Light Reading

Comcast: DTAs Can Be 'Force-Tuned'

Jeff Baumgartner
LR Cable News Analysis
Jeff Baumgartner

Digital Terminal Adapter (DTA) devices have no built-in return-path capabilities, making them unable to directly access video on demand (VoD) or other "two-way" cable services, but it turns out the simple channel-zappers can receive network instructions to "force-tune" to a particular channel.

And that could spark a debate over whether the devices should be viewed as "advanced" in the eyes of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) , as it chews on newly proposed CableCARD rules.

Comcast Corp. (Nasdaq: CMCSA, CMCSK), in reply comments submitted last week, argued that this force-tuning capability -- already used to deliver Emergency Alert System (EAS) messages to DTAs -- doesn't make those inherently one-way devices interactive or somehow advanced.

How the FCC ends up viewing DTA force-tuning is important because the Commission is considering a blanket exemption for HD-capable versions. That would give MSOs the green light to buy and deploy them without worrying about obtaining separate waivers to sidestep the integrated set-top security ban of July 2007. (See FCC Inches Towards Net-Agnostic Gateways and FCC Chews on HD-DTA Exemption .)

MSOs such as Comcast, which has already deployed millions of standard-definition DTAs for its Project Cavalry analog reclamation initiative, are eager to use the HD-DTA as a low-cost option (unit pricing is expected to be less than $50 when volumes ramp up). (See Comcast's $1B Bandwidth Plan , Cable ONE Seeks $50 HD Box, and Comcast Lights Up DTA Encryption .)

However, the FCC, which has already awarded several waivers for SD-DTAs with integrated security, could forgo any blanket HD-DTA exemptions if it decides that the hi-def versions are "advanced" boxes. Key to the SD-DTA waivers was the notion that they are limited, one-way digital-to-analog video converter boxes that don't support traditional DVR services, come with native Internet connections, or support other relatively sophisticated features. (See Comcast's $1B Bandwidth Plan , FCC Believes in Evolution-ary DTAs, and Huawei Gets Box Break at the FCC .)

CableOne , still the only MSO to get a waiver to use HD-DTAs, has already argued that HD services should no longer be considered advanced because they represent critical competitive table stakes. (See Scoop! Cable ONE Makes HD-DTA Picks , and HD No Longer an 'Advanced' Service?)

The force-tuning issue comes up because Comcast acknowledged, in its comments, that the capability is in DTAs, for EAS delivery, and "could theoretically be extended to other services." But that doesn't mean the DTAs are two-way devices, the MSO argued, because the boxes themselves "cannot function as interactive devices."

As an example of one of those other services, Comcast has been asked if the iPad-driven Xfinity remote control, demonstrated at The Cable Show in May, could work with DTAs. Technically speaking, the app could be mapped to the boxes, but Comcast hasn't made any formal plans to do that. (See To Xfinity... & Beyond!.)

"This service is being developed for our two-way digital set-top boxes, not for DTAs," Comcast told the FCC. It might be possible to adapt the app for DTAs, but that "would require significant new standardization and development work."

Even if such work was done, Comcast holds that the DTA wouldn't count as an interactive device, since customers would still have to send requests to the headend via a discrete device (e.g., an iPad) using a separate Internet connection.

"This would be analogous to the old one-way converter boxes that could receive pay-per-view content if the customer placed an order for the content via a phone call to the cable operator. It cannot be credibly argued that this made the converters 'two-way,'" Comcast said.

The FCC isn't expected to vote on the new CableCARD rule changes until later this year, but some early comments have come out against any further agency dispensation for DTAs with baked in security.

For example, Beyond Broadband Technology LLC (BBT) , a cable consortium backed by some Tier 2 and Tier 3 MSOs, which has developed a downloadable security platform, has argued that one-way boxes can "directly or indirectly do essentially everything a two-way device can do, such as provide an electronic program." BBT also questioned the historic "no-DVR" restriction on DTAs, holding that it could be circumvented with a whole-home recording device or a "modular DVR add-on device." (See Policy Watch: TiVo, Cable Trade SDV Barbs and BBT Notches First Install .)

Public Knowledge claims the HD-DTA exemption would undermine the FCC's "common reliance goals" to help develop a retail market. Comcast (and the bulk of the US cable industry) has already poked a hole in that argument, noting that common reliance is already achieved because more than 21 million CableCARD-equipped boxes have been deployed. (See CableCARD Update .)

Although there's no indication that consumer electronics firms intend to sell DTAs directly to consumers, Panasonic Corp. (NYSE: PC), which favors the HD-DTA exemption, has asked that the FCC require cable to adopt standards that could underpin a retail market for such boxes by July 2011.

Comcast said it's willing to work with Panasonic and the rest of the cable industry on DTA retail efforts, "but does not support any new 'common reliance' mandate in this area."

— Jeff Baumgartner, Site Editor, Light Reading Cable

(3)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View        ADD A COMMENT
Jeff Baumgartner
Jeff Baumgartner,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:30:44 PM
re: Comcast: DTAs Can Be 'Force-Tuned'

The ability to force-tune a one-way cable device sounds pretty close in function to the way Moto- and Cisco-made Tuning Adapters allow CableCARD-based TiVo and Moxi one-way boxes to access a cable operator's switched digital video channels.  I suppose Tuning Adapter was a decidedly friendlier name than going with something like the "SDV Force-Tuner". If so, I can't see why DTAs can't access switched channels, too, save for all that icky integration work that would probably be required. JB  



User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:30:41 PM
re: Comcast: DTAs Can Be 'Force-Tuned'

I suppose one could also argue that a pager is the equivalent of an iPhone - after all, a pager can receive a message from the network, and the person receiving the page can then go to a telephone and return that message, so how is a pager any different from an iPhone?

The logic of this argument strains all credibility...

Jeff Baumgartner
Jeff Baumgartner,
User Rank: Light Beer
12/5/2012 | 4:30:37 PM
re: Comcast: DTAs Can Be 'Force-Tuned'

I think that's part of the reason why Comcast is addressing that now and being  proactive on it... because it would be real tough to convince anyone (even at the FCC) that force-tuning would make a DTA two-way, but you gotta figure that someone  (hello, CEA) is going to try on that argument during this proceeding. JB

From The Founder
Steve Saunders provides an overview of white box networking and introduces a new "slim line" version of the OSI 7-layer model.
Flash Poll
Live Streaming Video
CLOUD / MANAGED SERVICES: Prepping Ethernet for the Cloud
Moderator: Ray LeMaistre Panelists: Jeremy Bye, Leonard Sheahan
Between the CEOs
Centec on Ethernet Switching

11|26|15   |   09:58   |   (0) comments

Centec CEO James Sun talks to Steve Saunders about Ethernet switching and the white box revolution.
LRTV Custom TV
Delivering Service Agility in the Virtualization Era

11|25|15   |   5.41   |   (0) comments

Interview with Massimo Fatato, WW OSS Business Lead, Hewlett Packard Enterprise.
Wagner’s Ring
How Might Open Source Fail?

11|24|15   |     |   (10) comments

Open source, SDN, and NFV are looking inevitable – but performance, standards proliferation and regulatory capture could derail the movement.
LRTV Custom TV
NFV Lifecycle Orchestration – a Fresh Vision for Telco

11|23|15   |   6.40   |   (0) comments

Simon Osborne, CTO Comptel, and Heavy Reading's Caroline Chappell reveal the business impacts of new SDN and NFV, and what the term service orchestration actually means. Together they define Lifecycle Service Orchestration and how the virtualized future will look for telecoms operators.
Between the CEOs
Cisco's Virtual Role in Saudi

11|20|15   |   12:15   |   (2) comments

Light Reading founder and CEO Steve Saunders talks with Zayan Sadek, Regional Manager at Cisco Systems, about the competitive communications services market and advance of virtualization in Saudi Arabia.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei Leads With Kubernetes for Cloud PaaS

11|19|15   |   08:26   |   (0) comments

Huawei is looking to Kubernetes as a key tool for building robust open source technologies for customers and partners, said Ying Xiong, chief architect of cloud platform at Huawei, in an interview with Light Reading West Coast Bureau Chief Mitch Wagner at the recent Kubecon conference.
Women in Comms Introduction Videos
WiC in London: The Highlight Reel

11|19|15   |   5:33   |   (1) comment

NetCracker's Mervat El Dabae headlines an inspiring morning in London with help from leading women from Vodafone, TalkTalk, Hyperoptics and Ciena.
LRTV Documentaries
Why Saudi's So Hot for New Tech

11|19|15   |   05:07   |   (0) comments

Light Reading's Steve Saunders reports from Saudi Arabia, a hyper-competitive market desperate to embrace the next generation of communications technologies and services.
LRTV Custom TV
Why Data Models Deliver More Value Than Information Models

11|19|15   |   5.08   |   (0) comments

Stefan Vallin argues that more automation is needed to manage end-to-end services and the hybrid networks they run on, and that data models are key to achieving this.
Telecom Innovators Video Showcase
SDN Management & Orchestration in the WAN

11|17|15   |   7.20   |   (0) comments

Carol Wilson and Packet Design CTO Cengiz Alaettinoglu discuss CSPs' SDN service delivery and assurance requirements. Learn about a modular approach to building automated control, orchestration and management functions for the WAN that are policy- and analytics-driven.
LRTV Custom TV
Flash Networks: Optimizing for Radio Spectral Efficiency

11|17|15   |   3:34   |   (0) comments

Today most optimization vendors only focus on optimizing voice or data. Ofer Gottfried, Flash Networks' CTO, shows how improving data throughput and maximizing spectral efficiency reduces capital and operating expenses while also providing a platform for user engagement.
LRTV Custom TV
Making Pay-TV User Experiences Millennial-Friendly

11|16|15   |   6:42   |   (0) comments

The unique challenge of reaching and engaging Millennials is driving pay-TV video experience transformation that can include higher quality UIs, viewing of multiple content streams at once and seamless transitions between handheld devices and the television.
Allot MobileTrends Report H2/2015 reveals how daily online behavior can be used to discover smarter ways to profile customers and propose valuable, real-time offers to them.
Hot Topics
Samsung to Sell Wireless Networking Unit?
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/23/2015
Samsung: No Sale of Wireless Unit
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/25/2015
How Might Open Source Fail?
Mitch Wagner, West Coast Bureau Chief, Light Reading, 11/24/2015
Sprint to Get $1.2B From New Leasing Venture
Dan Jones, Mobile Editor, 11/23/2015
Networking Shines in HP's Gloomy Final Earnings
Mitch Wagner, West Coast Bureau Chief, Light Reading, 11/25/2015
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
December 15, 2015
Virtualizing Cable Services
Webinar Archive
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
Centec CEO James Sun talks to Steve Saunders about Ethernet switching and the white box revolution.
Light Reading founder and CEO Steve Saunders talks with Zayan Sadek, Regional Manager at Cisco Systems, about the competitive communications services market and advance of virtualization in Saudi Arabia.
Cats with Phones
Can't Find the Phone on Thanksgiving? Click Here
Check under the cat! (hint: bottom right)
Live Digital Audio

Broadband speeds are ramping up across Europe as the continent, at its own pace, follows North America towards a gigabit society. But there are many steps to take on the road to gigabit broadband availability and a number of technology options that can meet the various requirements of Europe’s high-speed fixed broadband network operators. During this radio show we will look at some of the catalysts for broadband network investments and examine the menu of technology options on offer, including vectoring and for copper plant evolution and the various deployment possibilities for FTTH/B.