News Analysis   More News Analysis

AT&T Holders Cry Foul Over Exec Pay

April 27, 2007 | Raymond McConville | Comments (8)
no ratings

AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T) announced this morning at its shareholders meeting that Edward Whitacre would be stepping down as chairman and chief executive. (See AT&T's Whitacre Cedes Throne.) But that's not all that was on the docket today.

Stockholder Proposal D during today's meeting called for the adoption of a policy that would give the shareholders advisory voting powers in the approval of executive pay. "We believe current rules governing senior executive compensation do not give shareholders sufficient influence over pay practices - nor do they give the Board adequate feedback from the owners of the company," says the shareholder proposal.

Not surprisingly, AT&T's board of directors recommended the rejection of this proposal, which later happened by a vote of 56.2 percent to 43.8 percent.

Whitacre's compensation was cited as Exhibit A in demonstrating how AT&T execs were excessively compensated. Disgruntled shareholders pointed to a study conducted by the Corporate Library that cited AT&T as being one of 11 large corporations where the disconnect between pay and performance is severe.

"The study notes that over the five fiscal years through 2005, CEO Edward Whitacre received $85.2 million in compensation, while total shareholder return was negative 40.3%. The Corporate Library accordingly gave AT&T's Board a 'D' for overall effectiveness," argued the shareholders.

All of this came on the same day it was reported that Whitacre would be receiving a massive $158 million retirement package. The announcement has sparked yet another round of discussions over the huge compensations that executives in corporate America have been receiving as of late.

AT&T could not be reached for comment on this story

— Raymond McConville, Reporter, Light Reading

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
Scott Raynovich
User Ranking
Tuesday May 1, 2007 4:51:07 AM
no ratings
The result was posted in the orginal story. There is no way you can "overhype" a $158M retirement package.

56% to 44% vote is an extremely close vote for a corproate proxy vote, when you consider the advantages the board of directors has in lining up all their lackeys and gathering insider votes.

If anything, to me, this 44% indicates there was serious shareholder outcry on this.
Craig Matsumoto
User Ranking
Tuesday May 1, 2007 2:05:26 AM
no ratings
?? - Not sure what you mean, lap_work. We've got the result of the vote right there in the story.
lap_work
User Ranking
Tuesday May 1, 2007 12:08:56 AM
So..., the measure failed - 56% against, 44% for.
So, T execs will continue to get $100M plus paydays,
but LR doesn't report the results.

Typical Light Reading -- all hype -- few facts
wrt what actually happened.
thierryh
User Ranking
Monday April 30, 2007 4:50:56 AM
it's interesting to note that just now in France, similar stories of highly paid (but "only" between €5M and €10M) retiring top execs gets to the news' highlights and many politicians are expressing their views on that matter...

and for a 10-times more "offending" retiring package of Whitacre, the news hardly reach the top of business news and do not seem to make politicians react much...
DarkWriting
User Ranking
Saturday April 28, 2007 12:55:38 PM
DEATH TO CAPITALISM!!!!


BTW, it's could've or could have NOT could of, SHEESH! Also it's their, there or they're, you all can figure out which is the right one for your sentence!
brookseven
User Ranking
Saturday April 28, 2007 11:29:16 AM

Actually AT&T Park in San Francisco was built by the SF Giants. AT&T just has the naming rights that it picked up through Pac Bell.

I am just confused why an executive gets a "package". When I retire, I get a handshake and a good luck. As a shareholder, I want Ed Whitacre to get $0 and no benefits - just like any other employee.

seven
rjmcmahon
User Ranking
Friday April 27, 2007 8:24:45 PM
if i owned T, i'd by hopping mad right now.

Yeah. I'm hopping mad too. They're shoving this cost saving U-verse crap down our throats while Whitacre walks away with the cash that could of laid down the lines for 150,000 or so. I guess our superheros need their rewards and, unfortunately, *these* superheros really don't give a shit about anybody else.

Hey, let's go raid the electric fund to build another stadium!! That's what the public wants, right? Doesn't matter, they'll buy it.
chips_ahoy
User Ranking
Friday April 27, 2007 8:05:02 PM
the whole stock options blow up is chump change compared to this. when are we going to realize that chairman and ceo have conflicting interests and therefore these roles that should not be executed by the same individual.

if i owned T, i'd by hopping mad right now.
LIGHT READING MARKET PLACE
Free Network Management Tool!
Find and fix problems 70% faster, even through the cloud. Free management tool!
Used and Refurbished Cisco Switches
Purchase Your Switches From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
Free Cell Phones
Get a New Cell Phone or Upgrade for Free. Smart Phones, Blackberries and more.
Want to BUY your Nortel Optical packs
TruePulse pays CASH for your surplus Nortel OM3500, OM5200 & OME6500 cards
Used and Refurbished Nortel Switches
Purchase Your Switches From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Light Reading. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
Ethernet Academy Ad
Related Content
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Podcasts SPONSORED CONTENT
Services Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent Communications service providers want to be able to bring new services to...
Rural Ops Bridge the Digital Divide - by Tellabs Tellabs helps IOCs build triple play networks
Driving Network Transformation - by Alcatel-Lucent In order to deal with competitive pressures, the change in service models...
Back(haul) to the Future - by Tellabs Tellabs works with Vodafone to meet growing mobile broadband demands.
MRS Logistica - by Tellabs Tellabs helps MRS Logistica transform its existing, largely outdated TDM networks to IP.
Carrier Ethernet Offers an Enterprising Solution - by Tellabs What is VPLS and how does it work? Tellabs takes a closer look.
Swisscom’s Network Makeover - by Tellabs Fresh off the launch of 7.2 Mbps HSDPA, Swisscom sees 3G as an opportunity to launch a unifying ...
Telecom in Namibia - by Tellabs Tellabs helps Telecom Namibia with next-gen challenges
Companies
Alcatel-Lucent (5872), AT&T (1948), BellSouth (848), BT (1287), Cablevision (615), Cisco (5297), Comcast (1910), Cox Communications (858), Deutsche Telekom (807), eBay (Skype) (345), Ericsson (1617), France Telecom (964), Google (489), Huawei (1045), Intel (1127), Juniper (2022), Microsoft (1115), Motorola (1486), Nokia Siemens Networks (2645), Nortel (3956), NTT (173), Siemens (1359), Sprint (1059), Telefonica (439), Time Warner Cable (969), Verizon (2587), Vodafone (510), Yahoo (339)

Broadband
Access equipment (2169), Access technologies (2378), Broadband loop carriers / multiservice access nodes (388), Cable modem termination systems (CMTSs) (1104), Cable TV chips (286), DSL (2425), DSL chips (227), DSLAMs (703), Free-space optics (35), FTTx (3265), Gaming consoles (58), Gaming servers (22), Media adapters (23), Municipal networks (106), PON (1364), PON chips (217), Satellite (497), WiMax (880), Wireless LAN (354)

Cable Digital
Cable Modems (681), Cable/MSO equipment (2802), CableLabs (470), Compression (MPEG-2 and MPEG-4) (279), Docsis (1046), Embedded multimedia terminal adapters (E-MTAs) (213), Head-ends (233), PacketCable (129), QAM (307)

Chips, Components & Subsystems
ASICs & FPGAs (101), ATCA (480), ATM chips (13), Comm chips (2360), Dispersion compensators (149), Lasers (920), Modulators (163), Mux/demuxes (299), Network processors (933), Optical amplifiers (349), Optical channel monitors (92), Optical components (2824), Speciality fiber (94), Switches & OADMs (397), Transceivers (1247), Transmission fiber (419), Variable optical attenuators (139)

Ethernet
10-Gbit/s Ethernet switches (1454), Access devices (272), ATM switches (333), Circuit emulation (16), Converged access (103), Ethernet chips (573), Ethernet equipment (2212), Ethernet over copper (231), Ethernet PONs (160), Ethernet services (1909), Ethernet technologies (568), Multipoint (131), Multiservice edge equipment (143), Multiservice provisioning platforms (622), Multiservice switches (389), PBT (Provider Backbone Transport) (256), Point-to-point (139), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132)

IP & Convergence
B-RASs (229), Cell/WLAN (77), Compression equipment (13), Core routers (1294), DNS (56), Edge routers (1686), ENUM (53), Fixed/Mobile Convergence (485), GMPLS (76), IMS (1088), IMS Control Layer (27), IMS Service Layer (27), IP equipment (1224), IP software (381), IP technologies (1482), IPv6 (99), Layer 3 VPNs (194), MPLS (1774), MPLS (687), Multicast (36), P2P (258), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (132), QOS (350), SIP (396), Traffic managers (808), Wireline/Wireless (59)

Mobile/Wireless
3G Evolution (175), Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Carrier WiFi (226), CDMA (3G) (367), Core Network (173), EV-DO (126), Femtocells (30), Fixed Wireless (Microwave, etc.) (71), Fourth Generation (4G) Wireless (70), GSM/EDGE (430), HSDPA/HSUPA (321), IMS Core (47), Long-Term Evolution (LTE) (188), Mobile Advertising (24), Mobile Music (31), Mobile TV (130), Mobile Video (65), Mobile WiMax/WiBro (92), Mobile/Wireless (5877), Packet Core (61), Radio Access Network (236), TD-SCDMA (Chinese 3G) (67), Transmission (38), Ultra-Mobile Broadband (UMB) (8), UMTS(3G) (340), Voice Core (21), WiMax (880), Wireless Backhaul (272), Wireless Chips (191), Wireless LAN (354)

Optical Networking
40-Gbit/s transmission (452), Core optical switches (760), CWDM (289), DWDM (1842), Long-haul WDM equipment (654), Metro optical switches, ROADMs (1173), Metro WDM equipment (773), Multiservice provisioning platforms & add/drop muxes (375), Optical equipment (2191), Optical switches & crossconnects (398), Optical technologies (417), Sonet/SDH (1036), Sonet/SDH chips (351), Wavelength services (305)

Security
Anti-virus (29), Denial-of-service attacks (44), Encryption (97), Endpoint security (22), Firewalls (61), Intrusion detection & prevention (45), IPSec VPN (801), Security (1835), SSL VPN (862), URL filtering (12), User authentication (24)

Services Software
Activation (415), Billing systems (761), Content/software downloads (231), Customer relationship management (231), Data Integrity (61), Element management systems (36), Fault management (69), Inventory management (153), Mediation systems (204), Messaging (231), Middleware (72), Mobile location (41), OSS (2584), Performance monitoring (335), Policy control (269), Provisioning (553), Revenue assurance & fraud management (334), Service delivery platforms (SDPs) (328), Service management (220), Service-oriented architectures (310), Services (2480), Web gateways (56), Web services (124), XML (51)

Test & Measurement (Sponsored by Etaliq Inc)
Access equipment Access test & measurement equipment (126), Comm chips Comm chips test & measurement equipment (29), Ethernet equipment Ethernet test & measurement equipment (170), IP equipment IP test & measurement equipment (122), MPLS MPLS test & measurement equipment (14), Optical components Optical components test & measurement equipment (113), Optical equipment Optical test & measurement equipment (886), OSS OSS test & measurement (1059), Sonet/SDH Sonet/SDH test & measurement equipment (1599), Test & measurement (1755), VOIP equipment VOIP test & measurement equipment (145)

Video (Sponsored by Ericsson Televisionary)
Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (189), Broadcast video equipment (including encoding) (730), Content delivery network (CDN) (394), Content protection (270), DVRs (665), Internet Video (840), IPTV (3461), Middleware & business support systems (845), Set-top boxes (1624), Stored video servers (379), TV (3581), Video equipment (2448), Video services (4130), Video software (1349), Videophone (185), VOD (2635)

VOIP
Application servers (186), Centrex (198), Conferencing (78), Contact centers (38), Enhanced voice (34), Enterprise (637), Media gateways (357), Messaging (73), Presence management (43), Residential (835), Session border controllers (398), Signaling gateways (104), Softswitches (1090), VOIP chips (167), VOIP equipment (3423), VOIP services (3768), VOIP software (620), VOIP VPNs (28), Wholesale (220)