BelkBlog
Jeff Belk

iPhone Myopia & Google Android Euphoria

September 25, 2008 | Jeff Belk | Comments (2)
no ratings

3:55 PM -- First of all, I want to reiterate, both the new 3G iPhone and Google (Nasdaq: GOOG)’s Android are great additions to the wireless world, and represent sort of the O’Reilly and the Olbermann of wireless perspectives, although I’m not sure which is left or right, but one’s "open" and one’s "closed." (See Open=Beta? and Does Apple Bite?)

Both will push the wireless envelope, but now that both devices/platforms are launched, the hype around both needs a bit of caution. (See Slideshow: Switching On Android.)

Last week I spoke at a wireless conference in San Francisco, attended mainly by Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, venture capitalists, wireless execs, and journalists/bloggers/pundits. Great conference, but one of the things that stuck out for me was a question a panelist asked the audience: “How many people in the audience own an iPhone?” About 30 to 40 percent of the crowd raised their hands. Looking around at the tables for folks with laptops, probably close to half of the laptops were MacBooks and MacBook Pros. Remember, guys, I’m a Mac fan -- I have a bunch and own Apple stock -- but this is not the world.

One recent article has Apple selling 5 million iPhones this quarter, while another has Apple selling 40 million iPhones globally in 2009. This out of a global market for 1.2 BILLION (40,000,000 vs. 1,200,000,000) phones. A great start, but not game over. The Apple Apps store, in my opinion as a iPod Touch owner playing with the Apps Store (see Apple, Operator War Averted (for now)), is that the store is one of the greatest collections of maybe great beta apps around. But it’s not game over.

On the other side of the fence, kudos to Google for launching Android as the T-Mobile USA G1. Android, like the iPhone, was the subject of untold panels at the conference, and the topic of a great talk by a guy from Google. I have not had a chance to play with one yet, but for all the hoopla around "open," there is a lot of “same old, same old” for me: $179 price point, "subject to credit approval; two-year service agreement, qualifying rate plan, and data plan required.” Nothing new there. Several reports stated that that the $25 data plan will be capped at 1GB per month. I could not find that clause (I saw it on third-party sites, so it may have been pulled), but T-Mo does say: “To provide the best network experience for all of our customers we may temporarily reduce data throughput for a small fraction of customers who use a disproportionate amount of bandwidth."

And with "yet another new hardware platform” (YANHP?), we’re possibly looking at headaches after launch, especially with an operator like T-Mobile that is relatively new to 3G, as well as yet another platform for apps to come to market, which in my view is a dual-edged sword, as I really hate being a beta tester. Like my comments on the 3G iPhone, time will heal all wounds (or beta app headaches), but it takes time.

So, in the past month, we’ve seen the game change from both sides. Both platforms have pushed the ecosystem and both will continue to push wireless, but in my view, it’s a billion unit plus per year market, and a myopic focus on “Apple Wins” or a euphoric belief that “Android Wins” misses the point. The point is we all win, the folks in 2009 that buy the 50 million iPhones and Androids, as well as the 1.15 billion that buy stuff from Nokia Corp. (NYSE: NOK), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. (Korea: SEC), LG Electronics Inc. (London: LGLD; Korea: 6657.KS) , Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications , Research In Motion Ltd. (RIM) (Nasdaq: RIMM; Toronto: RIM), High Tech Computer Corp. (HTC) (Taiwan: 2498), and others. The pace of innovation is quickening, and from a lot of directions.

— Jeff Belk is a principal at ICT168 Capital LLC, focused on developing and guiding global growth opportunities in the Information and Communication Technology space. He can be reached at jeffrey.belk@gmail.com. Special to Unstrung

Light Reading Mobile Newsletter Ad
Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
IPobserver
User Ranking
Monday September 29, 2008 9:57:42 AM
no ratings
Good point. My main 3G connection here in the UK is with T-Mobile.

It’s inexpensive and performance is great. It helps that I live 200-odd meters from the tower. (Slightly worrying, too)
jkbelk
User Ranking
Thursday September 25, 2008 6:58:05 PM
no ratings
T-Mo and 3G: They've got a ton of 3G globally, and tons of experience in Europe, but they are the newbie to 3G in the U.S.!
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Light Reading. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
More BelkBlog
Return of the Suits
3:50 PM -- Hope you remember how to tie a Double Windsor!
Part II: Cash, Pain & 20%
12:40 PM -- Putting a percentage on cuts and personal reevaluation
Log On, Tune In & Connect (Or Drop Out)
6:00 PM -- A tale of two tails at CES
Nintendo Hell
6:00 PM -- A cautionary tale
Fighting the Last War
NOON -- The WiMax talking points are behind the times
Stoke Ad
Events
Green Broadband 2010
Tuesday, September 21, 2010
The Westin Times Square, New York City
Service Provider IT Global Event Series: The 360-Degree Customer Experience
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
The Cumberland Hotel, London
Ethernet Expo
Tuesday & Wednesday, November 2 & 3, 2010
Hilton New York, New York
TelcoTV Conference & Expo
November 9 – 11, 2010
Las Vegas
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Resource Library SPONSORED CONTENT
A Platform Approach to Mobile Unified Communications - by BlackBerry Presenters: John Cash, Enterprise Solution Advocate, BlackBerry Overview: BlackBerry Mobile ...
Ground-breaking test of service quality at 100Gbps - by Ixia Presenters: Rajiv Paoneja, Director, Isocore; Houman Modarres, Director of Product Marketing, ...
Analyst Q&A Webinar: How your billing system can keep up with organizational changes - not yours, but your customer's! - by MetraTech Corp. Presenters: Dan Baker, Principal Market synthesizer and Co-Founder, Technology Research ...
Evolve Your Network - Simpler, Smarter, Faster - by Alcatel-Lucent Presenters: Salvador Lopez, Senior Manager, Optical Business Development-Solutions and ...
Chalk Pushcast Software Webcast: Media Rich Training and Compliance Communications on BlackBerry Smartphones - by BlackBerry Presenters: Jody Glidden, Director, Chalk Media Overview: More and more, workforces are ...
IT Best Practices Webcast: Mobile Policies and Processes for Employee-owned smartphones - by BlackBerry Presenters: Mark Keating, Director - Platform Marketing, Research In Motion; Maribel Lopez, ...
On-Demand Webinar: Introducing BlackBerry Enterprise Server Express: Mobility for your Business Presenter: Erin Ransom, Sr. Product Marketing Manager, Research In Motion Overview: Learn how ...
On-Demand Webinar: BlackBerry Enterprise Server Express for the Small-to-Medium Sized Business Presenter: Shabbir Lasani, Product Marketing Manager - Small and Medium Business, Research In ...
On-Demand Webinar: Deploying BlackBerry Enterprise Server Express Presenter: Ajay Malhan, Technical Account Manager - IT Channel, Research In Motion Overview: ...
Companies
Alcatel-Lucent (6359), AT&T (3267), BellSouth (851), BT (1406), Cablevision (759), Cisco (6467), Comcast (2360), Cox Communications (1021), Deutsche Telekom (894), eBay (Skype) (360), Ericsson (2075), France Telecom (1060), Google (1102), Huawei (1425), Intel (1862), Juniper (2260), Microsoft (1731), Motorola (3153), Nokia Siemens Networks (2856), Nortel (4047), NTT (207), Siemens (1362), Sprint (2143), Telefonica (596), Time Warner Cable (1140), Verizon (3885), Vodafone (1888), Yahoo (354)

4G/LTE
3G Evolution (398), Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (270), Carrier WiFi (2770), CDMA (3G) (3866), China Mobile (81), Core Network (852), EV-DO (295), Femtocells (615), Fixed Wireless (Microwave, etc.) (147), Fourth Generation (4G) Wireless (256), GSM/EDGE (2555), HSDPA/HSUPA (880), IMS Core (136), Long-Term Evolution (LTE) (1461), Messaging (334), Messaging (150), Mobile Advertising (205), Mobile location (117), Mobile Music (171), Mobile TV (342), Mobile Video (372), Mobile WiMax/WiBro (2153), Mobile/Wireless (7221), Municipal networks (115), Packet Core (191), Presence management (51), Radio Access Network (2962), Services (2825), TD-SCDMA (Chinese 3G) (152), Transmission (119), Ultra-Mobile Broadband (UMB) (84), UMTS(3G) (520), Video services (4534), Videophone (205), Vodafone (1888), Voice Core (103), VOIP software (747), WiMax (1232), Wireless Backhaul (601), Wireless LAN (394)

Broadband
Access devices (306), Access equipment (2312), Access technologies (2465), Access test & measurement equipment (133), Broadband loop carriers / multiservice access nodes (425), Cable Modems (846), Carrier WiFi (2770), Content/software downloads (254), Docsis (1349), DSL (2700), DSL chips (249), DSLAMs (713), Ethernet PONs (176), Femtocells (615), Free-space optics (40), FTTx (4185), Home gateways (722), Internet Video (1288), IPTV (3800), Media adapters (30), Microsoft (1731), PON (1610), Satellite (588), Video services (4534), VOD (3056), Yahoo (354)

Cable
Access equipment (2312), Access technologies (2465), Broadcast video equipment (including encoding) (809), Cable modem termination systems (CMTSs) (1220), Cable Modems (846), Cable/MSO equipment (2912), CableLabs (595), Cablevision (759), Comcast (2360), Compression (MPEG-2 and MPEG-4) (323), Cox Communications (1021), Digital content (1409), Digital rights management (425), Docsis (1349), DVRs (869), Embedded multimedia terminal adapters (E-MTAs) (259), FTTx (4185), Gaming consoles (84), Head-ends (273), Home gateways (722), IPTV (3800), Media adapters (30), Middleware & business support systems (1077), Network DVR (135), PacketCable (142), PON (1610), QAM (367), Residential (880), Set-top boxes (1971), Stored video servers (425), Time Warner Cable (1140), TV (4486), Video equipment (2614), Video services (4534), Video software (1519), VOD (3056), VOIP services (3961), Wavelength services (342)

Ethernet
10-Gbit/s Ethernet switches (1491), 100-Gbit/s Ethernet (374), Access devices (306), Ciena (102), Circuit emulation (19), Converged access (133), Ethernet chips (619), Ethernet equipment (2454), Ethernet over copper (252), Ethernet PONs (176), Ethernet services (2115), Ethernet technologies (641), Ethernet test & measurement equipment (197), Multipoint (167), Multiservice edge equipment (156), Multiservice provisioning platforms (632), Multiservice provisioning platforms & add/drop muxes (384), PBT (Provider Backbone Transport) (275), Point-to-point (183), Powerline (94), Resilient Packet Ring (175), Sonet/SDH (1067), Tellabs (32), Wireless Backhaul (601)

IP & Convergence
Activation (442), Anti-virus (39), B-RASs (236), Billing systems (866), Cell/WLAN (86), Centrex (205), Circuit emulation (19), Conferencing (160), Contact centers (39), Content delivery network (CDN) (453), Content/software downloads (254), Converged access (133), Core Network (852), Customer relationship management (375), Data Integrity (165), Denial-of-service attacks (67), Edge routers (1789), Element management systems (109), Encryption (176), Endpoint security (100), Enhanced voice (106), Enterprise (683), Fault management (147), Firewalls (138), Fixed/Mobile Convergence (848), GMPLS (80), IMS (1164), IMS Core (136), Interactive advertising (306), Internet Video (1288), Intrusion detection & prevention (123), Inventory management (239), IP equipment (1338), IP software (423), IPSec VPN (867), Layer 3 VPNs (236), Media gateways (387), Mediation systems (283), Messaging (150), Middleware (145), Mobile/Wireless (7221), MPLS (1832), Multicast (41), OSS (3582), OSS test & measurement (1155), Performance monitoring (469), Planning tools (113), Policy control (403), Presence management (51), Product Management (106), Provisioning (669), Pseudowire (Layer 2 tunnels) (134), QOS (366), Residential (880), Revenue assurance & fraud management (429), Security (2005), Service delivery platforms (SDPs) (388), Service management (341), Service-oriented architectures (351), Services (2825), Session border controllers (428), Signaling gateways (123), SIP (433), Softswitches (1135), SSL VPN (931), Telepresence (247), Traffic managers (870), URL filtering (82), User authentication (99), Video services (4534), Videophone (205), VOIP equipment (3539), VOIP services (3961), VOIP software (747), VOIP test & measurement equipment (150), VOIP VPNs (33), Web services (155), Wholesale (242), Wireless LAN (394), Wireline/Wireless (74), XML (54)

Mobile Backhaul
10-Gbit/s Ethernet switches (1491), 100-Gbit/s Ethernet (374), Access devices (306), Cell/WLAN (86), China Mobile (81), Circuit emulation (19), Converged access (133), Core Network (852), Ethernet equipment (2454), Ethernet over copper (252), Ethernet PONs (176), Ethernet services (2115), Ethernet technologies (641), Fixed Wireless (Microwave, etc.) (147), Fixed/Mobile Convergence (848), Fourth Generation (4G) Wireless (256), IMS (1164), IMS Core (136), Mobile/Wireless (7221), Optical amplifiers (357), Packet Core (191), Point-to-point (183), QOS (366), Speciality fiber (106), Tellabs (32), Transceivers (1318), Transmission (119), Transmission fiber (426), Vodafone (1888), Voice Core (103), Wavelength services (342), WiMax (1232), Wireless Backhaul (601), Wireless LAN (394), Wireline/Wireless (74)

Optical Networking (Sponsored by TeraXion)
40-Gbit/s transmission (509), Alcatel-Lucent (6359), ATM switches (336), Core optical switches (780), CWDM (297), DWDM (1890), Ethernet technologies (641), Huawei (1425), Long-haul WDM equipment (737), Metro optical switches, ROADMs (1253), Metro WDM equipment (835), Multiservice edge equipment (156), Multiservice provisioning platforms (632), Multiservice provisioning platforms & add/drop muxes (384), Multiservice switches (405), Mux/demuxes (304), Optical amplifiers (357), Optical channel monitors (96), Optical components (2931), Optical components test & measurement equipment (127), Optical equipment (2451), Optical switches & crossconnects (409), Optical technologies (461), Optical test & measurement equipment (916), PBT (Provider Backbone Transport) (275), PON (1610), Resilient Packet Ring (175), Sonet/SDH (1067), Sonet/SDH chips (367), Sonet/SDH test & measurement equipment (1604), Switches & OADMs (433), Transmission fiber (426), Variable optical attenuators (143), Wavelength services (342)

Service Provider IT
Activation (442), Anti-virus (39), Application servers (210), Billing systems (866), Carrier managed (203), Cloud computing (302), Content/software downloads (254), Customer relationship management (375), Data Integrity (165), Denial-of-service attacks (67), Digital content (1409), Element management systems (109), Encryption (176), Endpoint security (100), Fault management (147), Firewalls (138), Grid networking (96), IMS (1164), IMS Control Layer (41), IMS Service Layer (44), Interactive advertising (306), Intrusion detection & prevention (123), Inventory management (239), IP software (423), IP technologies (1544), IPSec VPN (867), Managed Services (136), Media gateways (387), Mediation systems (283), Messaging (334), Middleware (145), MPLS (1832), MPLS (700), OSS (3582), OSS test & measurement (1155), Performance monitoring (469), Planning tools (113), Policy control (403), Product Management (106), Provisioning (669), QOS (366), Revenue assurance & fraud management (429), Security (2005), Service delivery platforms (SDPs) (388), Service management (341), Service-oriented architectures (351), Services (2825), SSL VPN (931), Telepresence (247), URL filtering (82), User authentication (99), Vendor managed (131), Web gateways (71), Web services (155), XML (54)

Video (Sponsored by Cisco)
Broadcast (Mobile TV, etc.) (270), Broadcast video equipment (including encoding) (809), Cable TV chips (356), Compression (MPEG-2 and MPEG-4) (323), Content protection (411), Digital rights management (425), DVRs (869), Gaming consoles (84), Internet Video (1288), IPTV (3800), Middleware & business support systems (1077), Mobile TV (342), Network DVR (135), P2P (278), Satellite (588), Set-top boxes (1971), Stored video servers (425), Telepresence (247), TV (4486), Video equipment (2614), Video services (4534), Video software (1519), Videophone (205), VOD (3056)

Enabling People and Organizations to Harness the Transformative Power of Technology