News Analysis   More News Analysis

AT&T Parties Like It's 1999

SAN JOSE, Calif. -- It's like the 90s all over again, as AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T) chairman and CEO Randall Stephenson said last night that AT&T has used up last decade's excess network capacity and is building for a flood of new demand coming in.

Stephenson was the guest of honor at a dinner organized by the Churchill Club, a Silicon Valley group that arranges talks by big-deal speakers to discuss issues of the day.

Pictures of the event are here, courtesy of Kimberly White/Getty Images:

Jersey Woman
Computer Sciences Corp., an event sponsor, also sponsors a Tour De France team (true).
Molly Sweeney of Xtelesis shows off the cycling jersey CSC gave away.

In his booming Oklahoma drawl, Stephenson took the opportunity to toss out some strong but predictable opinions: that regulation is bad, that the Verizon Wireless plan to open up the network isn't that big a deal, and that AT&T made the right decisions with U-verse.

In fact, let's get that last point out of the way. Stephenson reiterated the AT&T line that it wanted to go all-IP, and in doing so doesn't require the fat-pipe build that Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE: VZ) needs for FiOS. And he doesn't think the altered forecast is a big deal. (See AT&T Readjusts U-verse Forecast .)

A good portion of Stephenson's talk -- a discussion with editor Quentin Hardy of Forbes -- centered on the carrier's expected $18.5 billion in capital spending this year.

There's no doubt network demand is on the rise, Stephenson said, even referring to the euphoria of the last bubble. "The bandwidth glut of the 1990s, all those companies that took writeoffs -- it's gone," he said, adding later: "You're seeing what was promised in the 90s happen now."

Call minutes are even growing, to the tune of 10 percent a year on AT&T's network, with every indication that that rate will continue, Stephenson said. (It's mostly on the wireless side, of course.)

Like most of its fellow carriers, AT&T believes the industry is on the cusp of a massive wave of bandwidth demand.

"We are now obsoleting [sic] our national network," Stephenson said, referring to an overhaul of AT&T's IP backbone worldwide. That work includes four undersea builds, he noted.

Another data point: The IP transport facilities AT&T built in India last year "are now at 'exhaust.' "

Why should this surge be any different from the late-90s bubble? One factor to consider, he said, is that demand is still driven by "primitive" applications -- video that's not high-definition, or games that don't match the sophistication of Halo. Of course, counting on bigger, badder apps was part of what got telecom in so much trouble circa 2000, but for now, AT&T, like most of the industry, believes.

Asked what might threaten all this growth, Stephenson didn't cite the possibility that the predictions might be overly optimistic. Rather, he took the chance to go on a rant against government regulation.

"Keep the government away from all this, and investment will follow," he said.

Then again, AT&T wants the government's help in at least one timely matter. With telcos accused of being complicit in allowing illegal U.S. government wiretapping, AT&T and other carriers are asking Congress for indemnity against lawsuits.

Stephenson said AT&T's actions were just part of its "straightforward" policy towards law enforcement: AT&T honors any request from a legitimate agency showing legitimate cause. When an audience member pointed out Qwest Communications International Inc. (NYSE: Q) apparently decided the requests weren't legitimate, Stephenson parried, "You'd have to ask Qwest."

And he was unapologetic about asking for indemnity. "From our standpoint, if you follow the law, you should be protected by the law. We're in a position where the executive branch and the legislative branch of the government are in conflict, and we're caught in the middle of that."

Wireless world
Neither was Stephenson willing to give ground when asked about Verizon Wireless's recently announced plans to open its network, divorcing the handset from any particular service. (See Verizon Tears Down the 'Walled Garden' .)

"I thought it was overblown," he said of the reaction to Verizon's announcement. "The industry's headed that way, right? The wireline network, over time, became open-access."

Stephenson noted during the talk that open networks would emerge if the market demanded it -- but later refused to acknowledge Verizon's move as evidence that the market was demanding anything. After the talk, he told Light Reading that AT&T hasn't seen any demand for an arrangement like Verizon's.

In fact, AT&T's network is as "open" as they come, Stephenson claimed. "You can take a Nokia Corp. (NYSE: NOK) phone and connect it to our network, just put in your own SIM [subscriber identity module] card. We don't see customers do that. They want the phone subsidized."

Applications for AT&T's wireless network can be written in Java, he added, citing that as further evidence of the network's openness.

Stephenson likewise downplayed Google's Android platform, which aims to provide an open-source operating system and development environment for mobile devices. (See Google Makes Mobile Move, Google: Android's Not Evil, and Analysts: Google Plans Lack Substance .)

"Here are all these people that make large, carrier-class operating systems. And here's a new entrant who's never built a carrier-class operating system." Still, he said, AT&T will consider using Android if customers demand it.

Another wireless topic that came up a few times was the Apple Inc. (Nasdaq: AAPL) iPhone, which Stephenson of course took time to praise not just for its flashiness, but for its voice quality. He also noted a 3G version iPhone on the way. (See The 3G iPhone.)

Stephenson also confirmed AT&T will bid in the 700 MHz spectrum auction, noting that this shouldn't be a surprise. "I think all wireless carriers will. We refer to it as 'beachfront property.' It doesn't get any better than this."

— Craig Matsumoto, West Coast Editor, Light Reading

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
busted
User Ranking
Tuesday December 4, 2007 10:46:49 AM
no ratings
No Mention of this yet on LR?

http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5guSEQBOeibrt6c9KjbES2zonTQtwD8TAE8UG0
OldPOTS
User Ranking
Monday December 3, 2007 12:55:59 PM
IP does broadcast terribly without a good multicast capability. Broadcast is a one way Multicast to all subs. To be better than broadcast and use less BW, IP must support dynamic multicast, a very complex process.

That is why a BPON implementation (FIOS) uses a broadcast stream for TV and another Ethernet/IP stream (frequency) for Internet. This may prove to be a better choice than 'T's U-verse, primarily DSU IP, in the economic long run. Part of the 'T' argument for DSL was that it could be deployed quicker and easier, leveraging the copper in the ground. But 'T' moved too slowly using IP. Thus the comments.

OP

VZ also wants to move the third stream (voice) to Ethernet/IP also. IP theological reasons? Maybe, but the third stream must be handled in the network separatly, primarily on existing equipment (POTS) while costing some additional OPEX.
Craig Matsumoto
User Ranking
Monday December 3, 2007 11:43:49 AM
no ratings
miaroper -- Actually, that was just a joke for the caption. There really was a DPI question, but Stephenson was ready for it - he'd even bet someone $5 that it would be the first question out of the audience.

AT&T is interested in DPI for content protection, of course, but Stephenson said the company doesn't yet know where that model is going.
Raymond McConville
User Ranking
Monday December 3, 2007 10:06:57 AM
no ratings
FiOS does some IP type of things but its network is not all IP like AT&T's is. It is still broadcast, just like cable and not multicast which is what true IPTV is. It makes a big difference as far as bandwidth consumption, so for now AT&T can afford not to have Verizon's capacity, but that of course could change.
Tampico
User Ranking
Saturday December 1, 2007 1:23:31 PM
no ratings
Thanks for the clarification.Still, Stephenson's statement about IP makes no sense to me. AT& T certainly took the easy way out---trying to squeeze the last RED CENT out of that Copper! I feel that by 2010-11 the VZ choice with FTTH will really pay off for them, and T will be playing catch-up.I own them both so it makes for an interesting show.
brookseven
User Ranking
Saturday December 1, 2007 1:15:16 PM

U-Verse is a telco copper last mile not coax.

seven
Tampico
User Ranking
Saturday December 1, 2007 10:07:09 AM
no ratings
"Stephenson reiterated the AT&T line that it wanted to go all-IP, and in doing so doesn't require the fat-pipe build that Verizon Communications Inc. needs for FiOS." ***********This is a strange comment---U-verse is Coax Last-Mile and FiOS is FTTH, but aren't BOTH utilizing IP ??. This sounds like a defense of the less expensive U-verse approach that AT&T picked, yet we all know that nothing beats fiber, the VZ choice.
miaroper
User Ranking
Saturday December 1, 2007 8:15:11 AM
no ratings
So what was the issue with DPI that made Stephenson distinctly frosty ?
Craig Matsumoto
User Ranking
Friday November 30, 2007 12:45:50 PM
no ratings
To Stephenson's credit, he conveyed a genuine passion for what he does. He's a lively speaker who's willing to go easy on the buzzwords. People thanked him afterwards for his candor -- I wouldn't say he showed candor, considering how many answers were dodges or just toeing the company line. But he was much better than I'd expected -- these events can be such a snooze, and Stephenson kept the whole room engaged. (Kudos too to moderator Quentin Hardy of Forbes for throwing some curves in between the soft pitches.)
LIGHT READING MARKET PLACE
Polycom Sweepstakes
Win Two High Res Video Conferencing Systems. $8,000 Value. Enter Now to Win!
The Time is Now for FCoE
Join Cisco and its partners for a live informative webcast on 12/10/09
Want to BUY your Nortel Optical packs
TruePulse pays CASH for your surplus Nortel OM3500, OM5200 & OME6500 cards
Used and Refurbished Nortel Routers
Purchase Your Routers From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
Free e-Signature Site
Try it Now - It Only Takes Seconds! Used by Fortune 500 and Worldwide. Send & Sign Documents Online.
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Light Reading. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
Related Content
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Podcasts SPONSORED CONTENT
Services Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent Communications service providers want to be able to bring new services to...
Rural Ops Bridge the Digital Divide - by Tellabs Tellabs helps IOCs build triple play networks
Driving Network Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent In order to deal with competitive pressures, the change in service models...
Back(haul) to the Future - by Tellabs Tellabs works with Vodafone to meet growing mobile broadband demands.
MRS Logistica - by Tellabs Tellabs helps MRS Logistica transform its existing, largely outdated TDM networks to IP.
Carrier Ethernet Offers an Enterprising Solution - by Tellabs What is VPLS and how does it work? Tellabs takes a closer look.
Swisscom’s Network Makeover - by Tellabs Fresh off the launch of 7.2 Mbps HSDPA, Swisscom sees 3G as an opportunity to launch a unifying ...
Telecom in Namibia - by Tellabs Tellabs helps Telecom Namibia with next-gen challenges
Companies
Alcatel-Lucent (5872), AT&T (1948), BellSouth (848), BT (1287), Cablevision (615), Cisco (5297), Comcast (1910), Cox Communications (858), Deutsche Telekom (807), eBay (Skype) (345), Ericsson (1617), France Telecom (964), Google (489), Huawei (1045), Intel (1127), Juniper (2022), Microsoft (1115), Motorola (1486), Nokia Siemens Networks (2645), Nortel (3956), NTT (173), Siemens (1359), Sprint (1059), Telefonica (439), Time Warner Cable (969), Verizon (2587), Vodafone (510), Yahoo (339)

Broadband
Access equipment (2169), Access technologies (2378), Broadband loop carriers / multiservice access nodes (388), Cable modem termination systems (CMTSs) (1104), Cable TV chips (286), DSL (2425), DSL chips (227), DSLAMs (703), Free-space optics (35), FTTx (3265), Gaming consoles (58), Gaming servers (22), Media adapters (23), Municipal networks (106), PON (1364), PON chips (217), Satellite (497), WiMax (880), Wireless LAN (354)

Cable Digital
Cable Modems (681), Cable/MSO equipment (2802), CableLabs (470), Compression (MPEG-2 and MPEG-4) (279), Docsis (1046), Embedded multimedia terminal adapters (E-MTAs) (213), Head-ends (233), PacketCable (129), QAM (307)

Chips, Components & Subsystems
ASICs & FPGAs (101), ATCA (480), ATM chips (13), Comm chips (2360), Dispersion compensators (149), Lasers (920), Modulators (163), Mux/demuxes (299), Network processors (933), Optical amplifiers (349), Optical channel monitors (92), Optical components (2824), Speciality fiber (94), Switches & OADMs (397), Transceivers (1247), Transmission fiber (419), Variable optical attenuators (139)

Ethernet
10-Gbit/s Ethernet switches (1454), Access devices (272), ATM switches (333), Circuit emulation (16), Converged access (103), Ethernet chips (573), Ethernet equipment (2212), Ethernet over copper (231), Ethernet PONs (160), Ethernet services (1909), Ethernet technologies (568), Multipoint (131), Multiservice edge equipment (143), Multiservice provisioning platforms (622), Multiservice switches (389), PBT (Provider Backbone Transport) (256), Point-to-point (139), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132)

IP & Convergence
B-RASs (229), Cell/WLAN (77), Compression equipment (13), Core routers (1294), DNS (56), Edge routers (1686), ENUM (53), Fixed/Mobile Convergence (485), GMPLS (76), IMS (1088), IMS Control Layer (27), IMS Service Layer (27), IP equipment (1224), IP software (381), IP technologies (1482), IPv6 (99), Layer 3 VPNs (194), MPLS (1774), MPLS (687), Multicast (36), P2P (258), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132), QOS (350), SIP (396), Traffic managers (808), Wireline/Wireless (59)

Mobile/Wireless
3G Evolution (175), Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Carrier WiFi (226), CDMA (3G) (367), Core Network (173), EV-DO (126), Femtocells (30), Fixed Wireless (Microwave, etc.) (71), Fourth Generation (4G) Wireless (70), GSM/EDGE (430), HSDPA/HSUPA (321), IMS Core (47), Long-Term Evolution (LTE) (188), Mobile Advertising (24), Mobile Music (31), Mobile TV (130), Mobile Video (65), Mobile WiMax/WiBro (92), Mobile/Wireless (5877), Packet Core (61), Radio Access Network (236), TD-SCDMA (Chinese 3G) (67), Transmission (38), Ultra-Mobile Broadband (UMB) (8), UMTS(3G) (340), Voice Core (21), WiMax (880), Wireless Backhaul (272), Wireless Chips (191), Wireless LAN (354)

Optical Networking
40-Gbit/s transmission (452), Core optical switches (760), CWDM (289), DWDM (1842), Long-haul WDM equipment (654), Metro optical switches, ROADMs (1173), Metro WDM equipment (773), Multiservice provisioning platforms & add/drop muxes (375), Optical equipment (2191), Optical switches & crossconnects (398), Optical technologies (417), Sonet/SDH (1036), Sonet/SDH chips (351), Wavelength services (305)

Security
Anti-virus (29), Denial-of-service attacks (44), Encryption (97), Endpoint security (22), Firewalls (61), Intrusion detection & prevention (45), IPSec VPN (801), Security (1835), SSL VPN (862), URL filtering (12), User authentication (24)

Services Software
Activation (415), Billing systems (761), Content/software downloads (231), Customer relationship management (231), Data Integrity (61), Element management systems (36), Fault management (69), Inventory management (153), Mediation systems (204), Messaging (231), Middleware (72), Mobile location (41), OSS (2584), Performance monitoring (335), Policy control (269), Provisioning (553), Revenue assurance & fraud management (334), Service delivery platforms (SDPs) (328), Service management (220), Service-oriented architectures (310), Services (2480), Web gateways (56), Web services (124), XML (51)

Test & Measurement (Sponsored by Etaliq Inc)
Access equipment Access test & measurement equipment (126), Comm chips Comm chips test & measurement equipment (29), Ethernet equipment Ethernet test & measurement equipment (170), IP equipment IP test & measurement equipment (122), MPLS MPLS test & measurement equipment (14), Optical components Optical components test & measurement equipment (113), Optical equipment Optical test & measurement equipment (886), OSS OSS test & measurement (1059), Sonet/SDH Sonet/SDH test & measurement equipment (1599), Test & measurement (1755), VOIP equipment VOIP test & measurement equipment (145)

Video (Sponsored by Ericsson Televisionary)
Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Broadcast video equipment (including encoding) (730), Content delivery network (CDN) (394), Content protection (270), DVRs (665), Internet Video (840), IPTV (3461), Middleware & business support systems (845), Set-top boxes (1624), Stored video servers (379), TV (3581), Video equipment (2448), Video services (4130), Video software (1349), Videophone (185), VOD (2635)

VOIP
Application servers (186), Centrex (198), Conferencing (78), Contact centers (38), Enhanced voice (34), Enterprise (637), Media gateways (357), Messaging (73), Presence management (43), Residential (835), Session border controllers (398), Signaling gateways (104), Softswitches (1090), VOIP chips (167), VOIP equipment (3423), VOIP services (3768), VOIP software (620), VOIP VPNs (28), Wholesale (220)