

    4|28|16   |   25:32   |   (0) comments


    Hear from multiple industry experts from Deutsche Telekom, SK Telecom, Heavy Reading, Huawei, Cisco, Ericsson, Nokia, NEC and many more about developments in the mobile core as operators virtualize their IMS and evolved packet core systems and prepare for a 5G world.
    LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
    NFV World Congress Highlight

    4|26|16   |     |   (0) comments


    The highlight of the NFV World Congress contains exciting telecom news. Join us for an inside look at Huawei's ICT 2020 plan and its latest collaboration with industry leaders.
    LRTV Interviews
    Unified Comms Finds Its Voice

    4|25|16   |   03:44   |   (0) comments


    Peter Quinlan, VP of UCC Product Management at Tata Communications, talks about the evolution of the unified communications and collaboration services sector and how voice is now a big part of current developments.
    LRTV Documentaries
    So... What Do We Do Now?

    4|25|16   |   03:24   |   (0) comments


    After a long hiatus, Max Dingman, the CEO of a GeeGhiz, returns for a motivational board room pep talk.
    LRTV Documentaries
    NAB 2016 Highlights

    4|21|16   |     |   (0) comments


    Light Reading's Cable/Video Practice Leader Alan Breznick climbs down from the slots to tell us about the latest news in broadcast technology at NAB 2016 in Las Vegas.
    Upcoming Live Events
    May 23, 2016, Austin, TX
    May 23, 2016, Austin Convention Center
    May 24-25, 2016, Austin Convention Center, Austin, TX
    September 13-14, 2016, The Curtis Hotel, Denver, CO
    December 6-8, 2016,
    June 16-18, 2017, Austin Convention Center, Austin, TX
    All Upcoming Live Events
    Infographics
    A new survey conducted by Heavy Reading and TM Forum shows that CSPs around the world see the move to digital operations as a necessary part of their overall virtualization strategies.
    Hot Topics
    Ultra-Broadband Summit, Hong Kong
    Iain Morris, News Editor, 4/27/2016
    Amazon AWS Reports $2.6B Quarterly Revenue, Up a Colossal 64%
    Mitch Wagner, West Coast Bureau Chief, Light Reading, 4/28/2016
    WiCipedia: Woman Cards & Bitch Switches
    Sarah Thomas, Director, Women in Comms, 4/29/2016
    Rovi Reels in TiVo for $1.1B
    Mari Silbey, Senior Editor, Cable/Video, 4/29/2016
    FCC Poised to Re-Regulate Wholesale Access
    Carol Wilson, Editor-at-large, 4/28/2016
    Like Us on Facebook
    Twitter Feed
    BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
    In this latest installment of the CEO Chat series, Craig Labovitz, co-founder and CEO of Deepfield, sits down with Light Reading's Steve Saunders in Light Reading's New York City office to discuss how Deepfield fits in with the big data trend and more.
    Grant van Rooyen, president and CEO of Cologix, sits down with Steve Saunders, founder and CEO of Light Reading, in the vendor's New Jersey facility to offer an inside look at the company's success story and discuss the importance of security in the telecom industry.
    Animals with Phones
    Sloth Mail Click Here
    Sloth mail -- somehow even slower than snail mail.
    Live Digital Audio

    Of all the tech companies in the Valley, Intel has made the most aggressive commitment to building a diverse and inclusive workplace culture. It's doing so by taking concrete, measurable steps, making a large financial investment and through a commitment to complete transparency about its progress. In this radio show, WiC Director Sarah Thomas will be joined by Shlomit Weiss, Intel's Vice President, Data Center Group, and General Manager of Networking Engineering, who will share with us why Intel is tackling this huge challenge, how and to what effect. She will also discuss her unique experiences leading development of Client SOC development in the past and today leading development of all of the chipmaker's silicon hardware for networking IPs and discrete devices and managing a team of 600 engineers across Israel, Europe and the US.