Light Reading
Why it's time to bring clarity to the SDN controller northbound interface debate.

Compass Check: ONF & the Northbound API(s)

Dan Pitt
Column
Dan Pitt
11/6/2013
50%
50%

The Open Networking Foundation (ONF) turned a lot of heads in October with the announcement of a Northbound Interfaces (NBI) Working Group.

While we're always glad to draw more attention to the benefits of Software-Defined Networking (SDN), we want to be sure that the industry truly understands why we are looking north and how this new Working Group fits into the overall focus of Open Networking Foundation (ONF). This is especially important since we have been so vocal for more than two years about why we are not standardizing the northbound API. (Believe me, I've taken a lot of flak for that, but steadfastly resisted.)

ONF's mission is to accelerate the adoption of open SDN. To us, SDN includes both the OpenFlow substrate and the enablement of applications and services above it. This means that while our NBI Working Group is new, our work with the Northbound Interface is not.

Back in June 2011, we received an inquiry from another industry group asking if we planned to standardize the Northbound API. "Goodness, no," we replied, but we neglected to say why.

"Oh good," they replied. "Then we will."

Damage control included explaining why no one should, because:

  • No one had enough experience with OpenFlow controllers to know what to standardize
  • This period of innovative experimentation was important for learning and we did not want to stifle it
  • Anyone who tried would surely get it wrong
  • There won't be just one NBI anyway, and
  • That's not how software artifacts get standardized.

Fortunately, they listened.

Since then, the industry has built a considerable body of experience. With a solid OpenFlow substrate, the attention now shifts to include the software and services that the foundation enables. We have seen a greater demand from developers of application, orchestration, and management software for assistance in understanding NBIs as a critical component of a complete SDN solution.

So in the fall of 2012 we began looking at NBIs in the form of the Architecture and Framework Working Group's study of existing SDN use cases and controller interfaces, which are many. The large number of unique controller APIs indicates that there is no consensus yet on what makes the right NBI (and could also lead one to believe that they are not that hard to write). We will soon publish the first edition of our NBI study, cataloguing and comparing them.

While this proliferation of SDN controllers brings some valuable learning, it also creates confusion for those wanting to write to an NBI. Without stable interfaces to write to, overall adoption of SDN slows, and when we heard concerns from many in the ONF user population, we knew that we had to take action.

The question then became: What action should the ONF take? We have long said that software APIs are not typically standardized in advance by committees, because they don't have to be. Anyone can modify an (open) interface quickly; it's not like redesigning an ASIC. What we as an organization can do is bring clarity to the choices and their benefits, through both investigation and prototyping.

Therefore, ONF took the leap and chartered the NBI Working Group, which is evaluating Northbound Interfaces. Plural. That's an important distinction. The Working Group has already put together a chart showing how broad the topic is. Characterizing the different levels of abstraction as latitudes and the different use cases as longitudes, they starkly demonstrate the futility of imagining there being one, or "the," NBI.

Our first step will be to develop information models for Northbound Interfaces at different latitudes and longitudes with plans to prototype and gain market feedback on select examples. Again, examples -- plural.

What we don't plan to do is rush to a standard. ONF has spoken passionately about standards, and we have committed to standardizing only what is truly necessary. If the industry needs us to help them arrive at a standard for some use case, we will. Prominent among our members' requirements are for the interfaces they write to to be truly open and not vulnerable to the whims of a single vendor. Moreover, we suspect that a small number of NBIs will serve a large fraction of current market needs. Thus, one of the purposes of our NBI Working Group will be to determine if an NBI standard from a committee is needed by the market at this time.

ONF plans to publish its Northbound Interface information models in 2014, accompanied by open-source working code for select use cases. We will also continue to strengthen the OpenFlow substrate to make sure it offers great service to the software and services above the NBI.

As always, user needs remain our only compass.

— Dan Pitt, Executive Director, Open Networking Foundation

(1)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
sam masud
50%
50%
sam masud,
User Rank: Light Sabre
11/6/2013 | 2:33:21 PM
So what now?.
Dan,

Although it makes a lot of sense to have standard NBIs, I'm wondering whether having ONF standardize on the NBIs might slow the down the adoption of SDN. Also, curious as to what you would advise a customer who's considering deploying SDN--should they wait on the ONF's NBIs or go with whatever solutions are out there?

 
More Blogs from Column
PICMG, which develops open modular standards for embedded computing, looks ahead to the next decade.
As it embraces SDN and NFV, the networking industry needs to ensure it doesn't create new silos and repeat the innovation-stifling mistakes of its past.
Give it up for the optical specialists who are more than mere 'plumbers.'
Operators can cut the cost and complexity of extending legacy services to all-IP environments.
Flash Poll
From The Founder
It's clear to me that the communications industry is divided into two types of people, and only one is living in the real world.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Interview With Rick Talbot, Principal Analyst, Current Analysis

10|31|14   |   2:12   |   (0) comments


At the NFV Open Cloud Forum 2014, Rick Talbot shared his positive feedback about the holistic and open approach that Huawei adopts for SDN and NFV. He also found the open sharing at the event valuable as it features different perspectives from Huawei experts, telecom operators, industry analysts as well as security experts.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Interview With David Snow, Principal Analyst, Current Analysis

10|31|14   |   2:24   |   (0) comments


David Snow talked about his understanding of Huawei and its SoftCOM strategy at the NFV Open Cloud Forum 2014, saying that Huawei's wide approach combining IT and CT expertise, introducing big data and analytics into solutions and contributing to the OpenStack community particularly resonate with him and make the company stand out in the industry.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Interview With Roz Roseboro, Senior Analyst, Heavy Reading

10|31|14   |   3:13   |   (0) comments


Roz Roseboro commented on Huawei's data center capabilities and NFV solutions at the NFV Open Cloud Forum 2014, saying that in addition to covering all three key domains of compute, storage and networking, the company also emphasizes the importance of management capabilities and professional services, which are essential in making NFV a reality.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Interview With Michael Howard, Co-founder & Principal Analyst, Infonetics Research

10|31|14   |   5:25   |   (0) comments


Michael Howard talked about SDN, NFV, and OpenStack adoption at Huawei's NFV Open Cloud Forum 2014. Particularly, he pointed out that Virtual Enterprise CPE is the top NFV use case that operators plan to invest in over 2014 and 2015 to deliver new enterprise services through virtualized functions.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Interview With Jerry Caron, Senior Vice President, Current Analysis

10|31|14   |   3:11   |   (0) comments


At Huawei's NFV Open Cloud Forum 2014, Jerry Caron from Current Analysis said that orchestration and management are key to realizing SDN and NFV for global carriers, and the approach that Huawei is taking, with its FusionSphere Cloud OS at the core, is in the right direction to address the challenges.
LRTV Documentaries
Broadband Battles

10|31|14   |   01:39   |   (0) comments


This year's Broadband World Forum featured a number of show floor battles focused on access gear, components and coffee.
Jonestown
Mobile Backhaul: Going to the Dark Side?

10|30|14   |   2:26   |   (1) comment


Heavy Reading's Patrick Donegan shares his view on a dark trend that bubbled up at Light Reading's annual backhaul conference in NYC.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
2014 Huawei Electric Power Industry Summit: Interview With CEO of SwitchCom

10|30|14   |   4:13   |   (0) comments


SwitchCom, an IT company based in Angola, recommends a variety of Huawei solutions and hardware to their customers in the energy industry.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
2014 Huawei Electric Power Industry Summit: Interview With Ethiopia's Ministry of Water Irrigation & Energy

10|30|14   |   4:08   |   (0) comments


Gosaye Mengistie of Ethiopia's Ministry of Water Irrigation & Energy discusses the collaboration with Huawei in that country.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
2014 Huawei Electric Power Industry Summit: Interview with Dongfang Electronics Corporation

10|30|14   |   5:46   |   (0) comments


Dongfang Electronics Corporation, headquartered in Chengdu, China, is one of China's largest manufacturers of power generators and contractors of power station projects.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
2014 Huawei Electric Power Industry Summit: Interview with Zimbabwe's Customers

10|30|14   |   3:31   |   (0) comments


Representatives of Zimbabwe's Ministry of Power and Development discuss the energy needs of their country as well as new areas of improvement due to enhanced ICT capabilities.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
2014 Huawei Electric Power Industry Summit: Interview With Colbún Chile

10|30|14   |   4:29   |   (0) comments


In Chile, an aging energy infrastructure was in dire need of a modern update. Claudio Valenzuela of Colbún discusses how Huawei's ICT solutions continue to provide crucial information to improve the grid and how an in-country engineer is a cricial asset.
Upcoming Live Events
November 6, 2014, Santa Clara
November 11, 2014, Atlanta, GA
December 2, 2014, New York City
December 3, 2014, New York City
December 9-10, 2014, Reykjavik, Iceland
February 10, 2015, Atlanta, GA
May 6, 2015, McCormick Convention Center, Chicago, IL
May 30, 2015, The Westin Peachtree, Atlanta, GA
June 9-10, 2015, Chicago, IL
Infographics
WhoIsHostingThis.com presents six of the world's most extreme WiFi hotspots, enabling the most epic selfies you can imagine.
Hot Topics
Microsoft's Skype Embraces WebRTC on IE
Sarah Reedy, Senior Editor, 10/27/2014
FTC Slaps AT&T With Throttling Lawsuit
Sarah Reedy, Senior Editor, 10/28/2014
Wheeler Gets Down With OTT
Mari Silbey, Independent Technology Editor, 10/29/2014
China's MVNOs Hit the Wall
Robert Clark, 10/27/2014
Let's Not Kill SDN & NFV With Silos
Francois Locoh-Donou, Senior VP, Global Products Group, Ciena, 10/28/2014
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed