Light Reading

Lifting the Cloud Over SDN

Sunil Khandekar
7/21/2014
50%
50%

Software-defined networking (SDN) must be magic. Why else would researchers, educators, vendors, customers -- practically everyone and anyone connected to the networking industry -- be so high on SDN?

The answer, of course, lies in the promise of SDN. After all, isn't it supposed to completely transform networking? Isn't it the innovation that has finally rescued the networking industry after a decade-long drought? And, most importantly, isn't the SDN market forecast to generate tens of billions of dollars -- an estimate being raised every month? (See Defining SDN & NFV.)

The cloud over SDN
Interestingly, everyone has their own definition of SDN and their own take on how it will reshape the networking industry. That's not entirely surprising. The term is broad enough to allow everyone's convenient interpretation to stand. The industry has made progress in moving beyond hype, and customers are now asking how SDN will help them, rather than what SDN is. Nevertheless, there is still a fair amount of confusion, which causes doubt and constricts the real progress that SDN stands to deliver. It is time to lift the cloud over SDN.

Goal
The ultimate goal of an SDN solution is to massively simplify network operations, increase agility, and accelerate deployment of new services without sacrificing security and control.

Definition
The four key tenets of an SDN solution are abstraction, automation, control, and visibility.

SDN bridges the gap between applications and networks to enable the rapid consumption of network services such as bandwidth, QoS, security, firewall, and load balancing by providing visibility and control to the applications. It is about providing abstraction of network capabilities, and it is about the automation of network provisioning. It is about separating what applications need from how the network implements its capabilities.

In order to lift the cloud over SDN, we need to understand how various implementations of "SDN" currently promoted across our industry measure up against these defining characteristics of SDN.

1. Does SDN = OpenFlow?
Discussion of separating the control and data planes took off when the Open Networking Foundation introduced the OpenFlow protocol version 1.1 circa 2011. Normally, the control and forwarding planes are part of the same network switch or router. But the ONF advocated separating and logically centralizing the control plane from the forwarding plane. The forwarding plane would remain part of the network element -- in other words, the switch or router. The ONF introduced OpenFlow as the southbound protocol used by the control plane to program reachability information in the forwarding elements.

Separating the control plane and the forwarding plane was not new. It had been done a decade ago in routers, though both functions still resided in the same physical device. The idea of physically separating the two planes and logically centralizing the control plane is not new, either. It had been already proposed in prior work, such as IETF ForCES initiative. But the industry took note of the revived efforts this time around, and the idea opened up interesting possibilities. Benefits included the ability to conduct control plane upgrades that did not disrupt network forwarding, centralizing the control plane to enable traffic optimizations based on a network-wide view (vs. network-element views), and removing the burden of processor-intensive distributed control protocols from lightweight network elements: virtual switches, CPEs, etc.

However, the overt focus on the separation of the control and forwarding planes and the shiny new OpenFlow protocol diverted attention away from SDN. The separation of the control and forwarding planes created the notion that all forwarding elements could be made simpler and cheaper. It is absolutely true that the networking requirements in campus and data center networks have traditionally not been nearly as stringent as required in the WAN. As a result, the premium attached to these devices have not been justified. The "white-box" discussion that ensued in the industry and drove down the cost of networking devices commensurate with networking requirements has been great for customers. This change has been long overdue. It was tempting for some to apply the same broad brush everywhere and suggest that all networking elements, including WAN core and edge routers, could also be simplified. This caused some confusion in the industry, which has largely settled now.

To be clear, this approach -- separating the control and forwarding planes -- falls short when measured against the four tenets of SDN discussed before. Though it provides control over forwarding elements under the OF controller domain, it does not deliver against the other three tenets: visibility into applications, abstraction of networking capabilities, and network automation.

However, the long-overdue change that caused pricing structures to change in the networking industry is nothing but goodness, and the ONF deservedly gets the credit for this.

2. Does SDN = traffic engineering?
The often-cited case study of Google's SDN implementation for the purpose of traffic engineering the network is certainly interesting. The Google implementation is about computing optimal paths for the network using an offline compute tool and then programming these paths in network elements using OpenFlow. This approach affords Google full control and visibility over the network infrastructure. But it is not the first such implementation, nor is it new by any means.

The (former) MCI network team members must get a chuckle out of this, because they did exactly the same thing 14 years ago. The one difference? They did not use OpenFlow as the southbound protocol. Instead, they used MPLS labels for traffic engineered paths computed with an offline traffic engineering (TE) engine, now called a path computation element (PCE) server, which were programmed using SNMP in their network elements. Yes, this was back in Y2K.

Next: A new approach

(5)  | 
Comment  | 
Print  | 
Page 1 / 2 Next >
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
tdwivedi
50%
50%
tdwivedi,
User Rank: Light Beer
7/22/2014 | 8:45:09 PM
SDN
Thanks Sunil for distilling the buzzword into clear capabilities and characteristics.

I think the network is following the demands of the server and storage virtulization in the data center/enterprise and is responding to the economy of scale from the cloud computing.

I liked how you net the final goal of the network to be the "application delivery" with the abstraction of what from how, provisoning the network based on the application characteristics, and the visibility and control of the (App) delivery.

I see the similarities on OpenFlow with the other standards (and initiatives) and its possible fate (example SMI-S by SNIA from storage side of the world), as I see ONF has added conformance testing and vendor extenstions which reminds me of how fragmented the storage industry was in adopting the standards and the high expectation from customers and sysemintegrators. 

For reference http://snia.org/ I can't even find the SMi-S links now on the site. I wonder how is OpenFlow different from the other standards to lead a better outcome.

 

 

 

 
SunilKhandekar
50%
50%
SunilKhandekar,
User Rank: Blogger
7/22/2014 | 12:08:32 PM
Re: Let's not forget the business angle..
Thanks Steve.  

Couldn't agree more on the business benefits.  Indeed, massively simplying operations translates to OPEX savings, increasing agility and quicker TTM translates to capitalizing on opportunity, flexibility in the network infrastructure translates to CAPEX savings. 

Yes, my focus in the article is on the network and how to it is made consumable by SDN for applications running on top.  The applications running on top certainly are important on how they are architected for deployment and deliver efficiency and automation at that layer.
SunilKhandekar
50%
50%
SunilKhandekar,
User Rank: Blogger
7/22/2014 | 11:56:45 AM
Re: Bit quick to dismiss multi-vendor OSS
Definitely Ray - to the extent multi-vendor EMS helps right now to manage the existing mult-vendor networks, this is only goodness.  Was simply keeping focus on what SDN ultimately stands to deliver.
Steve Hateley
50%
50%
Steve Hateley,
User Rank: Light Beer
7/22/2014 | 9:28:26 AM
Let's not forget the business angle..
Great article Sunil.

From the Nuage position, your observations are good and well captured however I sense that there is still understandably an air of hardware vendor, "from the network up" perspective. But if the aim is to give an unbiased view on what SDN means to the industry across the board we should be throwing in the all-important business perspective. 

"The ultimate goal of an SDN solution is to massively simplify network operations, increase agility, and accelerate deployment of new services without sacrificing security and control."

Increasing agility (to build, configure and create new market-facing services) and accelerating deployment (shortening the time from lead-to-activate) are two goals that translate well into the concept of simplifying business automation. This requires a holistic ability to not only understand virtual networks and virtualised services, but to properly orchestrate their delivery from the sales process right through to the VNF manager and virtual machines. In many cases this sales automation is now driven from SaaS/Cloud based applications.

New startups with lightweight provisioning tools are a small part of the fully automated process, and provisioning is only one capability of the traditional EMS. In fact comprehensive orchestration needs to encompass technical catalog abstraction of available resources and logical services. In turn this is dependant upon a federated inventory perspective that reigns in not only the virtual resources but also logical and physical connectivity necessary to "connect" the cloud. Then of course there is "provisioning" but we mustn't forget the logical ordering of the necessary processes to activate requested services. So provisioning is just a cog in a larger machine.

SDN certainly brings an evolutionary change that impacts network vendors, CSPs, ISVs and customers all in one go - something that previous service and infrastructure enhancements have never fully done. Importantly though it's not just a network vendor play. To make it a success, NEMs, ISVs and CSPs need to find common ground and make it work. 

Best regards, Steve

 

 

 
Ray@LR
100%
0%
Ray@LR,
User Rank: Blogger
7/22/2014 | 3:32:52 AM
Bit quick to dismiss multi-vendor OSS
Good article Sunil, though I have to point out a slight tension in your argument.

 

You state early on that:

'The industry has made progress in moving beyond hype, and customers are now asking how SDN will help them...'

Indeed -- network operators want to know how SDN, and indeed ANY technology or strategy, will help them perform better, provide a better service and make (more/any) money.

 

Then later, when discussing 'next-generation element management systems', you rightly allude to the fact that a next-gen EMS does not equal SDN (and I think we all know who you're referring to here...) you state:

'Does [a multi-vendor EMS] provide business agility? Not really. At best, it enhances the present mode of operations, to an extent.'

I think there's a good argument that any multi-vendor EMS that works NOW and is also relevant to future network evolutionaryy developments is providing operational and business agility -- after all, the operators want to know HOW any technology can help them, and for most telcos SDN is something they are looking at for the future, whereas a multi-vendor EMS is something that can help them right now.

A multi-vendor EMS does not = SDN, but it can sure make a difference to companies struggling to maximize efficiencies and meet customer demands, something that an SDN implementation cannot do for them with such immediate impact.

So - I am not saying an EMS = SDN, or that SDN isn't going to transform networking, I'm just highlighting that you've maybe been a bit quick to dismiss something that COULD provide great value AND act as a stepping stone towards a virtualization strategy just because it doesn't tick your SDN boxes.  

 
More Blogs from Column
Bigger. And Better. But definitely bigger.
When trying to develop innovative technologies, engineers must be willing to take risks, make mistakes and move ahead incrementally without having all the data.
Mobile network operators have the network and a business model that makes them well suited to lead the charge as the Internet of Things (IoT) takes off.
Gathering useful information for real-time management of Ethernet and IP networks is a non-trivial issue.
There are three important questions service providers need to address for in-market and out-of-market expansion.
Flash Poll
From The Founder
The New IP is actually bigger even than business. Like another hugely important tech that Light Reading is digging into right now, the New IP has the potential to change the world by fundamentally advancing what it is possible for people to achieve with communications.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei Shares Its Vision of the Future of Mobile Networks Innovations

2|26|15   |   2:30   |   (0) comments


Mobile broadband is changing our lives. It's reshaping the Internet, industry, and society. It allows us to freely connect with one another anytime, anywhere. At this year's Mobile World Congress, Huawei will share its latest insights and newest ideas and technologies that will shape the future of MBB. They will showcase their end-to-end MBB solutions that will ...
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Accelerate Digitizing, Boost Digital Business

2|26|15   |   6:14   |   (0) comments


A new digital revolution is leading us to a better connected world. Together with millions of digital partners, Huawei will help CSPs to build their digital service ecosystem and aggregate a wide variety of digital services. In this video, we find out how Huawei is going to help CSPs implement digital operations.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
The Secret Recipe to Enabling Hyper-Growth Industries

2|26|15   |   3:38   |   (0) comments


With a number of successful cases on network capability exposure, Huawei is going to share the secret recipe to enabling hyper-growth markets with a step-by-step approach.
LRTV Documentaries
BTE 2015 Is Bigger & Even Better

2|25|15   |   03:13   |   (4) comments


This year's Big Telecom Event (BTE) in Chicago is going to provide more opportunities than ever for networking, getting to grips with key industry challenges and opportunities and, equally as important, having some fun.
LRTV Interviews
Light Reading ICT Leaders Roundtable at MWC 2015

2|12|15   |   1:07   |   (2) comments


On Sunday March 1, 2015, Light Reading will host an ICT Leaders Roundtable in partnership with Huawei. At this half-day event, CIOs, analysts and researchers will discuss key industry trends like virtualization in the cloud with a specific focus on new business models. Located at the luxurious Renaissance Hotel near the Fira Barcelona, space is limited so please ...
LRTV Documentaries
Going Green in 2015

2|12|15   |   02:04   |   (0) comments


Energy efficiency is set to be an incredibly hot topic in the telecom industry this year.
LRTV Custom TV
SDN & NFV: Where Are We Going From Here?

2|11|15   |   11:27   |   (0) comments


Vitesse Semiconductor CTO Martin Nuss gives his perspective on why SDN and NFV should be tightly interconnected and how he sees the industry moving forward.
LRTV Documentaries
Time for Gigabit Europe?

2|9|15   |   01:27   |   (4) comments


Gigabit broadband networks are springing up all around the US and they'll soon become more commonplace in Europe.
LRTV Interviews
Brocade Brings New IP Vision to 2020 Vision Executive Summit

2|3|15   |   4:23   |   (0) comments


In December 2014, Light Reading gathered telecom executives in Reykjavik, Iceland to discuss their vision for high-capacity networks through the end of the decade. The intimate, interactive meeting was set against the backdrop of Iceland's spectacular natural beauty. As one of the event's founding sponsors, Brocade's Kelly Herrell shared his company's strategy at ...
LRTV Interviews
Brocade's Kelly Herrell on the New IP

2|2|15   |   12:36   |   (0) comments


In December 2014, Steve Saunders sat down with Brocade VP of Software Networking Kelly Herrell at Light Reading's 2020 Vision executive summit in Reykjavik, Iceland. They spoke about Brocade's approach to the New IP, the future of the telecom industry, and more.
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Dr. Dong Sun Talks About Carriers' Digital Transformation & Huawei’s Telco OS

1|29|15   |   6:28   |   (0) comments


Dr. Dong Sun, Chief Architect of Digital Transformation Solutions at Huawei, discusses how telecom operators can become digital ecosystem enablers and deliver optimal user experiences that are in real-time, on-demand, all-online, DIY and social (ROADS).
LRTV Huawei Video Resource Center
Huawei's Chief Network Architect Talks about Network Experience & Operators’ Strategies

1|29|15   |   3:39   |   (0) comments


In the digital age, network experience has become the primary productivity especially for telecom operators. In this video, Wenshuan Dang, Huawei’s Chief Network Architect, discusses how carriers can tackle the challenge of infrastructure complexity in order to enhance business agility and improve user experience.
Upcoming Live Events
March 17, 2015, The Cable Center, Denver, CO
April 14, 2015, The Westin Times Square, New York City, NY
May 12, 2015, Grand Hyatt, Denver, CO
May 13-14, 2015, The Westin Peachtree, Atlanta, GA
June 8, 2015, Chicago, IL
June 9-10, 2015, Chicago, IL
June 9, 2015, Chicago, IL
June 10, 2015, Chicago, IL
All Upcoming Live Events
Infographics
Net neutrality, broadband services and the current outlook on data consumption, as presented by the New Jersey Institute of Technology.
Hot Topics
Cyber Security Expert Warns: You're Doing It Wrong
Sarah Thomas, Editorial Operations Director, 2/23/2015
10 Weirdly Useful IoT Devices
Eryn Leavens, Copy Desk Editor, 2/24/2015
Small Cells Enabling Location Services
Sarah Thomas, Editorial Operations Director, 2/25/2015
Is FCC Weighing Net Neutrality Changes?
Mari Silbey, Independent Technology Editor, 2/25/2015
MWC: Let the Madness Begin
Ray Le Maistre, Editor-in-chief, 2/23/2015
Like Us on Facebook
Twitter Feed
Webinar Archive
BETWEEN THE CEOs - Executive Interviews
Check out Light Reading's interview with Jay Samit, the newly appointed CEO of publicly traded SeaChange International Inc. With a resume that includes Sony, EMI, and Universal, Samit brings a reputation as an entrepreneur and a disruptor to his new role at the video solutions company. Hear what he had to say about the opportunities in video, as well as the outlook for cable, telco, OTT and mobile service providers.
G'day! And welcome to an entirely new feature on Light Reading -- our weekly "CEO-to-CEO" interview.