News Analysis   More News Analysis

RAD Plans Ethernet Access Push

Israel's RAD Data Communications Ltd. has long sold a box that emulates leased lines over Ethernet connections. Now it's found a way of making it sound sort of sexy.

It's repositioning the box, called the IPmux, as part of a bunch of products that enable carriers to take advantage of Ethernet technology in access networks. Handling everything as Ethernet packets enables carriers to offer multiple services -- notably leased lines, voice connections, and IP services -- over a single access line at low cost, the company says.

The sort-of-sexy aspect of this is that carriers can deploy this kit irrespective of their progress in deploying Ethernet in their core metro networks. RAD's solution works in both environments, enabling carriers to migrate to a packet infrastucture in the heart of their networks at their own pace.

In order to make this happen, the IPmux becomes a multiservice network termination unit (NTU) that sits at customer sites, connected to TDM (time division multiplex) gear, such as a PBX, and IP equipment, such as routers. The NTU shunts all of the traffic from this equipment into Ethernet frames for transport over the access line, making sure that it keeps track of the packets containing TDM traffic, which need to be resynchronized at the other end.

At the other end, at the carrier's point of presence, a planned access aggregator device can be configured to work in various ways. The traffic can be reconstituted into TDM circuits and IP packets and fed into separate connections in existing SDH (not Sonet) infrastructure. Alternatively, the aggregator can be fitted with a different blade to carry the TDM and IP traffic over different virtual circuits in the carrier's ATM infrastructure. On the other hand, if the carrier has already deployed metro Ethernet technology, the traffic can be left in its Ethernet format.

The access aggregator is scheduled for shipment in the first quarter of 2004.

RAD isn't alone in coming up with this idea, although the nearest thing to it appears to be a collaboration between two vendors -- Axerra Networks Inc., which makes an access concentrator, and Engage Communications, which sells a box similar to RAD's NTU direct to enterprises. Axerra and Engage recently announced successful interoperability tests (see Axerra and Engage Test IP Kit) and are now working together on some projects, according to Mark Doyle, Engage's VP of marketing.

In some respects, this puts Axerra/Engage ahead of RAD in that their products are already shipping. However, Axerra's box is designed for use in metro Ethernet networks, not legacy Sonet metro networks, according to spokeswoman Lara Sedar, so it can't match RAD's migration story.

The fact that RAD is developing the boxes at both ends of the access line also enables it to add all sorts of extras that rely on sharing intelligence about what's happening on the network. This enables RAD to offer traffic management functions such as shaping and quality-of-service assurance, as well as automated provisioning and reconfiguration. It also includes VLAN stacking and OAM (operations, administration, and maintenance) functions.

And that's just for starters. RAD says its approach could be used to extend MPLS to the access aggregator or even into the customer site to support such things as Layer 2 LAN-interconnect services.

Right now, however, a lot of this is PowerPoint technology. The sexiest thing the company can do right now is to turn some of its ideas into real working products.

— Peter Heywood, Founding Editor, Light Reading

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
++++++
User Ranking
Wednesday June 18, 2003 4:19:19 PM
no ratings

There are several solutions for carrying TDM traffice over Ethernet that I have seen.
(1) TDMoIP chips - being worked on at IETF in PWE3 Group, from companies like Zarlink (www.zarlink.com)
(2) TDM over Ethernet chips - from companies like Teknovus (www.teknovus.com)
(3) Ethernet over SONET chips - use SONET to carry mixed traffic, from many companies
iseidner
User Ranking
Wednesday June 18, 2003 10:53:18 AM
no ratings
Regarding TDMoIP viability, there is a good web site www.tdmoip.com that lists a number of case studies as well as applications suitable for TDM emulation.
iseidner
User Ranking
Wednesday June 18, 2003 10:51:50 AM
no ratings
Regarding TDMoIP viability, there is a good web site www.tdmoip.com that lists a number of case studies as well as applications suitable for TDM emulation.
starman
User Ranking
Wednesday June 18, 2003 9:08:55 AM
no ratings
feke

are u referring to Overture
incidentally on the approaches of the different vendors
1.SONET VT (Overture Networks)
Put TDM into SONET Virtual Tributaries then use SONET encapsulation, requires SONET infrastructure and/or ADMs
This approach is being folded into the SONET over MPLS draft
2.CESoPSN (Axerra)
Very simple raw bit encapsulation, can even be implemented in SW if performance is not an issue
3.TDMoIP (RAD)
Put TDM into AAL1 or AAL2, then carry that over MPLS, can implement using standard AAL1/2 SARs
The PWE3 WG still cannot reach consensus on a way to compromise between the latter two approaches

I am not convinced TDM emulation can be a viable solution when maximum revenue generating traffic is TDM /Voice based

Is there any info available on the trials /deployments of these solutions ?
kevin mcintyre
User Ranking
Monday June 16, 2003 6:21:25 AM
no ratings
Rad does/did invest in Axerra. However, they are definitely in competition. Both having opposing methods for doing circuit emulation over IP/MPLS networks in PWE3.

Kevin McIntyre
Zarlink Semiconductor.
giladn
User Ranking
Monday June 16, 2003 3:39:43 AM
no ratings
The RAD group is the brainchild of Yehuda and Zohar Zisapel, one (entity, as they work together) of Israel's tech-gurus. they work by "incubating" a company in-house, then getting outside investments. they invest in all of their companies, so Axerra should be no different, but they do not always discolose that.

Radvision, Radware, Silicom and more - are public companies of the RAD group. all in all, there are 16 companies.

the most recent "exit" was the sale of Radlan to Marvell, which should bring the Zisapels some 10-30 mil$ out of the total 50-100 mil (considering milestones payments) of the whole deal's worth. over the years the Zisapels gave the company at least 15$ mil, out of the total 60.5$ mil it raised.
feke
User Ranking
Saturday June 14, 2003 12:46:43 PM
no ratings
They are not alone!

There are a few more players in this field as well.
One is Ericsson, another one is OKI, and also a small company that I can not remember the name of but that I've seen rumours about beeibg bought by Cisco not to long ago.

They are all doing quite similar things CESoIP/ATM and I know RAD and Axerra are involved in the PWE3 working-group within IETF.

There are little competition on this market now but there are still some hurdles on the way to ensure the operators to use this kind of technology in large scale...

//Feke
Peter Heywood
User Ranking
Saturday June 14, 2003 6:23:25 AM
no ratings
Yes, I missed that, and Axerra is listed as a member of the RAD Group on RAD's website:

http://www.rad.com/Home/0,6583,547,00.html

It's strange because RAD isn't listed as an investor on Axerra's website:

http://www.axerra.com/investors.asp

Tell me more!


BobbyMax
User Ranking
Saturday June 14, 2003 4:29:31 AM
no ratings
RAD has very good access equipment. Ethernet in the Fist Mile will play a very vital role in the near future. RAD is very well positioned to meet this challenge.
giladn
User Ranking
Friday June 13, 2003 4:53:35 PM
no ratings
what you failed to notice is that RAD is actually competing against itself, as Axerra's original name was IpRad, which tells you it's part of the RAD group.
LIGHT READING MARKET PLACE
Conferencing System
Enter Now to Win Two Polycom Video Conferencing Systems. Details Here!
Explore Microsoft Windows
Get valuable resources, advice, videos, and tips about Windows 7
Free Cell Phones
Get a New Cell Phone or Upgrade for Free. Smart Phones, Blackberries and more.
Avoid Risky, Single-Server Architecture
Improve Your Website Performance with Content Distribution Networks.
Attain Business Continuity with Wireless
Learn About Incorporating Mobile Equipment and Services into Your Business Plan
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Light Reading. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Podcasts SPONSORED CONTENT
Services Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent Communications service providers want to be able to bring new services to...
Rural Ops Bridge the Digital Divide - by Tellabs Tellabs helps IOCs build triple play networks
Driving Network Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent In order to deal with competitive pressures, the change in service models...
Back(haul) to the Future - by Tellabs Tellabs works with Vodafone to meet growing mobile broadband demands.
MRS Logistica - by Tellabs Tellabs helps MRS Logistica transform its existing, largely outdated TDM networks to IP.
Carrier Ethernet Offers an Enterprising Solution - by Tellabs What is VPLS and how does it work? Tellabs takes a closer look.
Swisscom’s Network Makeover - by Tellabs Fresh off the launch of 7.2 Mbps HSDPA, Swisscom sees 3G as an opportunity to launch a unifying ...
Telecom in Namibia - by Tellabs Tellabs helps Telecom Namibia with next-gen challenges
Companies
Alcatel-Lucent (5872), AT&T (1948), BellSouth (848), BT (1287), Cablevision (615), Cisco (5297), Comcast (1910), Cox Communications (858), Deutsche Telekom (807), eBay (Skype) (345), Ericsson (1617), France Telecom (964), Google (489), Huawei (1045), Intel (1127), Juniper (2022), Microsoft (1115), Motorola (1486), Nokia Siemens Networks (2645), Nortel (3956), NTT (173), Siemens (1359), Sprint (1059), Telefonica (439), Time Warner Cable (969), Verizon (2587), Vodafone (510), Yahoo (339)

Broadband
Access equipment (2169), Access technologies (2378), Broadband loop carriers / multiservice access nodes (388), Cable modem termination systems (CMTSs) (1104), Cable TV chips (286), DSL (2425), DSL chips (227), DSLAMs (703), Free-space optics (35), FTTx (3265), Gaming consoles (58), Gaming servers (22), Media adapters (23), Municipal networks (106), PON (1364), PON chips (217), Satellite (497), WiMax (880), Wireless LAN (354)

Cable Digital
Cable Modems (681), Cable/MSO equipment (2802), CableLabs (470), Compression (MPEG-2 and MPEG-4) (279), Docsis (1046), Embedded multimedia terminal adapters (E-MTAs) (213), Head-ends (233), PacketCable (129), QAM (307)

Chips, Components & Subsystems
ASICs & FPGAs (101), ATCA (480), ATM chips (13), Comm chips (2360), Dispersion compensators (149), Lasers (920), Modulators (163), Mux/demuxes (299), Network processors (933), Optical amplifiers (349), Optical channel monitors (92), Optical components (2824), Speciality fiber (94), Switches & OADMs (397), Transceivers (1247), Transmission fiber (419), Variable optical attenuators (139)

Ethernet
10-Gbit/s Ethernet switches (1454), Access devices (272), ATM switches (333), Circuit emulation (16), Converged access (103), Ethernet chips (573), Ethernet equipment (2212), Ethernet over copper (231), Ethernet PONs (160), Ethernet services (1909), Ethernet technologies (568), Multipoint (131), Multiservice edge equipment (143), Multiservice provisioning platforms (622), Multiservice switches (389), PBT (Provider Backbone Transport) (256), Point-to-point (139), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132)

IP & Convergence
B-RASs (229), Cell/WLAN (77), Compression equipment (13), Core routers (1294), DNS (56), Edge routers (1686), ENUM (53), Fixed/Mobile Convergence (485), GMPLS (76), IMS (1088), IMS Control Layer (27), IMS Service Layer (27), IP equipment (1224), IP software (381), IP technologies (1482), IPv6 (99), Layer 3 VPNs (194), MPLS (1774), MPLS (687), Multicast (36), P2P (258), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132), QOS (350), SIP (396), Traffic managers (808), Wireline/Wireless (59)

Mobile/Wireless
3G Evolution (175), Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Carrier WiFi (226), CDMA (3G) (367), Core Network (173), EV-DO (126), Femtocells (30), Fixed Wireless (Microwave, etc.) (71), Fourth Generation (4G) Wireless (70), GSM/EDGE (430), HSDPA/HSUPA (321), IMS Core (47), Long-Term Evolution (LTE) (188), Mobile Advertising (24), Mobile Music (31), Mobile TV (130), Mobile Video (65), Mobile WiMax/WiBro (92), Mobile/Wireless (5877), Packet Core (61), Radio Access Network (236), TD-SCDMA (Chinese 3G) (67), Transmission (38), Ultra-Mobile Broadband (UMB) (8), UMTS(3G) (340), Voice Core (21), WiMax (880), Wireless Backhaul (272), Wireless Chips (191), Wireless LAN (354)

Optical Networking
40-Gbit/s transmission (452), Core optical switches (760), CWDM (289), DWDM (1842), Long-haul WDM equipment (654), Metro optical switches, ROADMs (1173), Metro WDM equipment (773), Multiservice provisioning platforms & add/drop muxes (375), Optical equipment (2191), Optical switches & crossconnects (398), Optical technologies (417), Sonet/SDH (1036), Sonet/SDH chips (351), Wavelength services (305)

Security
Anti-virus (29), Denial-of-service attacks (44), Encryption (97), Endpoint security (22), Firewalls (61), Intrusion detection & prevention (45), IPSec VPN (801), Security (1835), SSL VPN (862), URL filtering (12), User authentication (24)

Services Software
Activation (415), Billing systems (761), Content/software downloads (231), Customer relationship management (231), Data Integrity (61), Element management systems (36), Fault management (69), Inventory management (153), Mediation systems (204), Messaging (231), Middleware (72), Mobile location (41), OSS (2584), Performance monitoring (335), Policy control (269), Provisioning (553), Revenue assurance & fraud management (334), Service delivery platforms (SDPs) (328), Service management (220), Service-oriented architectures (310), Services (2480), Web gateways (56), Web services (124), XML (51)

Test & Measurement (Sponsored by Etaliq Inc)
Access equipment Access test & measurement equipment (126), Comm chips Comm chips test & measurement equipment (29), Ethernet equipment Ethernet test & measurement equipment (170), IP equipment IP test & measurement equipment (122), MPLS MPLS test & measurement equipment (14), Optical components Optical components test & measurement equipment (113), Optical equipment Optical test & measurement equipment (886), OSS OSS test & measurement (1059), Sonet/SDH Sonet/SDH test & measurement equipment (1599), Test & measurement (1755), VOIP equipment VOIP test & measurement equipment (145)

Video (Sponsored by Ericsson Televisionary)
Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Broadcast video equipment (including encoding) (730), Content delivery network (CDN) (394), Content protection (270), DVRs (665), Internet Video (840), IPTV (3461), Middleware & business support systems (845), Set-top boxes (1624), Stored video servers (379), TV (3581), Video equipment (2448), Video services (4130), Video software (1349), Videophone (185), VOD (2635)

VOIP
Application servers (186), Centrex (198), Conferencing (78), Contact centers (38), Enhanced voice (34), Enterprise (637), Media gateways (357), Messaging (73), Presence management (43), Residential (835), Session border controllers (398), Signaling gateways (104), Softswitches (1090), VOIP chips (167), VOIP equipment (3423), VOIP services (3768), VOIP software (620), VOIP VPNs (28), Wholesale (220)